Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

NickB79

(20,225 posts)
11. This has been known for years
Mon Dec 29, 2025, 04:58 PM
2 hrs ago

There have been studies going back a decade that found this. This one is from 2011.

https://www.nature.com/articles/ijo2011100

We found that 29% of subjects classified as lean and 80% of individuals classified as overweight according to BMI had a BF% within the obesity range.


The primary reason is that people who score as a "healthy weight" on the BMI scale, and don't appear obese, are in reality severely under-muscled due to lack of physical activity.

It's ironic that people have been claiming that BMI isn't accurate for years. When more accurate measurements are included that show that BMI actually underestimates obesity, that too is rejected. It's almost like a sizeable portion of the population just wants to ignore the serious health effects of obesity because it's uncomfortable to address.

Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I'll stick with BMI thank you. 3 links in I can't find the definition underpants 5 hrs ago #1
Here's the links to the BRI and BMI calculators. sinkingfeeling 4 hrs ago #3
Okay. I stay at 220 for the BMI underpants 3 hrs ago #8
Starts with demographics. sinkingfeeling 2 hrs ago #15
Uh huh. Why do smell the whiff of big pharma around the edges? I love when they do this. It's not the first time Vinca 4 hrs ago #2
Exactly. Maybe someday the focus can embrace lifestyle changes like nutrition, exercise and stress management. TheRickles 4 hrs ago #6
The Trump admin is all about the new weight loss drugs. yardwork 3 hrs ago #9
Has RFKjr seen Trump? NotHardly 3 hrs ago #10
I can't explain it either. yardwork 2 hrs ago #13
This has been known for years NickB79 2 hrs ago #11
What that weird drug does to people really creeps me out. ananda 2 hrs ago #17
Some of the effects now being slightlv 1 hr ago #21
BMI is junk science angrychair 4 hrs ago #4
I agree. Americanme 2 hrs ago #12
The correlation between obesity and health issues is unquestionable NickB79 2 hrs ago #14
i'm 6'2", 265 lbs and 14% body fat. According to BMI, I am obese. AZLD4Candidate 18 min ago #24
Well, Just Change back to the old definition! raccoon 4 hrs ago #5
Move More OC375 4 hrs ago #7
Move more and eat less FakeNoose 39 min ago #23
So with such statistics the logical approach would be for the gov to have a plan to combat it. twodogsbarking 2 hrs ago #16
Arnold in his is prime would have been morbidly obese according to doc03 2 hrs ago #18
Stop the testing JoseBalow 1 hr ago #19
6'-5" @ 219 lbs coming from a loudmouth soon yonder 1 hr ago #20
BMI also isn't a very good health indicator for some ethnic groups fujiyamasan 1 hr ago #22
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»More than 75% of US adult...»Reply #11