Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

longship

(40,416 posts)
35. But I don't think one can argue that they're qualitatively different.
Sun Mar 18, 2018, 05:42 PM
Mar 2018

For Pete's sake, farmers are forcing mutations using radiation and chemicals. That's even A-Okay with organic farming. Now there is no argument that that isn't safe. (No doubt it is safe.)

I am trying to steer the discussion away from the science, which anybody who understands it agrees that it is settled. Genetic modification is safe, even what you are calling transgenic. But I would prefer not to get involved in semantic arguments here. My field is physics, not biology, so I may not always use the precise terminology. Mea culpa.

However, anybody who claims that GMO is unhealthy simply because transgenic genes might be unhealthy has to answer for the percentage of genes humans already share with all life on Earth. That fact pretty much falsifies that claim. There are no bacteria genes, human genes, ape genes, etc. There are just genes, many of which are shared across the vast landscape of life forms.

And all GMO food is already thoroughly tested for safety. Not one has been shown to be unsafe. Not one!

A good discussion would be to ditch the labeling arguments and discuss regulation and testing. IMHO, that would be a productive avenue.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Bookmarked for viewing later errant boy Mar 2018 #1
K&R&Bookmarking for later. Control-Z Mar 2018 #2
Yep, I definitely want to watch this later. Equinox Moon Mar 2018 #3
Can GMOs be patented? Alternative Facts Mar 2018 #4
Even in non-GMO Ag, seeds are not kept to plant next year. longship Mar 2018 #5
Monsantos Dirty Little Secret Alternative Facts Mar 2018 #9
It always seems to be about Monsanto. Why??? longship Mar 2018 #11
An interesting article that discusses the movie Food Evolution. airplaneman Mar 2018 #6
Um, no shenmue Mar 2018 #7
MONSANTO! Drink! Archae Mar 2018 #8
A couple of things that I have read that usually get breezed over... rwsanders Mar 2018 #10
Well, here. longship Mar 2018 #13
If they are safe then why do so many countries ban them? torius Mar 2018 #12
Because they listen to people who are not scientifically literate. longship Mar 2018 #14
They ban it because of common sense gyroscope Mar 2018 #15
That's not really the same thing. cab67 Mar 2018 #16
The EU doesn't ban GMO, but does mandate labeling gyroscope Mar 2018 #17
Problem with labeling - cab67 Mar 2018 #18
That's your opinion. gyroscope Mar 2018 #20
Not opinion. It's science! longship Mar 2018 #22
Sure, if you believe the industry funded "studies" gyroscope Mar 2018 #23
grummmmmmmble...... cab67 Mar 2018 #27
Ah! The Monsanto ploy again. longship Mar 2018 #28
So the WHO are lying? And there's no corporate money flowing into our universities? gyroscope Mar 2018 #30
Okay. longship Mar 2018 #31
I disagree with one of your claims cab67 Mar 2018 #26
Over 60% of your genes are shared with the Cavendish banana. longship Mar 2018 #29
that's not what transgenic means. cab67 Mar 2018 #33
But I don't think one can argue that they're qualitatively different. longship Mar 2018 #35
no. cab67 Mar 2018 #24
The difference is gyroscope Mar 2018 #32
I'm actually part of the higher education system - professor at a large research university. cab67 Mar 2018 #34
Interesting gyroscope Mar 2018 #37
A better idea cab67 Mar 2018 #38
That could work too gyroscope Mar 2018 #39
some sincere advice - cab67 Mar 2018 #40
To clarify gyroscope Mar 2018 #41
Also - cab67 Mar 2018 #19
Did I say they were? gyroscope Mar 2018 #21
you keep coming back to the issue of Monsanto's trustworthiness. cab67 Mar 2018 #25
dupe gyroscope Mar 2018 #36
Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»Video & Multimedia»Neil deGrasse Tyson gets ...»Reply #35