Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Latest Breaking News
In reply to the discussion: Virgin Galactic spacecraft crash kills one [View all]joshcryer
(62,536 posts)70. Joel Glenn Brenner basically summed it up:
Many others have reported the same, Parabolic Arc had some damning tweets: https://twitter.com/spacecom
@SpaceShipTwo @VirginGalactic Plastic/nitrous engine had a hard start on the test stand in May 2013, 3 weeks after first SS2 powered flight.
The engine blew apart, the rocket casing and nozzle ended up on the desert floor far from the test stand. #SpaceShipTwo @virgingalactic
It's too early to say exactly what happened today, but it's possible based on what we saw the engine suffered a hard start. #SpaceShipTwo
I have unpublished photos of the aftermath of the May 2013 test stand accident. I will likely post those when I can. #SpaceShipTwo
I had deep concerns over both the new plastic/nitrous oxide engine and so did other sources familiar with the testing. #SpaceShipTwo
The concerns were three fold. One, that it wasn't being tested sufficiently on the ground before it was flown. #SpaceShipTwo
Second: that modifications required to ship to accommodate the new engine introduced additional complexity and failure modes. #SpaceShipTwo
Third, handful of test flights they were doing with new #SpaceShipTwo engine before putting Richard and Sam Branson aboard were insufficient
Let me stress2 things: one, we don't know what happened yet, so I'm not making a snap judgment about what caused the accident #SpaceShipTwo
Second, these concerns about the new engine were not mine alone. Folks much smarter and knowledgble than me were worried. #SpaceShipTwo
I predict you will be hearing a lot more about these concerns and the problems they were having in the days and weeks ahead #SpaceShipTwo
I've been deeply concerned for months that this could happen. It disturbed my waking hours and seeped into my dreams. #SpaceShipTwo
The engine blew apart, the rocket casing and nozzle ended up on the desert floor far from the test stand. #SpaceShipTwo @virgingalactic
It's too early to say exactly what happened today, but it's possible based on what we saw the engine suffered a hard start. #SpaceShipTwo
I have unpublished photos of the aftermath of the May 2013 test stand accident. I will likely post those when I can. #SpaceShipTwo
I had deep concerns over both the new plastic/nitrous oxide engine and so did other sources familiar with the testing. #SpaceShipTwo
The concerns were three fold. One, that it wasn't being tested sufficiently on the ground before it was flown. #SpaceShipTwo
Second: that modifications required to ship to accommodate the new engine introduced additional complexity and failure modes. #SpaceShipTwo
Third, handful of test flights they were doing with new #SpaceShipTwo engine before putting Richard and Sam Branson aboard were insufficient
Let me stress2 things: one, we don't know what happened yet, so I'm not making a snap judgment about what caused the accident #SpaceShipTwo
Second, these concerns about the new engine were not mine alone. Folks much smarter and knowledgble than me were worried. #SpaceShipTwo
I predict you will be hearing a lot more about these concerns and the problems they were having in the days and weeks ahead #SpaceShipTwo
I've been deeply concerned for months that this could happen. It disturbed my waking hours and seeped into my dreams. #SpaceShipTwo
If Branson wants to see the program survive he needs to open up his check book. This will be the fourth dead person attributable to the program (the Scaled Composites accident in 2007 on similar engines). The engines are a dud, the drawing board needs to be gone back to.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
81 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I understand that jets are used to launch this spacecraft not rockets
notadmblnd
Oct 2014
#27
The aircraft is carried up to the same altitude that commercial jets fly at by a turbine (jet)...
BlueEye
Oct 2014
#35
Agree, but any activity that shows we are not complete moron assholes like teaparty
randys1
Oct 2014
#3
Let's add prisons to that list, as well, notrightatall. Then you'll be right :)
PatrickforO
Oct 2014
#19
But they were overseen by NASA engineers and were built to NASA approved specifications
George II
Oct 2014
#8
But the New Mexico taxpayers pick up the tab for the already built Spaceport
Dont call me Shirley
Oct 2014
#53
The idea the private sector can do everything better, faster and cheaper is nothing but a sad
PatrickforO
Oct 2014
#21
I'm feeling this isn't a great time to bring political ideology into this discussion
groundloop
Oct 2014
#25
You have no idea what happened, why, and at the moment, one of the two test pilots is alive.
AtheistCrusader
Nov 2014
#66
Watching the reports. Apparently, engine failure on the test flight. Subsequent explosion in flight.
pinto
Oct 2014
#26
Please note : My wife's and my thoughts are with the families and the suriving pilot BUT
diabeticman
Oct 2014
#30
Richard Branson, the billionaire founder of Virgin Galactic, sent out a message on Twitter on Friday
Baclava
Oct 2014
#58
Indeed, I agree. Open his checkbook wide open. Get serious for a change.
True Blue Door
Nov 2014
#72
How do you perfect something if you don't actually attempt to use it?
PersonNumber503602
Nov 2014
#74