Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

Nihil

(13,508 posts)
17. 180 degrees out.
Fri Sep 27, 2013, 07:18 AM
Sep 2013

> Warren is demanding that manditory labeling is required not voluntary.

You've mixed up "manditory" (sic) and "voluntary" - Warren & Udall are both
*against* mandatory labelling of GMOs.


From the OP:

>> If the FDA heeds Senators Warren and Udall, the agency could use the voluntary guidance
>> to preempt state laws requiring mandatory labeling of GMOs. Currently, states have the right
>> to enact GMO labeling laws precisely because the FDA has not formally ruled on GMO labeling.
>> Once it does, state laws could be overturned.

>> The FDA’s guidance on voluntary GMO labeling also could be used to put an end to
>> existing, legitimate voluntary non-GMO labeling efforts.
>> By allowing the FDA, which has previously (and controversially) ruled that GMO and
>> non-GMO foods are “substantially equivalent,” the FDA could rule against non-GMO
>> or GMO-free labels on the basis that they mislead consumers by implying that there’s
>> a difference between GMO and non-GMO foods.

>> Senators Warren and Udall both have so far failed to support federal legislation
>> that would have required mandatory labeling of foods containing GMOs.

>> Both also voted against an amendment to the farm bill that would have protected
>> states’ rights to label GMOs.




Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

That's upsetting. Wilms Sep 2013 #1
What's upsetting? Javaman Sep 2013 #2
Apparently they referenced the docket which calls for voluntary labeling only. cui bono Sep 2013 #4
I read it. Wilms Sep 2013 #6
No - Warren is against mandatory labeling, and this could even prevent voluntary labelling bananas Sep 2013 #9
I think where she and Udall want to take this, is ... Myrina Sep 2013 #32
180 degrees out. Nihil Sep 2013 #17
No labelling is why I don't buy anything inch4progress Sep 2013 #3
Agree. And welcome to DU! cui bono Sep 2013 #5
Thanks, and I love your Warren net-bumper sticker:) inch4progress Sep 2013 #12
If they don't mandatory label Hydra Sep 2013 #7
Organic food cannot contain GMOs cprise Sep 2013 #10
They're loosening the rules Hydra Sep 2013 #11
I already buy food that says nonGMO certified lunasun Sep 2013 #8
"Organic" is a huge scam. Archae Sep 2013 #13
Have you tasted the difference? icymist Sep 2013 #14
Yes. Archae Sep 2013 #16
I don't know about you, but I taste a real big difference. icymist Sep 2013 #30
Spend sometime on an organic farm.... BronxBoy Sep 2013 #18
The big problem is "organic" is just a brand name. Archae Sep 2013 #20
The overwhelming majority BronxBoy Sep 2013 #24
You're either "forgetting" or ignoring one major component of organic farming, kentauros Sep 2013 #19
You want "organic" fertilizer? Archae Sep 2013 #22
There are all kinds of organic fertilizer that don't include kentauros Sep 2013 #23
Pretty sure it's the latter.... BronxBoy Sep 2013 #27
I know :) kentauros Sep 2013 #29
Thank you! I had a small commercial organic farm for several years. You clearly have Zorra Sep 2013 #34
The word 'organic' is miss-used in some cases. our food labeling system sucks in the USA. Sunlei Sep 2013 #31
Cool story, bro. Zorra Sep 2013 #33
Booo this stupid law. icymist Sep 2013 #15
This proves the fact the only time you agree with yourself is 100% of the time. JRLeft Sep 2013 #21
Proud member of OGA roody Sep 2013 #25
That the industry is against labels says it all. Democracyinkind Sep 2013 #26
Consumers want clear HONEST labeling on ALL products. Quit scamming people Corps.! Sunlei Sep 2013 #28
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Organic Consumers Opposes...»Reply #17