Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Latest Breaking News
In reply to the discussion: Venezuela looks to S.American leaders as toll hits 20 [View all]freshwest
(53,661 posts)28. Observing that they did not have sufficient governmental infrastructure or regulation - and it can
be easily understood as their change of course thorugh Chavez is not as established as longer standing governments like the USA, is not support for RW dictatorship. It is merely a statement of unfortunate facts on the ground there.
It is an obstacle that will be hard to overcome, and not their fault. This nation was barely in one piece less than a century after it was created, and even with a civil war, the practice of black slavery was not entirely rooted out by any means.
The new style of governance in VZ has not had that long to establish itself. Not that the USA was not attacked by a stronger military force in less than a quarter century after the Constitution was ratified. And Americans had the advantage of holding the land and were able to repell invasion.
In a country as old as VZ, it's hard to establish a working socialist system since the oligarchs are entrenched and have generations of supporters from a different class than that which Chavez was keen to lift up by socialist practice.
In a loose analogy, I'd say it could be constued to be like the situation of AA's here, who were held down and robbed all the way back to the very beginning and still are three centuries later. That is why the oligarchs are so hard to beat, they hold the land and those who are in need of change are up against a system that sees them as the outliers.
That is what the problem is, not the words of people on DU one way or the other. The suffering that is going on may end the experiment that Hugo began, or it may be able to find a compromise with the oligarchs to continue at a slower pace, until all can see the advantages of it.
I don't think civil war is the answer as the world appears to be going through an extremely regressive era. We don't like it and don't want it, but it is out there. The cards are stacked against the world's poor and vulnerable but some progress is being made.
Only the people of VZ will pay the cost for this, not us here, no matter how much it grieves us. For their sake, I hope both sides compromise and not have any further street battles. The longer this goes on, the greater the chance that the government will fall and whatever progress was made will be lost. We can't ignore those students who are not the enemy, they are the future. I'm hoping the call for a summit of SA leaders will bring this to a peaceful solution.
It is an obstacle that will be hard to overcome, and not their fault. This nation was barely in one piece less than a century after it was created, and even with a civil war, the practice of black slavery was not entirely rooted out by any means.
The new style of governance in VZ has not had that long to establish itself. Not that the USA was not attacked by a stronger military force in less than a quarter century after the Constitution was ratified. And Americans had the advantage of holding the land and were able to repell invasion.
In a country as old as VZ, it's hard to establish a working socialist system since the oligarchs are entrenched and have generations of supporters from a different class than that which Chavez was keen to lift up by socialist practice.
In a loose analogy, I'd say it could be constued to be like the situation of AA's here, who were held down and robbed all the way back to the very beginning and still are three centuries later. That is why the oligarchs are so hard to beat, they hold the land and those who are in need of change are up against a system that sees them as the outliers.
That is what the problem is, not the words of people on DU one way or the other. The suffering that is going on may end the experiment that Hugo began, or it may be able to find a compromise with the oligarchs to continue at a slower pace, until all can see the advantages of it.
I don't think civil war is the answer as the world appears to be going through an extremely regressive era. We don't like it and don't want it, but it is out there. The cards are stacked against the world's poor and vulnerable but some progress is being made.
Only the people of VZ will pay the cost for this, not us here, no matter how much it grieves us. For their sake, I hope both sides compromise and not have any further street battles. The longer this goes on, the greater the chance that the government will fall and whatever progress was made will be lost. We can't ignore those students who are not the enemy, they are the future. I'm hoping the call for a summit of SA leaders will bring this to a peaceful solution.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
77 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Yes, they are. But the overwhelming majority, despite current problems, are far better off
Zorra
Mar 2014
#48
No kidding. No sneaky kittens on that one. Would help put the situation into proportion. n/t
freshwest
Mar 2014
#54
Do you agree with Maduro that the Obama administration is behind the problems in Venezuela?
Zorro
Mar 2014
#14
And 'anticipatory orgasms' in common parlance is a sexual faux pas, I think. I don't think DUers
freshwest
Mar 2014
#53
Why is it always the CIA? Why not the Koches. Exxon, Chevron, whoever? Why a middleman?
freshwest
Mar 2014
#18
Maduro is in way over his head. He needs no help in running his own country into the ditch.
Ikonoklast
Mar 2014
#11
All of this in one year... It wasn't that crazy under Chavez, was it? TIA. n/t
freshwest
Mar 2014
#19
Chavez was a national hero, and the RW had no real possibility of a coup while he was
Zorra
Mar 2014
#23
Compared to Chavez, Maduro is a big step down. It's too bad when a country depends on one leader.
freshwest
Mar 2014
#24
I'd prefer to let President Maduro explain it to you, in detail, in his own words.
Zorra
Mar 2014
#52
"I'd prefer to let President Maduro explain it to you, in detail, in his own words."
EX500rider
Mar 2014
#61
Observing that they did not have sufficient governmental infrastructure or regulation - and it can
freshwest
Mar 2014
#28
The demonstrations aren't going to stop. The ones doing the killing are wearing uniforms
MADem
Mar 2014
#31
"The latest fatalities were a police officer who succumbed in hospital to a gunshot wound..."
Comrade Grumpy
Mar 2014
#39
Yes, and the previous eighteen (correction 21) were students and their supporters.
MADem
Mar 2014
#40
Here's two more dead: A National Guardsman and one of those motorcycle guys.
Comrade Grumpy
Mar 2014
#70
Maduro has told the colectivos (the armed motorcycle guys who shoot the students)
MADem
Mar 2014
#72
Chavez paid the bills, and thus had fewer problems keeping the shelves stocked, at least somewhat.
MADem
Mar 2014
#30
This is what I always thought. They could train their people to do everything. There should be no
freshwest
Mar 2014
#55