Editorials & Other Articles
Showing Original Post only (View all)Here's the Biggest Risk With Tesla's Gigafactory [View all]
By Chris Ciaccia
The Street
02/27/14
NEW YORK -- Everyone and their brother went nuts yesterday (myself included) when Tesla Motors unveiled plans for the Gigafactory. After a good night's sleep, a shower and some thinking, it might be time to take a step back and say, "wait a minute."
-snip-
Forget the fact that the Gigafactory is going to be expensive, which is part of the reason why Tesla announced a $1.6 billion convertible debt offering yesterday, as the company continues to grow. All companies need access to capital, and Tesla is no different. The one thing that bothers me is right smack in the company's 10-K filing, which it released yesterday in conjunction with the debt offering and the Gigafactory announcement:
In addition, we have also announced our intent to develop Gen III which we expect to produce at the Tesla Factory after the introduction of Model X. We intend to offer this vehicle at a lower price point and expect to produce it at higher volumes than our Model S. Importantly, we anticipate producing our Gen III vehicle for the mass market and thus we will need a high-volume supply of lithium-ion cells at reasonable prices. While our plan is to attempt to produce lithium-ion cells and finished battery packs for our Gen III vehicles at a new Tesla Gigafactory, our plans for such production are at a very early stage and we have not yet selected a site for the construction of the Tesla Gigafactory nor completed a factory design. In addition, we have no experience in the production of lithium-ion cells, and accordingly we intend to engage partners with significant experience in cell production and to date we have not formalized such partnerships. In addition, the cost of building and operating the Tesla Gigafactory could exceed our current expectations and the Tesla Gigafactory may take longer to bring online than we anticipate. If we are unable to build the Tesla Gigafactory in a timely manner to produce high volumes of quality lithium-ion cells for Gen III at reasonable prices and thus are forced to rely on others to supply us with lithium-ion cells for Gen III, our ability to produce our Gen III vehicles at a price that allows us to sell Gen III profitably could be constrained. Finally, we have very limited experience allocating our available resources among the design and production of multiple models of vehicles, such as Model S (including any variants we may introduce such as right-hand drive), Model X and Gen III. While we intend each of our production vehicles and their variants to meet a distinct segment of the automotive market, our vehicles may end up competing with each other which may delay sales and associated revenue to future periods. Also, if we fail to accurately anticipate demand for each of our vehicles, this could result in inefficient expenditures and production delays. Furthermore, historically, automobile customers have come to expect new and improved vehicle models to be introduced frequently. In order to meet these expectations, we may in the future be required to introduce on a regular basis new vehicle models as well as enhanced versions of existing vehicle models. As technologies change in the future for automobiles in general and performance electric vehicles specifically, we will be expected to upgrade or adapt our vehicles and introduce new models in order to continue to provide vehicles with the latest technology and meet customer expectations. To date, we have limited experience simultaneously designing, testing, manufacturing, upgrading, adapting and selling our electric vehicles."
The part that's bold-faced (I added that) is concerning to me. Tesla wants to build the biggest factory in the world as it relates to lithium-ion cell production, yet it has no experience producing them? That's a bit worrying to me.
More: http://www.thestreet.mobi/story/12459570/1/heres-the-biggest-risk-with-teslas-gigafactory.html