Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

reACTIONary

(6,997 posts)
24. The Mayflower Compact would have be chosen...
Fri Dec 12, 2025, 09:20 PM
Dec 12

... for its significance as an Ur-Document in American constitutional history.

It is considered to be of significance not because of its actual content, but because it provides the first concreate example of the American tendency towards self-government, rule of law, and written, explicitly thought-out and agreed to constitutional governance, rather than an amalgam or hodgepodge or traditional practices and tendencies.

It also provides an almost literal, and yet mythic, example of the enlightenment social contract theory of governance, emerging from a state of nature into civil society:

The Mayflower was blown off course, and did not make landfall where it was supposed to have. If it had, the colonists would have been integrated into an existing legal and social frame work. But having been blown off course, they faced the prospect of, quite literally, entering into a "state of nature." In Hobbs's formulation, the prospect loomed of facing a war of all against all. They did, almost picture perfect, what the advocates of social contract theory speculated about and advocated - they created a governing compact amongst themselves and almost unanimously and voluntarily signed up to its provisions.

The constitution of Rohde Island is more American in its content, but it was the Mayflower compact that (presumably) first exemplified the sprit of constitutional governance itself, that became the spirt of America and culminated in our Constitution as we know it today.

Oh! I forgot to add:

The gods of my tribe have spoken. They said do not trust the pilgrims. And especially do not trust Sarah Miller.

Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Not very inspiring. gordianot Dec 12 #1
White male sh*t... of course. NotHardly Dec 13 #41
The Australians like to say: Gaugamela Dec 12 #2
LOL! NotHardly Dec 13 #42
Pilgrims? RetiredParatrooper Dec 12 #3
They had a framework of a plan. BidenRocks Dec 12 #17
I say go ahead and put your face on one of them asshole we'll just dump them over on your property Walleye Dec 12 #4
lol mzmolly Dec 12 #5
BORING. And unimaginative. littlemissmartypants Dec 12 #6
To be expected from Repukes. paleotn Dec 12 #28
I'm fine with Trump on a coin Bob_in_VA Dec 12 #7
They tried to put Farmer-Rick Dec 13 #35
Hmmmmm.... electric_blue68 Dec 13 #45
I for one, want nothing in my life that I can think of to remind me of this 4 year period Buddyzbuddy Dec 12 #8
I wonder how many people will think that e pluribus unum means in God we trust mahina Dec 12 #9
I'll put my trust where I want, not where someone says I should. It's a coin not a holy object. twodogsbarking Dec 12 #11
Check! mahina Dec 12 #13
I'm surprised that from many, one is permitted! mahina Dec 12 #14
Probably most of them, alas Warpy Dec 12 #16
Proper translation PATRICK Dec 13 #47
Mostly boring, but... reACTIONary Dec 12 #10
So can we make a deal with him if he dies right NOW mountain grammy Dec 12 #12
That's a stupid looking idea for a coin and not even close to historical accurate. cstanleytech Dec 12 #15
Roger Williams bmichaelh Dec 12 #18
The Mayflower Compact would have be chosen... reACTIONary Dec 12 #24
Great clip Farmer-Rick Dec 13 #37
What, no slaughtering of the natives? eggplant Dec 12 #19
The thought of a Trump coin... karin_sj Dec 12 #20
If it does, I expect the ones I see to be accidentally defaced before being returned to circulation. nt Gore1FL Dec 13 #38
I'm surprised that the Constitution wasn't replaced with the BidenRocks Dec 12 #21
commemorate, commiserate Donkees Dec 12 #22
Reminds me that I'm living for the day "In God we trust" is removed from our money. Intractable Dec 12 #23
So, you've got a problem with evil? reACTIONary Dec 12 #25
Sorry but fuck the Puritans lonely bird Dec 12 #26
So ... the PILGRIMS came here in 1776? Good to know ... FakeNoose Dec 12 #27
They helped storm the airports! paleotn Dec 12 #30
Hey, Donnie. You've gotta die to get your face on a coin. paleotn Dec 12 #29
So everyone is confident it won't look like this? LiberalLovinLug Dec 12 #31
Replete with gibberish typos ? Appropriate. eppur_se_muova Dec 12 #34
instead of "liberty..." cab67 Dec 13 #44
Trumps gonna touch that and it will turn to shit. BradBo Dec 12 #32
Oops, I must have misread this: I thought it read "Trump showering." CTyankee Dec 12 #33
Good Lord; your post should have a Warning 🚨 label electric_blue68 Dec 13 #46
I am so sorry! I try not to think about it... CTyankee Dec 13 #50
Yeah, really! Eeeeee! 😄 electric_blue68 Dec 15 #53
Why 1776 to 2026 under puritan macho man and scared little wifey??? Farmer-Rick Dec 13 #36
Actually PATRICK Dec 13 #48
White people ber alles Zelda_Orchid Dec 13 #39
Good grief... GiqueCee Dec 13 #40
If demand from coin collectors is large enough, they'll find a loophole. cab67 Dec 13 #43
The pilgram one shown above is pathetic but jgmiller Dec 13 #49
Semiquincentennial Coin Program Media Kit Mosby Dec 13 #51
At least coins can be melted down and recycled. eppur_se_muova Dec 13 #52
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»New coins to commemorate ...»Reply #24