Latest Breaking News

TomDaisy

(2,120 posts)

1. by killing a lot of innocent people

Reply to WiseElder (Original post)

Sun Jun 9, 2024, 07:14 PM

Jun 2024

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

3 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

AloeVera canuckledragger Merlot

53 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

How Israel Pulled Off a High-Risk Hostage Rescue [View all] WiseElder Jun 2024 OP

by killing a lot of innocent people TomDaisy Jun 2024 #1

Are you saying that the hostages shouldn't have been rescued? orange jar Jun 2024 #2

That's exactly what he/she is saying. nt MarineCombatEngineer Jun 2024 #4

People seem to forget that the hostages are innocent people, too. orange jar Jun 2024 #5

People seem to forget that killing children is a war crime no matter who does it TomDaisy Jun 2024 #13

I agree. orange jar Jun 2024 #14

Collective Punishment - also a war crime. TomDaisy Jun 2024 #16

Indeed, the war crime of taking hostages is also the war crime of collective punishment. Beastly Boy Jun 2024 #21

Does deliberating slaughtering and/or raping thucythucy Jun 2024 #30

And, Once Again.... The Magistrate Jun 2024 #19

It's a war crime if done on purpose, yes. Accidentally not so much EX500rider Jun 2024 #42

And why was HAMAs holding hostages in a residential apartment? MarineCombatEngineer Jun 2024 #3

Hamas holding hostages in a civilian area Mysterian Jun 2024 #6

Any chance you will acknowledge sarisataka Jun 2024 #8

Plus killing Hamas terrorists. Looks like wnylib Jun 2024 #9

Yeah, Hamas shouldn't have opened fire mcar Jun 2024 #15

By killing a lot of Hamas terrorists. Beastly Boy Jun 2024 #20

In certain circles sarisataka Jun 2024 #23

It sounds like at least some of the Palestinian casualties sarisataka Jun 2024 #7

"Sounds like?" That's a damned weak supposition. Sounds like a refugee camp suffered hundreds of deaths in Martin68 Jun 2024 #11

Does Hamas have unique weapons sarisataka Jun 2024 #12

Well, we already know Israel has no such weapons, but they do have weapons that are 10,000 times more devastating than Martin68 Jun 2024 #24

Not for lack of trying sarisataka Jun 2024 #25

Okay atreides1 Jun 2024 #28

Agreed sarisataka Jun 2024 #29

Which means the Israeli response is highly disproportionate. Martin68 Jun 2024 #32

What would be your idea of a proportionate response to abducting, raping and killing hostages? Beastly Boy Jun 2024 #34

Carry out a ground operation to locate and exterminate Hamas. That would require the death of more Israeli soldiers, but Martin68 Jun 2024 #39

How do you locate an estimated 15,000 militants hiding underground among civilians? Beastly Boy Jun 2024 #40

It is not insanity, it is anti-terrorism. It involves loss of life on both sides, But it is far better than bombing Martin68 Jun 2024 #41

What is your background in anti-terrorism? Beastly Boy Jun 2024 #47

The IDF HAS been carrying out a ground operation to locate and exterminate Hamas. EX500rider Jun 2024 #43

My point is that the threat is an empty one. Hamas does not have the ability or power to eradicate Israel. Using that Martin68 Jun 2024 #31

Let's see if you can take your premise to its logical conclusion. Beastly Boy Jun 2024 #35

It sure looks to me like Israel has eradicated Gaza. Have you seen photos of the destruction? How many Israelis has Martin68 Jun 2024 #38

If Israel eradicated Gaza, who is holding the hostages? Who is shooting at Israeli soldiers? Beastly Boy Jun 2024 #46

I do not view it as empty nor sarisataka Jun 2024 #37

The WSJ. MAGA mouthpiece. Martin68 Jun 2024 #10

The WaPo had a similar article. Are they also a MAGA mouthpiece? LeftInTX Jun 2024 #49

In an ideal world . . . Aussie105 Jun 2024 #17

I'm going to follow Benny Ganz's next move. SleeplessinSoCal Jun 2024 #18

Its great that 4 hostages were rescued Bayard Jun 2024 #22

This isn't Hollywood. RandySF Jun 2024 #27

I agree. But I'm curious to know: thucythucy Jun 2024 #33

Almost 20,000 French civilians were killed in the lead up to D-day EX500rider Jun 2024 #44

The Washington Post is still saying 274...Hamas tried to kill the hostages after they had been rescued. LeftInTX Jun 2024 #50

Good work. RandySF Jun 2024 #26

K & R Excellent news rollin74 Jun 2024 #36

So now we have a value equivalence of human lives. Aussie105 Jun 2024 #45

Too many act as if Israeli lives aren't worth shit. RandySF Jun 2024 #51

Too many act as if Palestinian lives aren't worth shit. Aussie105 Jun 2024 #52

If Israelis feel about Oct 7th how I felt about 9/11, then every Hamas shitbag should be neutralized according to them. SoFlaBro Jun 2024 #48

Israeli agents went in undercover disguised as Gazan's EX500rider Jun 2024 #53