A frame that could give Democrats the unifying concept to WIN? [View all]
Conservatives often complain that theyve been exiled from power, whether in the corridors of the Capitol or the pages of the New York Times. Yet conservative ideas have dominated American politics for thirty years. The centerpiece of that dominance is the notion that the market equals freedom and government is the threat to freedom. Despite the Great Recession and election of Barack Obama, the most progressive candidate to win the presidency since 1964, that idea retains its hold.
--snip--
If there is to be a true realignmentnot just of parties but of principles, not just of policy preferences or cognitive frames but of deep beliefs and ideaswe must confront conservatisms political philosophy. That philosophy reflects more than a bloodless economics or narrow self-interest; it draws from and drives forward a distinctly moral vision of freedom, with deep roots in American political thought.
--snip--
We must, in other words, change the argument from the abstractions of the free market to the very real power of the businessman. More than posing an impersonal threat to the deliberations of a democratic polityas the progressive opposition to the Supreme Courts Citizens United decision would have it, or as liberals like Paul Krugman and Hendrik Hertzberg have suggested about the unionbusting in Wisconsinthe businessman imposes concrete and personal constraints on the freedom of individual citizens. What conservatives fear above all elsemore than higher taxes or lower profitsis any challenge to that power, any inversion of the obligations of deference and command, any extension of freedom that would curtail their own.
--snip--
We must also change the argument about government. Government need not be a source of constraint, as conservatives claim. Nor is it designed to protect citizens from the vagaries of the market, as many liberals claima formulation that depicts citizens as needy and passive and opens liberals to the charge of paternalism and condescension. When government is aligned with democratic movements on the ground, as Walter Reuther and Martin Luther King Jr. understood, it becomes the individuals instrument for liberating herself from her rulers in the private sphere, a way to break the back of private autocracy.
https://www.thenation.com/article/reclaiming-politics-freedom/
The platform proposals I've heard so far from people like Chuck Schumer have seemed weak and lackluster so far. But this article strikes me as providing a powerful ideal to run and win on. I think it would have legs and be a powerful counter to right wing framing. Would love to have the community give it some thought and let me know if you think it resonates. I think a powerful frame has helped the conservatives' rise, but this one strikes me as the argument that could take hold and spread.