Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Squinch

(59,695 posts)
9. This movie is a joke! Maggie's learning disabled kid would be rejected by a real charter school!
Sat Sep 29, 2012, 04:26 PM
Sep 2012

The premise of the movie is that Maggie's character starts up the charter school for the love of her learning disabled child.

The fact is that charter schools usually reject kids with learning problems. If a kid with a learning problem gets in by mistake, they are strongly encouraged to leave (by a variety of distasteful means) before "testing season" each spring so that the school's scores don't suffer as a result of that child's existence.

In real life, after Maggie's character had won her "victory" and gotten her charter school, her child would be booted within a few months. And now that the local public school is a charter school that won't accept Maggie's kid, the kid will be bussed out of the neighborhood to go to a public school that welcomes children with learning disabilities.

In real life, the other parents who thought the charter school was a keen idea, would find that they had no say in how their child is treated in that charter school, and if they are unhappy with their child's treatment, there is no place they can go to get help.

In real life, the children in the charter school have a 37% chance of doing worse than they did in the public school, and a 17% chance of doing better than they did in the public school.

Charter schools are a freaking scam!

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Du rec. Nt xchrom Sep 2012 #1
I saw the film advertised and wondered if it was just another fasttense Sep 2012 #2
I have not seen this advertised yet, but it does sound like an Alec marketing tool.... midnight Sep 2012 #3
New group ALICE to counter ALEC’s influence midnight Sep 2012 #4
You should post this as an original post on a general forum. I've been hoping for a group like this Squinch Sep 2012 #8
I can do that.... midnight Sep 2012 #18
Apparently, Holly Hunter plays a corrupt Teachers Union official... Cooley Hurd Sep 2012 #5
ALEC's message is loud and clear.... Unions are in the way so they are evil... Once we remove them midnight Sep 2012 #7
In New York State, they tried to farm public preschool special education through private agencies. Squinch Sep 2012 #10
Like the scandal, Scott Walker, being investigated in Wisconsin, there is always more... We already midnight Sep 2012 #15
They are trying to get the public to force public schools to close. Frustratedlady Sep 2012 #6
This movie is a joke! Maggie's learning disabled kid would be rejected by a real charter school! Squinch Sep 2012 #9
ALEC Accountability Act brings transparency of gifts/lobbing of our legislators has been stalled... midnight Sep 2012 #11
This message was self-deleted by its author liskddksil Sep 2012 #12
The reviews are really bad and the box-office so far is equally so. liskddksil Sep 2012 #13
Awesome..... midnight Sep 2012 #14
"One of the worst openings ever in a movie in 2500 theaters." EVER. Suck it, Kochs! Squinch Sep 2012 #16
PBS commentator Bill Moyers says the Koch supported ALEC bill mill is everywhere.. and this movie midnight Sep 2012 #17
Latest Discussions»Editorials & Other Articles»"Won't Back Down&quo...»Reply #9