Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

The DU Lounge

In reply to the discussion: Anyone Here Have Magic Jack? [View all]

Orrex

(67,398 posts)
7. One (possibly major) and one (minor) thing to consider
Mon Dec 26, 2011, 10:24 PM
Dec 2011

First off, we've had Magic Jack for about 16 months and have had close to zero complaints about it, but we would have liked to know a few things about it before we bought it:

1. The volume on your handset will be tied to your computer's volume, so that when you mute the volume it also knocks the handset volume way down, almost to the point of inaudibility. Not a big deal after you're aware of it, but it still takes like five or six steps to correct each time, and according to the good people at Magic Jack's tech support, there's no way (as of today) to avoid this.

2. Calls to 911 will be handled by an intermediary service. When you call, you'll be prompted for your name and address and a brief overview of the situation. The operator will then say something like "I'm going to put you on hold for a moment while I connect to 911." A few seconds later you'll be put in touch with your local 911 service, and they'll again confirm all of your info, etc.

Seems like an unnecessary extra step, and it can add a full minute to putting the call through, which can be insupportable if you're facing a real-time urgent crisis. Also, if you're trying to teach a young child how to use 911, this extra step can be very confusing.


Despite all of that, we've been very happy with Magic Jack, and it's certainly saved us a ton of money.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Anyone Here Have Magic Jack? [View all] romantico Dec 2011 OP
Love it. It uses a usb port and your broadband connection. Lucinda Dec 2011 #1
Yes, we've had it for a couple of years. auntAgonist Dec 2011 #2
Sounds like a vibrator. undeterred Dec 2011 #3
We did the same thing 2 yrs ago. No landline/tv etc. Highspeed Internet only... jannyk Dec 2011 #4
WOW romantico Dec 2011 #5
it's good but not perfect NJCher Dec 2011 #6
There are certain numbers I can't get through on", like 911? leftyohiolib Dec 2011 #19
One (possibly major) and one (minor) thing to consider Orrex Dec 2011 #7
Thanks romantico Dec 2011 #9
I don't think that the volume issue would happen with the MJ Plus Orrex Dec 2011 #11
So you are going with dry loop DSL? Gold Metal Flake Dec 2011 #8
??? romantico Dec 2011 #10
You are dropping your land line phone, right? Gold Metal Flake Dec 2011 #14
Thanks! romantico Dec 2011 #15
"Sometimes that can reduce your speeds." no it doesnt leftyohiolib Dec 2011 #17
b/c you got a higher speed dsl w/ cable or you had trouble with your phone line leftyohiolib Dec 2011 #18
Dude, you have to deal with the conditions you have. Gold Metal Flake Dec 2011 #22
That sounds painful... NYC_SKP Dec 2011 #16
You really got to work up to it. Gold Metal Flake Dec 2011 #23
My sister has it. RebelOne Dec 2011 #12
How does Majuc Jack compare with Ooma? yellowcanine Dec 2011 #13
We have Ooma and love it. nt Saturday Dec 2011 #20
I have it and it meets my needs. deucemagnet Dec 2011 #21
Something else that just occurred to me about Magic Jack Orrex Dec 2011 #24
I have had Magic Jack for 5 years now. annonymous Dec 2011 #25
Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Anyone Here Have Magic Ja...»Reply #7