Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Wiz Imp

(10,931 posts)
39. Please stop. The unemployment data being released is accurate.
Sun Sep 28, 2025, 03:04 PM
Sep 2025

As someone extremely familiar with the process (I'm a recently retired career government statistician), I'm going to copy the summary from Google's AI overview. In this case, I can attest to it being completely accurate. This overview summarizes it more clearly and succinctly than I could do myself.

The commissioner of the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) does not even see the jobs numbers before they are finalized. The process is intentionally designed to keep the commissioner, who is a political appointee, at arm's length from the data collection and estimation process to protect the integrity of the statistics.

Key details about the process:

Final numbers are locked in The commissioner is typically briefed on the final numbers on the Wednesday afternoon before the public release on Friday. By this point, the data is prepared, finalized, and locked into the system.

No role in estimation The commissioner plays no role in estimating or manipulating the figures. Their involvement is limited to reviewing the accompanying narrative for the public release, not altering the underlying data.

Internal safeguards The BLS maintains a strong culture of independence and has systems in place to prevent any single person, including the commissioner, from interfering with the data. Former commissioners have stated it would be impossible to manipulate the data without being detected, which would likely trigger whistleblowers and resignations.

Career staff handles data The numbers are collected and processed by nonpartisan career civil servants who have no connection to the political administration.

These safeguards came under scrutiny in August 2025 when then-President Donald Trump fired Commissioner Erika McEntarfer after a weak jobs report and baselessly alleged the numbers were "rigged". However, multiple former BLS officials, including those appointed by Trump, rejected the idea that the commissioner could manipulate the data.

Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

What we are witnessing is the systematic destruction of America. Doodley Sep 2025 #1
Agree. It is deliberate and hateful, but we have become a country of hate. Lonestarblue Sep 2025 #2
This is the culmination of an entire history of hate... ananda Sep 2025 #4
Yes we thought we had eradicated the cancer with the Civil War. Irish_Dem Sep 2025 #29
I thought we had it with Civil Rights. ananda Sep 2025 #34
And women's rights, ecology, etc. Irish_Dem Sep 2025 #37
Unfortunately, there seems to be no low that is too low for this country mdbl Sep 2025 #46
Burning America to the Ground has always been "their goal." Botany Sep 2025 #12
Not just Trump and Putin, but the entire array of right-wing bolsheviks lined up behind him JHB Sep 2025 #21
"They" are planning on and working for the deaths of millions worldwide. Botany Sep 2025 #31
You're not wrong. ananda Sep 2025 #35
Watch them produce a crisis to give Trump & company more power and make crypto the coin of the realm Botany Sep 2025 #41
Yup. Choir here. ananda Sep 2025 #44
It looks that way, and if you look at the leadership in each government department, they want to dismantle it. Doodley Sep 2025 #32
For eight months ? Yeah, right ! Watch them cut people off after the first check, saying it''s wasteful. nt eppur_se_muova Sep 2025 #3
Sadly, you make a good point. taxi Sep 2025 #5
It has already been underway at least four months with no such cut offs. . . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Sep 2025 #8
It's difficult to imagine HOW Safe as Milk Sep 2025 #20
I don't think they will cancel, but voter suppression is underway: women's "maiden" names and gerrymandering. nt Bernardo de La Paz Sep 2025 #28
And GSA is hiring back many in the first wave underpants Sep 2025 #27
So far it's worked as promised. COL Mustard Sep 2025 #11
Yep SickOfTheOnePct Sep 2025 #23
Congratulations! COL Mustard Sep 2025 #25
Thank you! n/t SickOfTheOnePct Sep 2025 #26
Huh? The people they're talking about took the deferred resignation option Wiz Imp Sep 2025 #36
Vought..."We want the bureaucrats to be traumatically affected" Leghorn21 Sep 2025 #6
I want Russell Vought to be traumatically INfected Seinan Sensei Sep 2025 #17
It's about abuse. This guy is a sadist. tetedur Sep 2025 #19
I guess not even Bessent can convince tRump that unemployment is not getting better. Bernardo de La Paz Sep 2025 #7
When EVERYTHIG falls apart Mossfern Sep 2025 #9
There are several groups of federal employees popsdenver Sep 2025 #18
If someone took the first DRP they could have left in March COL Mustard Sep 2025 #10
My retirement date is 30 Sep... SickOfTheOnePct Sep 2025 #24
Talk about waste fraud and abuse? Wiz Imp Sep 2025 #38
Yup. It's a total waste of resources. COL Mustard Sep 2025 #48
America's enemies love this systematic screwing of Americans IronLionZion Sep 2025 #13
They are destroying the US without firing a shot. Irish_Dem Sep 2025 #30
I seriously doubt the actual unemployment numbers will make their way into reports. Buddyzbuddy Sep 2025 #14
Such reports never really impress people until they're one of the statistics themselves. nt Trueblue Texan Sep 2025 #16
False unemployment numbers wouldn't be about the direct impact on people. Buddyzbuddy Sep 2025 #51
Please stop. The unemployment data being released is accurate. Wiz Imp Sep 2025 #39
That sounds like a very weak barrier, tbh. nt intrepidity Sep 2025 #42
🙄So All of the past BLS Commissioners are lying or stupid? Got it. Wiz Imp Sep 2025 #54
No, no, no intrepidity Sep 2025 #56
I love that you believe the reports can't be manipulated. Buddyzbuddy Sep 2025 #50
🙄I wrote a long response but decided to erase it because you're not worth it. Wiz Imp Sep 2025 #52
None of what I said was personal but ok. Buddyzbuddy Sep 2025 #58
So many words to say absolutely nothing other than to insult me (intentionally or not) Wiz Imp Sep 2025 #59
"Being wrong is not a weakness, not admitting it to yourself or others is, when nothing is done to correct it." Buddyzbuddy Sep 2025 #60
People who leave volutarily... SickOfTheOnePct Sep 2025 #55
You're absolutely correct. Thank you for pointing that out. Buddyzbuddy Sep 2025 #57
Republicans have been telling us for years that government doesn't work. cloudbase Sep 2025 #15
This is their whole thing, exactly. intrepidity Sep 2025 #43
As Col Mustard stated above, I took the first round of DRP absyntheminded Sep 2025 #22
That sounds like a good deal. padfun Sep 2025 #33
I'm selling my annual (vacation) leave back... SickOfTheOnePct Sep 2025 #40
When I retired 8 years ago BumRushDaShow Sep 2025 #47
'The total resignation program is set to cost $14.8bn, elleng Sep 2025 #45
Joy as Defiance pat_k Sep 2025 #49
Agent kra$nov keeps on destroying the US from the inside. Justice matters. Sep 2025 #53
I'm sure it's only coincidental that COL Mustard Oct 2025 #61
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»US set for largest mass r...»Reply #39