Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

stopbush

(24,852 posts)
19. So I did a google search and here's what I found:
Sun Apr 27, 2014, 07:39 PM
Apr 2014

"The Costa Rican grandmother claims that miracle took place after she was told by doctors that she had less than a month to live, a written statement distributed by the church attests.

"However, her neurosurgeon, Alejandro Vargas, denies he ever told his pious patient any such thing.

"Though Vargas does admit Mora's condition was potentially fatal, he says he predicted only a two percent chance that the aneurysm would kill her, possibly bleeding into her brain within a year of the diagnosis, Reuters reported."

Source - The Daily Mail: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2357226/Costa-Rican-woman-claims-late-Pope-John-Paul-II-cured-fatal-brain-aneurysm-make-eligible-sainthood.html#ixzz308G7IhJw

The Giuseppe Zannini "confirmation" is even more laughable:

"Sister Caterina was hospitalized and underwent an operation which lasted for five hours. The inside of her stomach was completely covered with a strange and rare form of ulcerous tumours, caused, perhaps, by the improper functioning of the pancreas and spleen. The Professor was obliged to remove her stomach, except for a small piece the size of a prune. He also removed the pancreas and spleen. The esophagus was connected directly to the part of the intestine known as the fasting. It was also necessary to cut the aorta and connect it to the hollow part, making a deviation of the blood circulation. It was a delicate operation and the probabilities for the patient to come out of the operating room alive were quite slim.

"Before the operation, Sister Caterina tells us, I had prayed to the Holy Virgin of Pompei, to whom I am very devout. The day after the operation, while I was thanking the Virgin for having come through the operation safely, a Sister from our Congregation told me: It was Pope John who saved you. I had placed his image on the bed of the operating room and had continued to pray throughout the operation." http://www.saintanthonyofpadua.net/messaggero/pagina_stampa.asp?R=&ID=80

Idiot - she "thanks the Virgin" for having come through the operation. Apparently, no thanks for the doctor who operated, though.

The story goes on: she felt better, then worse, then better, etc. She went through a number of surgeries. Guess what? All those surgeries eventually added up and cured her, not some visit from Pope John's ghost. Nowhere in the link I provided does Zannini say it was a miracle that she survived.

Childish bullshit. The rants of a nun who is predisposed to believe in such shit and who gives no credit to the surgeons who operated on her and gave her a chance to survive. This is what you're hanging your rah-rah-religion hat on?

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Yeah! That just solved a whole lot of the world's problems. NOT! stopbush Apr 2014 #1
Couldn't have said it better. phil89 Apr 2014 #2
Healings done in their names. Brickbat Apr 2014 #5
1. Made a lame man blind stopbush Apr 2014 #10
It was a miracle so few priests were arrested under JPII. ChairmanAgnostic Apr 2014 #13
It's really nothing more than a PR move Major Nikon Apr 2014 #3
FWIW Francis changed the rule LiberalElite Apr 2014 #6
No, it's defined as a medical cure that cannot be explained scientifically. rug Apr 2014 #15
Really? And what was that medical cure that can't be explained scientifically in this case? stopbush Apr 2014 #17
For JP2, it was a paralyzing brain aneurysm. rug Apr 2014 #18
So I did a google search and here's what I found: stopbush Apr 2014 #19
For one thing, I'm not hanging it on The Daily Mail or "saintanthonyofpadua.net". rug Apr 2014 #20
The bullshit was reported by Reuters and picked up by the Daily Mail. stopbush Apr 2014 #22
I'll just leave your posr reeking out there as an example of typical "behavior". rug Apr 2014 #24
It speaks for itself, as do the easily exposed lies about miracles occurring. stopbush Apr 2014 #25
It certainly does speak to something. It's not what you think, though. rug Apr 2014 #26
It's easy to toss out meaningless one-liners. Harder to address my exposing the lie stopbush Apr 2014 #27
"my exposing the lie", Lol! rug Apr 2014 #28
Rug. Good for LOLs. Not much else. stopbush Apr 2014 #29
You have now completed your descent into inanity. rug Apr 2014 #31
Just following your lead. stopbush Apr 2014 #32
Prudent but doubtful. rug Apr 2014 #33
Miracles are getting weaker and weaker. progressoid Apr 2014 #21
LOL nt flying rabbit Apr 2014 #23
In other words... Helen Borg Apr 2014 #4
Hey, let's be real for a minute... Moostache Apr 2014 #7
what a joke. NYtoBush-Drop Dead Apr 2014 #8
Message auto-removed Name removed Apr 2014 #9
Moreover, what *is* a Saint? SorellaLaBefana Apr 2014 #11
You can't spell "saint" without "ain't." stopbush Apr 2014 #30
It's traditional... Archae Apr 2014 #12
Pretty cool! Thanks for posting. Kaleva Apr 2014 #14
Thanks for posting. A blessed 840high Apr 2014 #16
Nonsense, all of it. Owl Apr 2014 #34
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Pope Francis Declares 2 P...»Reply #19