Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

polly7

(20,582 posts)
23. Behind India’s ‘Epidemic’ Of Farmer Suicides
Wed May 18, 2016, 06:43 PM
May 2016

BY BEENISH AHMED APR 17, 2015 2:50 PM

Vandana Shiva, India’s most prominent environmental activist, believes genetically-modified seeds — specifically, those sold by the agricultural behemoth Monsanto — are driving farmers to lose control of their own farming practices. She’s claimed that the frustrations over Monsanto’s proprietary policies which forbid farmers from planting, selling, or even accidentally growing seeds from Monsanto’s patented crops push farmers to the brink. Shiva and other environmental activists have come to refer to Monsanto seeds as “suicide seeds.”

In 2013, she explained her argument, citing one of Monsanto’s genitically-modified cotton seeds as an example.

“Monsanto’s seed monopolies, the destruction of alternatives, the collection of superprofits in the form of royalties, and the increasing vulnerability of monocultures has created a context for debt, suicides and agrarian distress which is driving the farmers’ suicide epidemic in India,” Shiva wrote. “This systemic control has been intensified with Bt cotton. That is why most suicides are in the cotton belt.”

But many researchers have started to take issue with the notion that genetically-modified crops like Monsanto’s Bt cotton are to blame for India’s epidemic of farmer suicides. Some have pointed out that Indian farmers continued to purchase Monsanto seeds even as activists railed against them — and for good reason: because it proved profitable to do so.

For its part, Monsanto has argued that its crops require less pesticide purchase and less loss of yield — meaning that farmers who opted for its genetically-modified seeds would be more successful than those who use traditional seeds.

But Shiva has countered, claiming that Monsanto drove up the price of seeds 8,000 percent — and that “the high costs of purchased seed and chemicals have created a debt trap.”

Since debt is a major cause to farmers’ despair, however, it’s not just agricultural companies like Monsanto who are responsible. For those seeking loans to pay higher up-front costs for Monsanto seeds, unfair lending practices increase their financial woes.

Anoop Sadanadan, a professor of political science based at Syracuse University, has argued that farmer suicides should be attributed not to agricultural practices but rather financial ones. In a paper published last year, he noted that farmer suicides were concentrated in five of India’s 28 states — and that those five offered the least institutional credit to farmers, forcing them to take out private loans at interest rates as high as 45 percent.


Full article: http://thinkprogress.org/world/2015/04/17/3648423/india-farmer-suicide/

I have personal experience with Monsanto planting crops up here and followed very, very closely Percy Schmeiser's fight with them. I know how fucking evil they are, so save your crap.

http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2011/12/25/percy-schmeiser-farmer-who-beat-monsanto.aspx
Monsanto is poison erlewyne May 2016 #1
Poor Europe they get out poisons and all the refugees we jwirr May 2016 #2
Wow! A true treasure trove of unabashed nutbaggery! Major Nikon May 2016 #3
. HuckleB May 2016 #5
Yeah, I've seen more bullshit from the MSM as you've cherry-picked from here. polly7 May 2016 #6
You used a crap source, and that's your excuse? HuckleB May 2016 #9
Oooooh. Deep. polly7 May 2016 #11
You almost always use crap sources. HuckleB May 2016 #12
LOL You, I don't even take seriously. nt. polly7 May 2016 #13
You don't take life seriously. HuckleB May 2016 #14
Oh, sure I do. polly7 May 2016 #15
No, you don't. HuckleB May 2016 #16
Sorry, I've read all your propaganda. Don't plan on wasting time reading more. polly7 May 2016 #17
Now you're spreading the anti-GMO suicide myth? HuckleB May 2016 #18
No, your posts are pathetic look at me crap that idolize a poison giant you seem polly7 May 2016 #19
Yet another sad and false response. HuckleB May 2016 #20
Behind India’s ‘Epidemic’ Of Farmer Suicides polly7 May 2016 #23
Doubling down with Shiva and Mercola doesn't make the lies about India's suicides go away. HuckleB May 2016 #25
Some how I doubt you followed Percy Schmeiser that closely Major Nikon May 2016 #30
Oh no, don't doubt that at all. polly7 May 2016 #31
Anyone who uses the right wing quack Mercola as a source obviously doesn't have a "fucking clue" one Major Nikon May 2016 #32
Nah ......... I was here. Where every farmer in the province was talking about polly7 May 2016 #33
Sure, that's why you have to parrot out a right wing quack and AIDS denialist for your proof Major Nikon May 2016 #34
You bet, great sources I have. polly7 May 2016 #35
Cool story bro Major Nikon May 2016 #36
Look in a mirror, you'll be more accurate 'bro'. nt. polly7 May 2016 #37
Perhaps, but I don't have to rely on right wing AIDS deniers and loony bins for my evidence Major Nikon May 2016 #38
Awww ........... need a little teeny fiddle for your poor, poor Monsanto - the perpetual victim? polly7 May 2016 #39
Do you really think your easily debunked lies are doing your cause any good? Major Nikon May 2016 #40
Not just my cause, millions the world over. polly7 May 2016 #41
... Major Nikon May 2016 #42
Creepy propaganda. Does Monsanto pay for that, too? nt. polly7 May 2016 #43
... Major Nikon May 2016 #44
Pretty stupid of you. Here's Bill Nye pointing out how the Monarch butterfies were decimated FighttheFuture May 2016 #47
In other words, you don't realize that more toxic herbicide ... HuckleB May 2016 #49
Pretty stupid of you to quote Nye completely out of context and pretend that's what he meant Major Nikon May 2016 #50
Quote seems pretty on target to me as a response to your Facebook crap. Also, FighttheFuture May 2016 #59
Yeah, how about that... Major Nikon May 2016 #61
And precisely what, pray tell, is your point? n/t gregcrawford May 2016 #7
Here We Go Again - the 'evil' Monsanto Thread! Gamecock Lefty May 2016 #4
Right, because poisons are always so safe and this multi-billion dollar industry has nothing FighttheFuture May 2016 #8
You probably should have read farther Major Nikon May 2016 #22
I know enough to avoid poisons and not want them used. the simplistic WHO procouncement, FighttheFuture May 2016 #24
So tell me then if you completely avoid other things as well... Major Nikon May 2016 #27
Have you seen this piece on the IARC? HuckleB May 2016 #28
No, but anyone who spews the significance of IARC classifications probably should Major Nikon May 2016 #29
Disengenuous apples and oranges comparisons. I am also not only relying on the IARC, as you seem FighttheFuture May 2016 #45
How you can tell when you're a conspiracy theorist.... Major Nikon May 2016 #46
Post removed Post removed May 2016 #48
And yet I don't have to call you stupid in order to make my points Major Nikon May 2016 #52
No, you call me a "Conspiracy theorist". Fuck you. How's that for telling? FighttheFuture May 2016 #54
I didn't call you a conspiracy theorist. You've called me several names Major Nikon May 2016 #60
So what other legit science organization agrees with you? HuckleB May 2016 #51
You might want to read this, then. HuckleB May 2016 #26
We are talking about Roundup, and man made poisons and the mega-corporations behind FighttheFuture May 2016 #53
In other words, you didn't bother to read the piece. HuckleB May 2016 #55
I did. Maybe I misunderstood what you were trying to say. I do take this from the end, which FighttheFuture May 2016 #56
Your response showed no indication of that at all. HuckleB May 2016 #57
No, you prefer to support exsiting posions, I prefer to call them what they are. Poison and it FighttheFuture May 2016 #58
Thanks for proving my point. HuckleB May 2016 #62
When it has been proven... gregcrawford May 2016 #10
As EU Weighs Approval, More Evidence Industry is Rigging the Glyphosate Game polly7 May 2016 #21
Latest Discussions»Editorials & Other Articles»Monsanto and the Poisonin...»Reply #23