Breaking: Army psychiatrist convicted of murder for Fort Hood shooting, now eligible for death

[branford]

34. The fact that you keep on repeating it, doesn't make it true!

Other than your belief, what is your evidence that he either lacked the ability to participate in his own defense, that he did not appreciate the nature of his conduct or the proceedings, or that he did not understand that his actions were illegal.

Having strong religious beliefs, thinking that your conduct is justified, representing yourself, proffering a lousy defense, or just plain idiocy, are rights guaranteed by the Constitution, not prima facie evidence of sufficient mental illness to absolve Hassan of criminal liability. Hassan was evaluated by doctors, provided more than sufficient due process, proudly admitted his conduct in support of his honestly held religious beliefs, and duly convicted by a jury of his peers. He will also be allowed to appeal both his conviction and any sentence he receives.

Additionally, a desire to see a criminal punished is not "bloodthirst," it is justice. Are you are really claiming that society does not have the right to punish a multiple murderer? Hassan will be given a sentence as dictated by the law. He will be able to appeal that sentence. He will not be tortured (as defined by the law, not you), his dietary, medical and religious needs will be met and accommodated, proper security measures will be instituted in accordance with the threat he poses, and he will have access to an attorney to remedy any issues while incarcerated (or prior to his execution).

You may have sympathy for Hassan. However, others, including myself, do not share your concern for a convicted murderer. I believe that he is entitled to due process and protection from cruel and unusual punishment. I've seen absolutely nothing that raises any issues, and he will be able to appeal to multiple courts. That is precisely where my concern ends. Whether he sits in a small cell for the rest of his natural life or receives a needle in his arm, the only one Hassan can blame for his situation is himself.