Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Video & Multimedia

applegrove

(132,273 posts) Sat Aug 11, 2012, 10:06 PM Aug 2012

Paul Ryan re: "Our rights come from God and nature, not the government" [View all]

Doesn't the link contradict the whole American creation myth? He contradicts himself in the first few seconds. Says American is an idea (which come from men....leaders of the independance movement...the future government I would think follows) and then he says "our rights come from God and nature, not government"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=pMQw6fsF_ts

31 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Paul Ryan re: "Our rights come from God and nature, not the government" [View all] applegrove Aug 2012 OP

So that piece of paper called the constitution means nothing? liberal N proud Aug 2012 #1

I'd be curious how he views the Second Amendment. Buzz Clik Aug 2012 #28

Cue the initiation of the Salem Witch Hunt Trials... MichiganVote Aug 2012 #2

Hey Paulie, you can believe that all you like. One question, though... JHB Aug 2012 #3

+1,000. Thanks for that. freshwest Aug 2012 #8

So God gave you the right to trash nature? bucolic_frolic Aug 2012 #4

Have Heard The God Grants Rights Argument Before - What If God Does Not Exist? cantbeserious Aug 2012 #5

When Republican's speak of such things, what they REALLY mean, is Human Rights... Volaris Aug 2012 #20

My Thoughts Apply To Republicans As They Exist Today - They Would Be Dishonest Then cantbeserious Aug 2012 #22

Ryan twisted what the Declaration of Independence actually says Tx4obama Aug 2012 #6

Thanks. I don't know my american history well enough. applegrove Aug 2012 #9

This... Volaris Aug 2012 #21

Here's a question to Ryan Smilo Aug 2012 #7

Paul Ryan civics fail. At least some of our rights come from government. limpyhobbler Aug 2012 #10

Forget civics, Ryan knows exactly what he's saying meanit Aug 2012 #27

The kicker in Ryan's speech was where he said 'HE WOULD GIVE a RIGHT' (LOL) Tx4obama Aug 2012 #11

Our rights come from God... Norbert Aug 2012 #19

Hmmm FlaGranny Aug 2012 #12

I have rights because I exist. RC Aug 2012 #13

Informed people know our Constitution does not give or grant rights. Our rights are natural, jody Aug 2012 #14

Wow, God Distributes his Opinion..... Grassy Knoll Aug 2012 #15

Ah yes...Paul Ryan, Class of 1988, voted Biggest Brown Noser! SoapBox Aug 2012 #16

Translation: God gave us nature to exploit and Government is in my way! bucolic_frolic Aug 2012 #17

And if Romney-Ryan and the GOP hate the government so much bucolic_frolic Aug 2012 #18

That's how they've used government so far in their careers. Overseas Aug 2012 #24

Scary appeal to those with Faith-Based rather than fact based politics. Overseas Aug 2012 #23

So Proud Liberal Dem Aug 2012 #25

I agree with Ryan on this, although he and I view the principles involved differently Jack Rabbit Aug 2012 #26

Especially if you're a rich White male catbyte Aug 2012 #29

What he means by natural rights is: Might makes Right. tclambert Aug 2012 #30

translation: "I don't want to pay taxes" n/t Enrique Aug 2012 #31