Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

happyslug

(14,779 posts)
12. What has this killing to do with religion?????
Mon Jun 10, 2013, 07:08 PM
Jun 2013

Sorry, nothing in the Article indicts this was a RELIGIOUS Killing. The location gives me the impression it was a military operation. Given a choice between hitting the Check point (using the dump as a cover since others were at the dump) and hitting the dump, which would you choose? I would hit the check point from the dump. This my comment this killing does NOT makes sense for the Taliban to do. If the Taliban killed these boys, that means they are killing their own cover. That makes NO SENSE in any MILITARY OPERATION.

Get away from the idea that the Taliban kill JUST FOR RELIGION. They are NOT, most of the moves the Taliban do is to win the war and that concentration is why the Taliban are winning the war in Afghanistan. This extends to their attack on schools, since schools means the Government is doing some good, it turns people away from the fight against the Government, thus the schools must be shut down. The Viet Cong did the same thing in Vietnam. The Algerian resistance (which was more communist then religions in their war against the French in the 1950s) did the same thing for the same reason. The US contras in Nicaragua did the same thing in the 1980s. They want the people to look to the Taliban as their legitimate government and sole provider of Government Services, including education. Thus in guerrilla warfare, Schools are a prime target.

Thus the Taliban has attacked schools in the past, they have NOT attacked people going through a Garbage dump. Why would the Taliban do so? They gain nothing from it. Thus my comment, looks who BENEFIT from this attack, and it does NOT look like it is the Taliban.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Inhumane. Boomerproud Jun 2013 #1
Disturbing story, but this typo made me laugh: ZombieHorde Jun 2013 #2
I noticed that too... KansDem Jun 2013 #3
It should have been the 10-year-old boy. n/t RebelOne Jun 2013 #5
Maybe they Turbineguy Jun 2013 #4
The Taliban Visited George H.W. Bush many times. red dog 1 Jun 2013 #6
What does that have to do with this? leftynyc Jun 2013 #23
Actually, I'm blaming both the Bush 41 AND Bush 43 Administrations for this disgusting bahavior red dog 1 Jun 2013 #29
Blaming the bush's for the leftynyc Jun 2013 #30
Calling me names does not validate your argument red dog 1 Jun 2013 #34
Awwww, poor baby doesn't like leftynyc Jun 2013 #35
This message was self-deleted by its author red dog 1 Jun 2013 #38
Why would the Taliban do this?? happyslug Jun 2013 #7
Religious fanatics rarely care about what's advisable shawn703 Jun 2013 #8
yes. Ed Suspicious Jun 2013 #10
What has this killing to do with religion????? happyslug Jun 2013 #12
As a warning to villagers not to co-operate with the Afghan government oberliner Jun 2013 #9
That might be the reason, but at a dump? happyslug Jun 2013 #13
What do you think is more probable? oberliner Jun 2013 #15
You have my two theories. happyslug Jun 2013 #16
Interesting oberliner Jun 2013 #24
Based on my own experience AND other news reports happyslug Jun 2013 #25
Gotcha oberliner Jun 2013 #28
It doesn't surprise me at all Marrah_G Jun 2013 #11
I do not know if you talking about the Taliban or our Afghan Allies happyslug Jun 2013 #14
So, your position is that though barbaric and monstrous, the geek tragedy Jun 2013 #17
A school girl or any children attending a school Harmony Blue Jun 2013 #18
This article is about a 10 year old and a 16 year old boy, not a girl in school happyslug Jun 2013 #26
I agree booley Jun 2013 #36
Bacha bazi (kept boys) from the military checkpoint or Talabin military? Sunlei Jun 2013 #19
That seems more likely Harmony Blue Jun 2013 #20
Yes, could be. How horrible to treat children this way. freshwest Jun 2013 #22
To young and to old. happyslug Jun 2013 #27
not in Afghanistan. boys are removed from homes, moved to the 'military areas very young to 'train' Sunlei Jun 2013 #32
Wikipedia is a good start on any research, but you have to be careful with it. happyslug Jun 2013 #33
looks like a 'respect' issue quadrature Jun 2013 #21
religion makes me blow chunks. nt boilerbabe Jun 2013 #31
And normal military operations are AOK?? happyslug Jun 2013 #37
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»2 children beheaded by mi...»Reply #12