Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

fasttense

(17,301 posts)
5. So many half truths in this article.
Wed Aug 28, 2013, 07:36 AM
Aug 2013

The discovery of DDT was science and the discovery that it devastated bird populations was also science. Science is a tool, not a meme to be used to support a corporation.

Both DDT and tobacco brought billions in profit to greedy corporations. Science is not the problem here, it's how science is used by corporations that is the problem. What's the big deal about testing new products, even if they are created by using scientific methods. In fact, using the scientific method to test new products for problems before they sicken people and devastate the environment is well..scientific.

As a small farmer I can honestly say small low tech solutions are amazingly useful in everyday farming. You don't need an expensive American kitchen to get a garden going. Every culture, every person has some amount of trash and waste. Using that trash and waste to garden with is not limited to rich Americans. In many arid areas the simple solution of planting under a tree can work wonders.

The problem with white rice that the GMO rice was trying to cure is economic. Poor people eat a lot of white rice because it is very cheap and frequently one of the few staples subsidized by corrupt governments. Poor families do not have the money to buy a lot of other foods. They can't afford a varied diet to get the carotene they need. So the white rice is just fine if it is eaten with other foods. Richer families do not have problems with getting their balance of carotene. Not everyone who eats rice will suffer from vitamin deficiency. So the real problem here is poverty and corruption and not white rice. What about giving all that GMO research money to those poor people? It will do a lot more for a balanced diet than creating a GMO rice.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

the kick and the rec.... mike_c Aug 2013 #1
I Fucking Love Science.... roseBudd Aug 2013 #6
The Seralini study carla Aug 2013 #15
False. Seralini used Sprague-Dawley rats.... roseBudd Aug 2013 #20
If American companies really wanted to act like they beleived in science, they would truedelphi Aug 2013 #2
You couldn't be more wrong. Perhaps you should research the issue... roseBudd Aug 2013 #7
You couldn't be more wrong. Perhaps you should research the issue... carla Aug 2013 #16
You might want to listen to scientists on Seralini roseBudd Aug 2013 #25
That's quite a word salad. GeorgeGist Aug 2013 #3
there's a common fallacy in dealing with GMOs Defectata Aug 2013 #4
The well fed deciding for those who can barely afford food roseBudd Aug 2013 #8
while engineered foods can grow faster Defectata Aug 2013 #14
Yes, except for Golden rice, Golden Banana, Golden Cassava roseBudd Aug 2013 #22
So many half truths in this article. fasttense Aug 2013 #5
The arrogance of the well fed... roseBudd Aug 2013 #9
The arrogance of using RW talking points that are irrelevant fasttense Aug 2013 #10
rose Budd carla Aug 2013 #17
I think you suffer from confirmation bias roseBudd Aug 2013 #26
Argumentum ad mosantum always degenerates to shill roseBudd Aug 2013 #19
NO evidence to support What Claims?? fasttense Aug 2013 #29
+1 HuckleB Feb 2014 #33
It appears the well fed aren't up to the task of delivering. roseBudd Aug 2013 #24
Wow, you are desperate. fasttense Aug 2013 #30
Science and GMOs aren't the problem and never were. JoeyT Aug 2013 #11
There will be 9 billion people antues Aug 2013 #12
The main problem with brown rice Sentath Aug 2013 #13
Brown rice is not the subject. golden Rice with beta carotene is roseBudd Aug 2013 #18
Beta-carotene rice is a so-so tech solution to an economic problem. Sentath Aug 2013 #21
What a sad statement that the well fed assume that grow a few carrots roseBudd Aug 2013 #23
Thank you for that assult Sentath Aug 2013 #27
As if you are NOT Well Fed? fasttense Aug 2013 #31
I am well fed. Just not an asshole. roseBudd Sep 2013 #32
This looks like a fairly balanced article on this project. Sentath Aug 2013 #28
Latest Discussions»Editorials & Other Articles»Science And GMOs Are Not ...»Reply #5