Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

Mosby

(19,491 posts)
19. Yup
Sun Jun 9, 2013, 02:09 PM
Jun 2013

and in the past people were a little more candid about the goal:

My idea was to search out Arab schoolteachers, on the grounds that they would probably speak English, were educated men, would know the feelings of their communities, and would have thought about Arab problems. Arabs, living in their own communities, have their own schools, by their own wish, where the children are taught in Arabic, according to Arab principles. Nissim, my driver, was to serve as translator until I had found someone I could talk to; he was then to disappear. I did not want anyone to feel hampered by his alien presence. I might have spared myself anxiety. The candor of the Arabs is proof of their freedom inside the state of Israel; they are not in the least cowed.

In the Christian Arab village, the schoolteacher was an attractive lean young man, with prematurely gray hair, working in his garden in the cool of the evening. He had a good modern house, a young modern wife, and after six years of marriage, a first baby, a six-months-old girl named Mary, whom he and his wife so adored that neither of them took their eyes off the child at the same moment. He was healthy, prosperous, respected, freely doing his chosen work, loved and loving; by any standards, a fortunate man. After hours of listening to him, I had grasped the lacking clue, and felt hopeless.

-snip-

"The Arab governments and the Palestinian Arabs rejected Partition absolutely. You wanted the whole country. There is no secret about this. The statements of the Arab representatives, in the UN are on record. The Arab governments never hid the fact that they started the war against Israel. But you, the Palestinian Arabs, agreed to this, you wanted it. And you thought, it seems to me very reasonably, that you would win and win quickly. It hardly seemed a gamble; it seemed a sure bet. You took the gamble and you lost. I can understand why you have all been searching for explanations of that defeat ever since, because it does seem incredible. I don't happen to accept your explanations, but that is beside the point. The point is that you lost."

"Yes." It was too astonishing; at long last, East and West were in accord on the meaning of words.

"Now you say that you want to return to the past; you want Partition. So, in fact you say, let us forget that war we started, and the defeat, and, after all, we think Partition is a good, sensible idea. Please answer me this, which is what I must, know. If the position were reversed, if the Jews had started the war and lost it, if you had won the war, would you now accept Partition? Would you give up part of the country and allow the 650,000 Jewish residents of Palestine -who had fled from the war--to come back?"

"Certainly not," he said, without an instant's hesitation. "But there would have been no Jewish refugees. They had no place to go. They would all be dead or in the sea."


http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1961/10/the-arabs-of-palestine/304203/6/

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

This is John2 Jun 2013 #1
I agree that Israel had a huge amount of millitary aid, but you ignore the motivation karynnj Jun 2013 #6
Take it to the starting point in your example: People from other states kicked the NCers out of byeya Jun 2013 #9
I'm not in disagreement there - I know that Palestinians fled, taking their house keys karynnj Jun 2013 #17
You don't know what you are talking about. former9thward Jun 2013 #11
I do know what I'm talking about. John2 Jun 2013 #16
"There are only an estimated, 5,000 Jews left in Poland, from what was about 3-4 million." oberliner Jun 2013 #28
Thank you! sikofit3 Jun 2013 #36
Hear! Hear! The USA should not send another dime to Israel until that country cleans up its act. byeya Jun 2013 #2
We keep Israel alive Plucketeer Jun 2013 #7
+1 L0oniX Jun 2013 #15
OK then, Let's use the 1948 lines then!! on point Jun 2013 #3
+ + + byeya Jun 2013 #4
They already are using the 1948 lines, more or less cpwm17 Jun 2013 #8
Israel is the poster child for theocracies??? former9thward Jun 2013 #12
Israel is blocking the two-state solution cpwm17 Jun 2013 #13
I named a number of them. former9thward Jun 2013 #14
That is factually untrue Douglas Carpenter Jun 2013 #27
Actually sikofit3 Jun 2013 #37
Israel is not a theocracy Mosby Jun 2013 #18
Everything after yr subject line is incorrect... Violet_Crumble Jun 2013 #30
More interesting, IMO, and buried in the sixth paragraph... Poll_Blind Jun 2013 #5
The Arabs weren't satisfied with the 1948 lines Pab Sungenis Jun 2013 #10
Yup Mosby Jun 2013 #19
They've never accepted Jews. jessie04 Jun 2013 #20
What they didn't accept was not jews. but a state that disposed them of their land on point Jun 2013 #22
the nation of Israel is part of Judaism. Mosby Jun 2013 #23
Sorry, but if you really want to go back in history they stole it then too on point Jun 2013 #24
Post removed Post removed Jun 2013 #26
"The fact is the Jews stole Palestinian lands" oberliner Jun 2013 #29
That post was factual cpwm17 Jun 2013 #39
No it wasn't oberliner Jun 2013 #40
Do you think the Palestines have any right to live there? Marrah_G Jun 2013 #21
Sure they do. Pab Sungenis Jun 2013 #31
wow... okay Marrah_G Jun 2013 #33
I wouldn't have been happy with my land being taken either... Violet_Crumble Jun 2013 #25
The "Palestinians" were never a race Pab Sungenis Jun 2013 #32
So what? Neither are Australians. They are a people, though... Violet_Crumble Jun 2013 #34
My solution telclaven Jun 2013 #35
I too sikofit3 Jun 2013 #38
I do support a Palestinian state Pab Sungenis Jun 2013 #41
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Israel official: No Pales...»Reply #19