Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Orrex

(67,456 posts)
29. Everyone talks about self-checkout screwing people out of their jobs, but is it?
Fri Nov 4, 2022, 08:58 PM
Nov 2022

I'd like to see hard data on that, because everything I've seen and heard so far is suppositional and anecdotal.

It may be that self-checkout leads to attrition, with stores not hiring cashiers to replace those who've left, but is it common practice for stores to terminate cashiers specifically because self-checkouts have been installed?

In any case, that whole objection is a red herring. If an employee costs the company a nickel a day, the company will use any excuse to eliminate that employee if it saves that nickel. Doesn't matter if it's a self-checkout or shelf-stocking robot or a trained ostrich taking out the garbage; if the corporation can do it cheaper, they will.


Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

If I have a few things I do self checkout. If a lot I try and go full service. MLAA Nov 2022 #1
Of course they're helpful, but that's not the issue Merlot Nov 2022 #12
Never show a receipt upon exit Ponietz Nov 2022 #2
Why? , it only takes a few seconds. MichMan Nov 2022 #78
Would you show your receipt to an automated machine on exiting? Ponietz Nov 2022 #79
Yes, if I thought someone might tackle me in the parking lot otherwise Major Nikon Nov 2022 #80
That works for you Ponietz Nov 2022 #82
Good luck with that Major Nikon Nov 2022 #86
The shopkeeper's privilege exists in all 50 states Ponietz Nov 2022 #87
I don't have to be intimidated to see all the holes in your plan Major Nikon Nov 2022 #89
I'm a retired attorney Ponietz Nov 2022 #92
Sometimes I think I'm the only one on DU who doesn't anonymously claim to be a lawyer Major Nikon Nov 2022 #97
Have a nice day Ponietz Nov 2022 #99
You're claiming that ownership is transferred upon the purchase that you refuse to verify Orrex Nov 2022 #93
I don't have to verify it Ponietz Nov 2022 #94
Let's see the list of many lawyers Orrex Nov 2022 #95
Have nice day Ponietz Nov 2022 #96
The bullshit meter is pegging here Major Nikon Nov 2022 #100
What can they do if you just keep walking ? Beachnutt Nov 2022 #3
Depends on the state Major Nikon Nov 2022 #81
They got you on camera every step of the way, when you're in the stores. Why do they need to SWBTATTReg Nov 2022 #4
I take great pleasure in "telling" the self-checkout register agingdem Nov 2022 #5
I use the self-checkout at Kroger since I never have that many items. They only have one doc03 Nov 2022 #6
They probably don't want to spend 14 minutes of their 15 minute break in line FoxNewsSucks Nov 2022 #18
Everyone talks about self-checkout screwing people out of their jobs, but is it? Orrex Nov 2022 #29
They probably don't actually fire them, FoxNewsSucks Nov 2022 #34
But that's nothing new either Orrex Nov 2022 #35
At work, I refuse to learn the computer, and instead I have a secretary take dictation progree Nov 2022 #38
Use self checkout all the time at multiple stores and never get asked for a receipt MichMan Nov 2022 #7
Similar Here ProfessorGAC Nov 2022 #76
I love self-checkouts. Saves me money. I'm underpaid and poor. Why should I care about jobs? Marcus IM Nov 2022 #8
From the first self-checkout I ever saw MOMFUDSKI Nov 2022 #9
I'm a boomer who hates self check out. I kacekwl Nov 2022 #10
As soon as self-checkout appeared in California, Mr.Bill Nov 2022 #11
This is something I know a lot about, I work as a cashier in the garden center at Lowe's dewsgirl Nov 2022 #13
I don't mind self-checkout in some situations localroger Nov 2022 #14
I hear you, but the reason the people with full carts use the self-checkout Trailrider1951 Nov 2022 #54
Costco makes every shopper show their receipt before exiting the store dlk Nov 2022 #15
DU's old-timers may remember the flap about Circuit City Orrex Nov 2022 #25
Best Buy used to do this too. AngryOldDem Nov 2022 #73
The 2 Near Me Don't ProfessorGAC Nov 2022 #77
And Costco self checkouts usually move a lot faster than the lines with cashiers. fierywoman Nov 2022 #27
Costco has workers scanning in the self checkouts dlk Nov 2022 #42
Yeah, they help me all the time. fierywoman Nov 2022 #45
Costco excels at customer service dlk Nov 2022 #61
Same with Sam's Club Simeon Salus Nov 2022 #40
I think membership stores have special rules intrepidity Nov 2022 #55
Costco has the most maddening self-check out. AllyCat Nov 2022 #106
CVS forces self-checkout XanaDUer2 Nov 2022 #16
There's no cashier on duty at all? Orrex Nov 2022 #23
This just started XanaDUer2 Nov 2022 #26
I believe you, but that's a new one for me. (nt) Orrex Nov 2022 #30
We were unhappy campers nt XanaDUer2 Nov 2022 #33
The ones at the CVS I go to most are often out of order. AngryOldDem Nov 2022 #74
Yeah it's more bullshit to make the corporate bottom line better. Fuck humans. Done with Lowecifers, Evolve Dammit Nov 2022 #17
Ah Nostalgia BOSSHOG Nov 2022 #19
Love it judesedit Nov 2022 #20
Then go through the line with an actual cashier Orrex Nov 2022 #21
I don't believe this is true intrepidity Nov 2022 #56
Shopkeeper's Privilege Orrex Nov 2022 #59
Unreasonable detention intrepidity Nov 2022 #66
I'd say that it's up to the courts, but your definition seems unpersuasive Orrex Nov 2022 #68
I was at Kroger one late afternoon. AngryOldDem Nov 2022 #75
I believe you, but I haven't seen that. Orrex Nov 2022 #83
I went through a period that - for some reason - the alarm always went off as I was leaving Walmart. TomSlick Nov 2022 #22
Sounds like the guy who threatened to sue me when his 40-wing bucket contained only 39 Orrex Nov 2022 #39
A there's the point. TomSlick Nov 2022 #41
I'm just about 100% sure that your lawsuit would have failed Orrex Nov 2022 #43
I defend lawsuits in SW Arkansas for a living. I would not be so sanguine about such a defense. TomSlick Nov 2022 #44
Sounds exactly like you want to make a big deal out of, ultimately, nothing Orrex Nov 2022 #46
I think you misunderstood my story. TomSlick Nov 2022 #47
And you apparently misunderstand my position Orrex Nov 2022 #48
I have a rule against alerting on posts attacking me personally. TomSlick Nov 2022 #51
For the record, counsellor: Orrex Nov 2022 #53
It is obvious that no one is reading our little exchange except the two of us. TomSlick Nov 2022 #62
And if I come across an attorney who bullies an underpaid door worker, I call them out Orrex Nov 2022 #63
I suggest we will not reach an agreement. TomSlick Nov 2022 #65
National biscuit company Orrex Nov 2022 #70
Probably so. I've never played dominoes. TomSlick Nov 2022 #71
An attorney who uses strawman to make an argument should know better Major Nikon Nov 2022 #90
:thumbs up: Orrex Nov 2022 #91
I live in East TN TNNurse Nov 2022 #24
It isn't MichMan Nov 2022 #49
I actually prefer self-checkout. ShazzieB Nov 2022 #28
I'm sure that those people only use self-serve gas pumps and walk-in banks, too Orrex Nov 2022 #31
Self-serve gas pumps are the only kind I ever see any more. ShazzieB Nov 2022 #36
I'm with you, believe me Orrex Nov 2022 #37
Odd, at Lunds & Byerlys (grocery chain), they limit self-checkout to 15 items or less progree Nov 2022 #32
I was at Home Depot yesterday. Tracer Nov 2022 #50
Self-checkouts give me anxiety but I use them when I'm feeling brave. IcyPeas Nov 2022 #52
Remember when self-serve gas pumps gave a discount? intrepidity Nov 2022 #57
The few full service pumps that I see generally charge more per gallon Orrex Nov 2022 #60
I fear that, as well intrepidity Nov 2022 #67
Good point. Ditto for cigarettes and certain other products Orrex Nov 2022 #69
They are all "hiring" but no one wants to work for the wages they pay TexasBushwhacker Nov 2022 #58
I went shopping today & I admit that I use self checkout every opportunity I can. elocs Nov 2022 #64
THIS. AngryOldDem Nov 2022 #72
I think that Sams Club is the only place where I avebury Nov 2022 #84
Not a big deal DesertAuthor Nov 2022 #85
I detest self-checkout. 3catwoman3 Nov 2022 #88
My Acme RobinA Nov 2022 #102
I hate those things iemanja Nov 2022 #98
Assembly lines at auto manufacturers use robots, but people still buy their cars.... panader0 Nov 2022 #101
I have never used self check out. Kali Nov 2022 #103
The Walmart I go to now has more people working there Dysfunctional Nov 2022 #104
As a cashier for Walmart... keroro gunsou Nov 2022 #105
Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Dear WalMart, Target, Hom...»Reply #29