Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Wiz Imp

(9,016 posts)
43. He can and I believe will be charged by the state.
Thu Jan 8, 2026, 02:39 PM
Thursday
https://www.reuters.com/world/us/can-ice-agent-who-shot-minneapolis-woman-be-prosecuted-2026-01-08/
Federal agents are generally immune from state prosecution for actions taken as part of their official duties. Immunity only applies when an officer's actions were authorized under federal law and were necessary and proper.

If Minnesota charged the agent, he could seek to move the case to federal court and argue he is immune from prosecution.

To prevail, the state would have to show the actions were outside his official duties or were objectively unreasonable or clearly unlawful.


The actions were clearly NOT necessary and proper. They violate Federal law enforcement procedures. It's a slam dunk for the state to show that the actions were unreasonable and clearly unlawful.

The state of Minnesota will NOT let this guy get away with it. I believe they will definitely charge him. What happens after that remains to be seen. A judge may rule he has immunity (though I suspect the vast majority of judges including Republican appointees would rule against him). A jury could acquit him, though that is unlikely as well. But, I'm not predicting the ultimate outcome, just that the State of Minnesota will definitely bring charges against him. They have no choice. The guy committed cold blooded murder captured on video.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Could this require a lawsuit in federal court to get the information released? SSJVegeta Thursday #1
Pretty sure everything would accidentally be lost ashredux Thursday #9
Yep, including all if the video that ICE took progressoid Thursday #33
No offense, but posts like this are silly Wiz Imp Thursday #36
Yeah, progressoid Thursday #48
For the George Floyd killing, it wasn't the officer body cams that had the pertinent video evidence, it was the videos iluvtennis Thursday #45
Same with this. I find this whole "being blocked" thing an excuse SSJVegeta Friday #52
Vid from shooter Iwasthere Friday #56
It may. If that happened, the State of Minnesota would win. Wiz Imp Thursday #35
The fix is in Blues Heron Thursday #2
I came here to post this exact same thing JoseBalow Thursday #30
Yep, Mr. PooPooHead has blabbed to block our thoughts from Epstein. GreenWave Thursday #47
Hey Minnesotans, how is this playing out in this election year? Trump is clearly after Minnesota Raven123 Thursday #3
WTF! sheshe2 Thursday #4
so start wholesale arrests of ICE agents moonshinegnomie Thursday #5
There isn't anyone with the power to do that FBaggins Friday #55
That is bullshit, a complete cop out. Bluetus Thursday #6
An arrest warrant in what name? Has the killer's name been released? What about his accomplices? nt in2herbs Thursday #10
THere are clear photos. He could be identified very easily. Bluetus Thursday #13
He is probably out of Minnesota by now... returnee Thursday #37
With a warrant to stand trial for manslaughter Bluetus Thursday #46
Agreed and disappointed in Walz. returnee Friday #49
THIS orangecrush Thursday #32
Trump's fragile little ego underpants Thursday #7
Can MN file a writ of habeas corpus to gain access to the killer? Which court: state of federal? nt in2herbs Thursday #8
Federal in this case sboatcar Thursday #16
"habeas corpus" is a way to get someone released from custody if they haven't been charged muriel_volestrangler Thursday #23
I thought i heard that the ACLU was getting involved? If so maybe the Minnesota investigators bluestarone Thursday #11
I fully expect that the Trump regime will protect the shooter and not allow Gaugamela Thursday #12
Start indictments up the chain of command. C_U_L8R Thursday #14
Arrest the guy in charge that day, Bovino. sop Friday #53
so, the State of MN will not be able to file any charges. It is in Federal (Trumps) hands now. riversedge Thursday #15
FALSE Wiz Imp Thursday #38
right now on msNOW:: Gov Walz saying Trump Admin has Denied MN State a role in shooting Investigation riversedge Thursday #17
The state better hurry. The feds want to hurry and try, convict and pardon him LiberalArkie Thursday #18
No way does the Federal Government charge the guy. Wiz Imp Thursday #39
I don't think they will either.. And I don't think that the state can charge a federal officer in pursuit of his duty. LiberalArkie Thursday #42
He can and I believe will be charged by the state. Wiz Imp Thursday #43
"A state court cannot try or convict a person who has been pardoned by the federal government." Wiz Imp Thursday #41
Don't do that! Bayard Thursday #19
Minnesota Attorney General, Keith Ellison just torched the FBI and ICE for not cooperating in the investigation LetMyPeopleVote Thursday #20
Obstruction of Justice? Kid Berwyn Thursday #21
No surprise there... 2naSalit Thursday #22
Then, you go surround those assholes and do not let them leave their position without cooperation. OldBaldy1701E Thursday #24
Time to kill off qualified immunity for law enforcement Warpy Thursday #25
They don't want State Charges popsdenver Thursday #26
The only recourse at this point appears to be a civil wrongful death suit by her family. SunSeeker Thursday #27
Stop playing, Miguelito Loveless Thursday #28
We are in a dictatorship orangecrush Thursday #29
A lot of the Jan. 6 rioters were identified by photos. Katinfl Thursday #31
Thought this issue was settled long ago. North Coast Lawyer Thursday #34
Can someone say "coverup"? sakabatou Thursday #40
I knew they'd do this. SergeStorms Thursday #44
I previously never thought his wishes included a civil war, but it's getting harder to reject that now. ificandream Friday #50
Now that he has total immunity from the law.... SergeStorms Friday #54
This is just an excuse SSJVegeta Friday #51
Meanwhile FOX "News" claims MN police "drops out" of investigation. Kid Berwyn Friday #57
"Blue State" vs Federal Overreach: Minnesota officials blocked from investigating ICE shooting. AcanthaV Friday #58
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Minn. Officials Say They'...»Reply #43