Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Judi Lynn

(164,103 posts)
16. Ah, Miami's FTAA event, starring their fun-loving police chief, John Timoney!
Wed Dec 31, 2014, 04:58 PM
Dec 2014

John Timoney, America�s Worst Cop

He has spent 138 days on the road in just a few years on the job. Who�s minding the Miami Police Department?

By Tamara Lush Thursday, Sep 20 2007

~ snip ~

The defining event of Timoney's tenure, the Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA) summit, came to Miami November 20. Police were on guard because of the massive riots that had taken place in Seattle during a 1999 World Trade Organization meeting and demonstrations during the 2000 Republican National Convention in Philadelphia, when Timoney was police commissioner there. Hundreds of people were arrested at both. "Timoney's strategy during the RNC was to arrest as many people as possible, look good in front of the TV cameras, and deal with the Constitution later," commented Kris Hermes, spokesman for a group that helped defend many of the demonstrators.

From FTAA's start, Timoney locked down the city's center. Then he dispatched 2500 officers in riot gear against about 12,000 protesters. The cops used rubber bullets, shields, batons, concussion grenades, and stun guns. The "rough start," Timoney would later explain, was needed because some demonstrators didn't have permits. Sixty people were taken into custody; many were beaten by cops. At one point, Timoney jumped off of his patrol bicycle and yelled at a protester: "Fuck you! You're bad!" Nineteen-year-old Edward Owaki of Connecticut was linking arms with other protesters on Biscayne Boulevard when police barreled into the crowd and pinned him to the ground. He suffered a severe head injury and was hospitalized for a week.

Free speech advocates were horrified. One editorial writer from the St. Petersburg Times said, "The show of force would have made a Latin American dictator blush."

Timoney responded with typical sensitivity. His officers "demonstrated a tremendous amount of restraint," he said.

~ snip ~
Fallout from the FTAA riots continued in 2004. Accountants totaled costs for security around $23.9 million. The American Civil Liberties Union received 150 complaints alleging police abuse and filed six lawsuits on behalf of protesters in federal court. (They are all still pending.) The city settled for $180,000 with an independent filmmaker named Carl Kessler after he was injured by a police beanbag fired into his face. And the Miami Civilian Investigative Panel issued a report criticizing cops for profiling and unlawfully searching protesters.

Yet the chief stood by his claim that his handling of the protests was a "success." And he was right — at least if you consider his frequent-flyer account. During at least half of the 26 trips Timoney took after the FTAA summit, he was called up to discuss what became known as "The Miami Model" of crowd control.

In April that year, the chief was embarrassed when a Philadelphia judge dismissed the case against "The Timoney Three," who had been arrested during the 2000 GOP convention after one had allegedly thrown a bicycle at the chief. It was the story he told to local media while chuckling that first day on the job. Called to testify, Timoney couldn't identify his attacker. Worse, a video showed the trio had cooperated with police before taking a beating.

More:
http://www.miaminewtimes.com/2007-09-20/news/john-timoney-america-s-worst-cop/full/

[center]~ ~ ~[/center]
Police Trampled Civil Rights During 2003 Free Trade Protests in Florida, ACLU Charges

November 17, 2005

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Contact: media@aclu.org

MIAMI – The American Civil Liberties Union of Florida’s Greater Miami Chapter today filed three lawsuits charging that officers of the Miami, Miami-Dade and Broward police departments used excessive force to intimidate and unlawfully arrest innocent bystanders and protesters who were exercising their free speech rights during the November 2003 Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA) ministerial meetings in downtown Miami.

The three lawsuits filed today – on the two-year anniversary of the FTAA summit – are on behalf of a former Miami New Times reporter, four labor union members and a college student from Massachusetts whose skull was fractured after police hit him in the head three times with a baton. All six ACLU plaintiffs were arrested on November 20, 2003, during marches that resulted in hundreds of arrests after police used unnecessary force to disperse crowds.

“The ‘Miami Model’ was a police tactic designed to intimidate political demonstrators, silence dissent, and criminalize protest against the government policies,” said ACLU Greater Miami Chapter President Terry Coble, referring to the City of Miami’s law enforcement strategy during the FTAA meetings. “If this type of police action is allowed to continue, our country will have lost one of our most basic rights, and we will be on the road to a totalitarian government.”

~ snip ~

Working under the overall command of Miami Police Chief John Timoney, officers from the City of Miami, Miami-Dade County and the Broward Sheriff’s Office made extensive plans to militarize the police force in an attempt to limit demonstrations. According to news reports, police officers from more than three dozen law enforcement agencies converged on downtown Miami to create an almost surreal backdrop that included armored vehicles on the ground and helicopters dotting the skyline above. The police marched in lines wearing full riot gear and wielding batons, tear gas, pepper spray and beanbag rifles to control the crowds of demonstrators.

~ snip ~

“The police used intimidation and fear to basically shut us up,” said Winter, who returned to Miami from Pittsburgh to participate in an ACLU news conference today. “When I asked them why they were arresting us, they replied that they were simply following orders and proceeded to handcuff me and force me face down into the grass. At that moment, it felt like I had no rights; they had complete power to suspend my rights for the sake of what they called ‘security,’ but in reality they were the ones causing all of the violence and problems.”

The second case, Owaki v. City of Miami, et al., involves the severe beating of college student Edward Owaki, of Amherst, Mass. Owaki, 19, joined other college students in a peaceful demonstration that was cut short when police officers decided to order everyone to flee the area near Northeast Third Street in downtown. The officers used tear gas, batons and shields to push the protesters toward Biscayne Boulevard. Owaki, who turned around to follow police orders to disperse, was then struck from behind three times with a police baton. He was beaten so severely that his skull was fractured, and he fell unconscious. Owaki, an Eagle Scout who had never before been in trouble with the law, was arrested for “disorderly conduct” and then transported to Jackson Memorial Hospital. He was given Tylenol and then taken to the Miami-Dade County Jail, where he spent the night. Owaki suffered from pain and vomiting and a nurse at the jail noted that he was dehydrated. Owaki was released from jail late the next day and his friends took him back to Jackson because he was disoriented and in severe pain. He was admitted to intensive care and spent nine days in the hospital while being treated for a skull fracture, cerebral contusions and seizures.

More:
https://www.aclu.org/free-speech/police-trampled-civil-rights-during-2003-free-trade-protests-florida-aclu-charges

[center]~ ~ ~[/center]
Text-book case for the Miami original first wave "exiles' to use to show Cuba how to do it up right, wasn't it? My god. Could not have been an uglier nightmare.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Why do I suspect there are other interests involved not wanting a normalization of relations? still_one Dec 2014 #1
Excellent point. carla Dec 2014 #2
So why can't Cubans have democracy at the national level? hack89 Dec 2014 #3
Whether Cuba has or doesn't have democracy at the national level wasn't my point. My point was that still_one Dec 2014 #4
I agree that lifting the embargo will bring freedom to Cuba hack89 Dec 2014 #6
agreed, especially the potential for the eventual political liberalization in Cuba still_one Dec 2014 #7
The diplomatic reproachment apparently isn't tied to any lifting of repression Bacchus4.0 Dec 2014 #8
I'd be careful. Rhinodawg Dec 2014 #9
Some slow evolving has occurred but the government still doesn't tolerate criticism Bacchus4.0 Dec 2014 #10
I think you are a true optomist ripcord Jan 2015 #21
WTF did I tell you. Rhinodawg Dec 2014 #5
Maybe the US should free its political prisoners before demanding that others do so. Mika Dec 2014 #11
Allow me to quote FiveGoodMen... Rhinodawg Dec 2014 #12
I don't recall any Ferguson protester being arrested prior to showing up for the protests but keep Bacchus4.0 Dec 2014 #13
Actually, the Cuba model is far less violent and intrusive than the US model. Mika Dec 2014 #14
Yeah, so what is the point of arresting people before they show up at an event Bacchus4.0 Dec 2014 #15
You apparently haven't stirred yourself to follow how police surveillance of dissidents is done Judi Lynn Dec 2014 #17
"crowd control technique used in Miami, which included large scale pre-emptive arrests" Mika Jan 2015 #19
Ah, Miami's FTAA event, starring their fun-loving police chief, John Timoney! Judi Lynn Dec 2014 #16
Miami did such a slam-bam job on the protesters of all ages, it set a standard! From Wikipedia: Judi Lynn Dec 2014 #18
If Cuba did ANYTHING close to what happened here, the US would INCREASE sanctions on Cuba. Mika Jan 2015 #20
Such short memories among the right-wingers! Judi Lynn Jan 2015 #22
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Cuba Detains at Least Thr...»Reply #16