Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

hughee99

(16,113 posts)
61. I'm not arguing that Comey was right to send that message to congress, although I will concede
Tue Nov 1, 2016, 10:22 PM
Nov 2016

that the republicans have him boxed in. He can either come out with info on an ongoing investigation (which he shouldn't) or he can keep his mouth shut and be accused of giving false testimony to congress. I think he attempted to split the baby in two and just made things worse.

But, or course none of this has anything to do with what I've been arguing, which is the state of the Trump-Russia investigation. Now I think we can agree that this investigation can be in one of three states... not started, in progress, or complete. You've suggested that it might be not even started

"In my communications with you and other top officials in the national security community, it has become clear that you possess explosive information about close ties and coordination between Donald Trump, his top advisors, and the Russian government"

If this investigation hasn't even started, then the explosive information isn't from the investigation, so why doesn't Reid just release it. If the investigation is in progress and produced this explosive information, then Comey is doing exactly what he wanted Comey to do in the Clinton investigation, and say nothing about an ongoing investigation. Except that Reid said he wanted Comey to release this information MONTHS ago. If the investigation is complete, and has found this explosive information, why is he not demanding that the information be turned over to the AG's office, which would be the normal process?

All his statement really did was put out there that this information may exist, and that the FBI is covering it up, putting Comey in another bad spot, where he would have to comment on an ongoing investigation, or stick to protocol and look like he's covering it up.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Comey knows there is nothing there and has known so for months. JoePhilly Oct 2016 #1
Rep. Elijah Cummings sums it up best: Coyotl Oct 2016 #4
+ 1 JoePhilly Oct 2016 #15
And he has had the Russian connection DK504 Oct 2016 #24
And cover up of "explosive" Trump/Putin scandal to boot ffr Oct 2016 #2
I believe that Comey might be either bribed or blackmailed. MADem Oct 2016 #3
No, he's just a Republican. That more than covers it. Coyotl Oct 2016 #6
This is not "CT." This is based on the Reid letter. MADem Oct 2016 #8
If this is discovered that Putin is involved with INdemo Nov 2016 #39
He really has that "hostage" look about him PatSeg Oct 2016 #7
He did look that way. MADem Oct 2016 #9
There is something really fishy going on PatSeg Oct 2016 #19
Maybe Putin hacked HIS email, first.... MADem Oct 2016 #20
Oh, oh PatSeg Oct 2016 #21
Hmmmmm! MADem Oct 2016 #30
This is really starting to sound PatSeg Nov 2016 #42
The MUNCH-churian Candidate? He does look like he never misses a meal... nt MADem Nov 2016 #43
An act of desperation on Comey's part to save the dying republican party ffr Oct 2016 #5
Come on, people, rec this up! AwakeAtLast Oct 2016 #10
Comey Has Mischaracterized What The FBI Has DallasNE Oct 2016 #11
I don't agree with Mr Reid. malthaussen Oct 2016 #12
Reid is calling Comey out. The subtext of his comments might as well read thusly: MADem Oct 2016 #22
kick Angry Dragon Oct 2016 #13
K&R...Thanks for posting, EarlG red dog 1 Oct 2016 #16
K & R ...... nt Wounded Bear Oct 2016 #18
Carville: House Republicans, KGB Trying To Affect Democracy Coyotl Oct 2016 #23
So Reid knows what Comey is holding back? Why doesn't he just tell us, then? hughee99 Oct 2016 #25
He did in the accusation, but until unless the FBI confirms it ThoughtCriminal Oct 2016 #27
He didn't really say what the accusation was, just that it's a "bombshell". hughee99 Oct 2016 #28
Depends on what the FBI shared - probably no more than what Reid said ThoughtCriminal Oct 2016 #31
Does the FBI even have proof of anything, or is it still an ongoing investigation? hughee99 Oct 2016 #33
David Corn just confirmed it. MADem Oct 2016 #32
I think Reid may have lost whatever political sense he has left FBaggins Oct 2016 #29
No, you're behind the news cycle. The horse has long left the barn. MADem Oct 2016 #34
According to Reid, he's been asking for the release of this information since long before hughee99 Oct 2016 #35
YEP. Not surprising, since this information has been known by the FBI and others MADem Oct 2016 #36
Based on your link above from David Corn, the FBI has launched a "preliminary inquiry". hughee99 Oct 2016 #37
I've never seen a preliminary inquiry that didn't blossom into something more. MADem Nov 2016 #38
So you think Comey should have handled both situations the same way, to keep his mouth shut until hughee99 Nov 2016 #49
He should have told Congress to pound sand about testifying re: an "open" MADem Nov 2016 #50
So you don't think he should have said anything to congress like the recent letter he sent. hughee99 Nov 2016 #51
What's with the repeated "So you..." stuff? I think I've been quite clear. MADem Nov 2016 #52
I'm trying to make sure I understand what you're saying. I'm trying not to mischaracterize your hughee99 Nov 2016 #53
Reid asked them to INVESTIGATE AND RELEASE a COMPLETED investigation. MADem Nov 2016 #54
"We've no idea if they've even gotten off the dime on that". hughee99 Nov 2016 #55
The point that wooshed by you is that Reid asked for a report on a completed investigation MADem Nov 2016 #56
"I am sure he knows, clearly, just where Comey is at in terms of his lack of progress" hughee99 Nov 2016 #57
Even the NYT is saying "WTF?" And the FBI is "demoralized" for a reason--because this guy fucked up MADem Nov 2016 #58
I'm not arguing that Comey was right to send that message to congress, although I will concede hughee99 Nov 2016 #61
We'd have to know what the "evidence" was to know how it fits into the investigation MADem Nov 2016 #62
If Comey concluded his investigation in July and made his statement, how could he claim in September hughee99 Nov 2016 #63
Sorry, I can't see how that's responsive to what I posted FBaggins Nov 2016 #40
Comey's initial action had a cascading effect. He has, in effect, spilled the jigsaw pieces MADem Nov 2016 #44
Again - we seem to be talking past each other FBaggins Nov 2016 #45
Reid didn't ask Comey to opine--read what Reid was actually asking for. MADem Nov 2016 #46
That's odd spin. What does "opine" have to do with it? FBaggins Nov 2016 #47
Are you being serious? "Opining" is what opened this bag of worms. How soon some forget! MADem Nov 2016 #48
It was? FBaggins Nov 2016 #59
It wasn't Reid's job to condemn. It was COMEY's job to stay above partisan politics. MADem Nov 2016 #60
Dec 1969 #
Dec 1969 #
Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»Video & Multimedia»Pic Of The Moment: Comey,...»Reply #61