The DU Lounge

taught_me_patience

(5,477 posts)

87. I thought it was Waters that drove the band apart

Wed May 9, 2012, 02:20 PM

May 2012

Wish You were Here was the culmination of all their work and widely regarded as their best. By the Wall, Waters insisted in writing the lyrics AND music for the whole albumn. There was a marked drop off in music quality in the Wall. The one song on the Wall Waters didn't write the music for... Comfortably Numb.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

93 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Name a musician you dearly love, but admit also produced some unlistenable crap. [View all] Throd May 2012 OP

Neil Young, almost EVERYTHING from the 1980s. 7 albums, 5 of them SUCKED HORRIBLY. Amerigo Vespucci May 2012 #1

I can't dispute a thingle thing you wrote. Throd May 2012 #3

Carly Simon rogerballard May 2012 #18

Weren't those first 80's album done because he wanted to get out of a contract or something? harmonicon May 2012 #21

No, it became antagonistic over a period of time, and he got sued Amerigo Vespucci May 2012 #22

Ok, I knew there was some conflict involving a lawsuit. harmonicon May 2012 #25

The CORE albums, for me... Amerigo Vespucci May 2012 #53

That would coincide perfectly with Neil's flirtation with the Reagan dark side KamaAina May 2012 #30

I didn't mind Trans that much. bluedigger May 2012 #43

Yep. There is a N.Y. concert VHS/DVD release, "Live In Berlin"... Amerigo Vespucci May 2012 #51

This is exactly what I was going to post. tabasco May 2012 #91

Dylan. nolabear May 2012 #2

I don't know about the two gospel albums, but 'Slow Train Coming' is awesome! DutchLiberal May 2012 #62

Led Zeppelin Archae May 2012 #4

Much as it pains me, I have to agree with you Populist_Prole May 2012 #6

Diehard pipi_k May 2012 #34

Never met a led zep song I didn't love OriginalGeek May 2012 #42

I thought 'Coda' was a huge improvement over 'In Through the Out Door' Populist_Prole May 2012 #50

lol, you aren't alone OriginalGeek May 2012 #55

You're the first I heard that discovered LZ so late, but the point is you got there. Populist_Prole May 2012 #72

good point on "too blues" NoGOPZone May 2012 #29

Where to start?! pink-o May 2012 #5

I do like Elton John's "Club At The End Of The Street." Archae May 2012 #8

Yup. Elton and Rod Stewart are prime offenders hifiguy May 2012 #17

Rod Stewart's fall pipi_k May 2012 #35

Tom Waits Rittermeister May 2012 #86

Chris De Burgh. Aristus May 2012 #7

"Don't Pay The Ferryman"--LUV it!! lastlib May 2012 #45

Another good one. Aristus May 2012 #69

David Bowie was a Genius in the 1970's Tabasco_Dave May 2012 #9

Eric Clapton bluesbassman May 2012 #10

He had a slump, but even at his lowest point he was better than most! Bake May 2012 #38

Agreed, the skill was there but no soul. bluesbassman May 2012 #40

Emerson Lake and Palmer - HughBeaumont May 2012 #11

Yeah, but Brain Salad Surgery isn't what most consider "listenable" - well, unless they're wasted. HopeHoops May 2012 #14

I liked most of it, except for the last parts of Karn Evil #9. HughBeaumont May 2012 #60

You mean you didn't enjoy "Love Beach?" Amerigo Vespucci May 2012 #19

Looks like Bee Gees to me....... Burma Jones May 2012 #24

Emerson hated Lake by this point, for sure, hifiguy May 2012 #32

Lake wanted to do pop/folk tunes, Emerson and Palmer wanted to do prog TrogL May 2012 #82

Yup. hifiguy May 2012 #83

Nice mooseknuckle, Keith. HughBeaumont May 2012 #33

Didn't I see him on the Barry Gibb Talk Show??? Bake May 2012 #39

Tori Amos. BlueIris May 2012 #12

Don McLean HopeHoops May 2012 #13

Paul McCartney.... brendan120678 May 2012 #15

Funny, that's one of the only christmas songs I can stand. DutchLiberal May 2012 #63

Metallica. Iggo May 2012 #16

Right on. OriginalGeek May 2012 #44

Agreed. nt Codeine May 2012 #56

Lou Reed - 'nuff said. (nt) harmonicon May 2012 #20

Elvis Presley.....n/t Burma Jones May 2012 #23

HEY NOW! Don't say nothin' bad about The King! Bake May 2012 #41

Ozzy Osbourne Giantsfootball10 May 2012 #26

The Clash. geardaddy May 2012 #27

San Jose's ultra soccer supporters' section is known as the Casbah KamaAina May 2012 #31

I loves me some "Should I Stay or Should I Go?" Arugula Latte May 2012 #36

Yes, it is catchy. geardaddy May 2012 #37

Might not be their best but OriginalGeek May 2012 #46

Well, I knew them before they were big. geardaddy May 2012 #48

lol, it was a running gag among my friends OriginalGeek May 2012 #49

I think this is a very common phenomenon. Almost ubiquitous RZM May 2012 #54

I think you're right. geardaddy May 2012 #80

Yeah, Zappa was the first name I thought of NoGOPZone May 2012 #28

David Byrne bluedigger May 2012 #47

Even the Beatles. Archae May 2012 #52

U2. The Cure. Depeche Mode. Codeine May 2012 #57

ESPECIALLY U2. HughBeaumont May 2012 #58

No way. Zooropa was the Shizz! JVS May 2012 #73

Love and Rockets was a huge disappointment Throd May 2012 #61

Depeche Mode is kind of like a fine wine - some years are just better than others. Initech May 2012 #65

First three albums sucked?! No way. harmonicon May 2012 #74

I liked the first single from Sounds of the Universe, Codeine May 2012 #77

I agree with you about bauhaus, but the Smiths? harmonicon May 2012 #75

I love that song, Codeine May 2012 #76

Bob Dylan: most of 'Self-Portrait' DutchLiberal May 2012 #59

I loved it! Taverner May 2012 #89

David Bowie TorchTheWitch May 2012 #64

Bobby Goldsboro... ScreamingMeemie May 2012 #66

John Lennon NoPasaran May 2012 #67

Pink Floyd made some really bad stuff after the wall taught_me_patience May 2012 #68

Actually I though they sucked from "Dark Side of the Moon" on. bif May 2012 #79

Probably depends if you were into Syd Barrett, Roger Waters or David Gilmour TrogL May 2012 #84

I thought it was Waters that drove the band apart taught_me_patience May 2012 #87

Ahhah FZ was my first thought when I saw the subject! TroglodyteScholar May 2012 #70

Paul McCartney WhoIsNumberNone May 2012 #71

Probably most of them, but the one who first comes to mind is Paul McCartney LeftishBrit May 2012 #78

Philip Glass TrogL May 2012 #81

"Akhnaten" is an incredibly beautiful hifiguy May 2012 #85

I feel like Glass has been on autopilot since the mid 80s cemaphonic May 2012 #90

Lou Reed - Metal Machine Music Taverner May 2012 #88

The Chili Peppers come to mind LeftOfSelf-Centered May 2012 #92

Jefferson Airplane crashing as the Starship kwassa May 2012 #93