Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

ancianita

(43,310 posts)
43. Fascism is also a feeling that Trumpists feel, needing a "perceived"strong man leader.
Fri Sep 11, 2020, 11:16 AM
Sep 2020

Which Trump knows. He knows this has happened before. This is a cultural review of people's receptivity to fascist messaging.

And what moved them, in Knausgaard’s view, was not the Nazis’ promise to redistribute income, or Hitler’s analysis of world affairs, or even, initially, their hatred of the Jews. What moved them was, rather, the joyful feeling of togetherness and community, of being able to transcend not only the fragmented democracy of the Weimar period but politics altogether.

“In National Socialism,” writes Knausgaard, “philosophy and politics come together at a point outside the language, and beyond the rational, where all complexity ceases, though not all depth.” Riefenstahl’s film [Triumph of the Will]communicates the pleasure the people experienced—how “good” it felt to them—at having escaped the quotidian chaos of their shabby republic and their trivial private lives, at being liberated from the restrictions of rationality and deliberation, at being on the brink of achieving something large and lasting, deep and simple.



Beginning not long after the 2016 election with the historian Timothy Snyder’s bestseller Tyranny: Twenty Lessons from the Twentieth Century (2017), soon followed by the philosopher Jason Stanley’s How Fascism Works: The Politics of Us and Them (2018), numerous scholars have sought to use historical analysis of the Weimar period to alert Americans to the early signs of fascistic rule. As the Trump presidency has dragged on, these urgent warnings have given way to a wide-ranging debate, including in these pages, about whether such historical analogies are warranted or appropriate.

Understood in relation to that debate, Malick’s and Knausgaard’s artistic treatments of Nazism may persuade us not of the inaccuracy or inappropriateness of such analogies, but of their utter and complete futility—at least insofar as it is claimed such comparisons can inoculate us against repetition. In their focus on the emotional pull of Nazism—its promise to liberate citizens from the frustrations and banalities of an alienated, lonely existence, to connect them with a mass of like-minded souls in “unconditional joy”—the works of Malick and Knausgaard expose us to aspects of how fascism works that it would be laughable to think could yield to academic analysis, no matter how accessibly arranged.

“Establish a private life,” warns Snyder. “Listen for dangerous words.” Do we really imagine it was advice such as this that interwar Germans lacked?


https://www.nybooks.com/daily/2020/08/14/the-unbearable-toward-an-antifascist-aesthetic/?fbclid=IwAR0JbfH134TAdSyZhKQgtp7vgFZgM8QFQ7jqwYMg_yt_YAopymHHNL4zIyo

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

LOL Homicide. KILL ME NEXT. underpants Sep 2020 #1
FANTASTIC! 634-5789 Sep 2020 #2
GOP dirtbag vultures like Tom Cotton and Nikki Haley are circling the corpse of Trump vlyons Sep 2020 #3
Is this photo even real? grumpyduck Sep 2020 #4
Given the creator's track record EarlG Sep 2020 #6
. PunkinPi Sep 2020 #19
I laughed. demmiblue Sep 2020 #29
of course it's photoshopped... AZ8theist Sep 2020 #8
It's getting harder and harder to tell truth from fiction. raccoon Sep 2020 #35
This message was self-deleted by its author raccoon Sep 2020 #36
Who cares? It is The Truth. n/t Tommymac Sep 2020 #11
Oh, it's the truth, grumpyduck Sep 2020 #14
Oh, my. . Nobody said it was an actual pic. Clearly understood to be an accurate representation niyad Sep 2020 #17
Oh, totally accurate. grumpyduck Sep 2020 #21
That was my question. Is this real?? ananda Sep 2020 #24
Kick and recommend. bronxiteforever Sep 2020 #5
Oh shit. This is so true mountain grammy Sep 2020 #7
Art, meet life JDC Sep 2020 #9
Oh, come on -- not one single spelling error ? eppur_se_muova Sep 2020 #10
To be fair EarlG Sep 2020 #13
Okay, you got me. grumpyduck Sep 2020 #16
This Is a masterpiece n/t hibbing Sep 2020 #12
Perfect (except for obvious fotoshopping). I really liked "KEEP LYING TO US". NCjack Sep 2020 #42
Well done! bluewater Sep 2020 #15
The psychology of the death cultists in one image. Well done, EarlG! niyad Sep 2020 #18
EarlG, I don't know how you do it every single time renate Sep 2020 #20
2nd that! Duppers Sep 2020 #28
Yup, you got me this time. grumpyduck Sep 2020 #30
i tell ya, can't fix stupid onetexan Sep 2020 #22
Funny but fake left-of-center2012 Sep 2020 #23
Is worth 1000 words, EarlG Mersky Sep 2020 #25
Sadly this is true Dukkha Sep 2020 #26
More like this, showing what stupid assholes Cult45s are. ffr Sep 2020 #27
I love this paragraph: catbyte Sep 2020 #31
EarlG you've outdone yourself this time! FakeNoose Sep 2020 #32
Thank You Sir May We Have Another Blue Owl Sep 2020 #33
Own the Libs ... GeorgeGist Sep 2020 #34
Listening to c span this am questionseverything Sep 2020 #37
Perfect, EarlG! love_katz Sep 2020 #38
There aren't words for this. idziak4ever1234 Sep 2020 #39
Exactly.. So What we're DEAD. Cha Sep 2020 #40
Just the truth n/t malaise Sep 2020 #41
Fascism is also a feeling that Trumpists feel, needing a "perceived"strong man leader. ancianita Sep 2020 #43
Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»Video & Multimedia»Pic Of The Moment: Trump ...»Reply #43