The DU Lounge

happybird

(5,400 posts)

22. Ben and Jerry's Brownie Batter

Thu May 4, 2023, 11:46 PM

May 2023

It was discontinued in pints but you can (supposedly) get it by the scoop at the cone shops. It was the best damn ice cream I’ve ever had. Since it’s unavailable, I go for Cherry Garcia and dream of someday enjoying my beloved Brownie Batter again.

Edit to Add:
Years ago, Hagen Daas made a Bailey’s ice cream that was super tasty. My best friend and I bought every pint they had at our Food Lion when we realized it was a limited release.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

111 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Having just seen an ice cream post..... [View all] Upthevibe May 2023 OP

When I'm sick... hippywife May 2023 #1

hippywife...... Upthevibe May 2023 #42

Ben & Jerry's, cherry Garcia or chocolate chip cookie dough Eliot Rosewater May 2023 #2

Eliot Rosewater............ Upthevibe May 2023 #43

Sorry you've been home sick for so long. elleng May 2023 #3

elleng........ Upthevibe May 2023 #44

Noro is going around in these parts, too. Laffy Kat May 2023 #4

Laffy Kat.............. Upthevibe May 2023 #19

I'm in Boulder County, Colorado. Laffy Kat May 2023 #28

Laffy Kat............. Upthevibe May 2023 #29

So glad you're feeling better! Now, I'm sick. LOL. Laffy Kat May 2023 #30

Laffy Kat ....... Upthevibe May 2023 #45

Oh, I'm fine now. It's starting to feel like a vacation. Laffy Kat May 2023 #50

Ben & Jerry's NY Super Fudge Chunk, or Chocolate Therapy... electric_blue68 May 2023 #5

Their black raspberry chocolate chip is heaven. JudyM May 2023 #15

I'm a dark chocohalic through and through... electric_blue68 May 2023 #18

Me too, dark chocolate all the way. JudyM May 2023 #26

Ah, so you Know! 😄👍 electric_blue68 May 2023 #34

How many people do you know that don't like raspberry flavor? Laffy Kat May 2023 #32

My heart goes out to you, Laffy Kat! JudyM May 2023 #33

I'm a weirdo! Laffy Kat May 2023 #36

Oh, really? At least I think one medicine I had as a kid was cherry flavored. 👎 electric_blue68 May 2023 #35

I'll have to look for Chocolate Therapy, it sounds good happybird May 2023 #23

Never have tried the batter types of ice cream. electric_blue68 May 2023 #37

electric_blue68.......... Upthevibe May 2023 #46

Idk. They do have a FB page. I couldn't find anything about that. electric_blue68 May 2023 #84

I'm so sorry you've been under the weather! My favorite brand of ice cream is a local Michigan catbyte May 2023 #6

catbyte........ Upthevibe May 2023 #47

I'll second the Hudsonville brand of ice cream. WestMichRad May 2023 #107

Mango sorbet is... 3catwoman3 May 2023 #54

Coffee Fudge Mopar151 May 2023 #7

Mopar151 ....... Upthevibe May 2023 #48

mmmmmm Coffee Fudge. Is Swensen's still around? yellowdogintexas May 2023 #95

I just finished my.nightly treat wendyb-NC May 2023 #8

wendyb-NC........ Upthevibe May 2023 #49

Uncle Bob's, anything caramel, made in Eureka, IL sinkingfeeling May 2023 #9

sinkingfeeling ............. Upthevibe May 2023 #51

I always go for Haagen Dazs Vanilla Swiss Almond or IcyPeas May 2023 #10

IcyPeas ...... Upthevibe May 2023 #52

I have become almost addicted to moose tracks WhiteTara May 2023 #11

+1000 GuppyGal May 2023 #39

glad to know I'm not alone! WhiteTara May 2023 #40

WhiteTara...... Upthevibe May 2023 #53

prepare to swoon WhiteTara May 2023 #70

Have a Dove Dark Chocolate ice cream bar and you'll be feeling better in no time 😋 Deuxcents May 2023 #12

WhiteTara .......... Upthevibe May 2023 #55

The more chocolate the better Freddie May 2023 #13

You might like Trader Joe's chocolate. SharonClark May 2023 #21

Freddie......... Upthevibe May 2023 #56

Both local PA brands Freddie May 2023 #75

Ah We get Turkey Hill here in NYC, NJ. electric_blue68 May 2023 #87

Blue Bunny is sold in Texas. nt yellowdogintexas May 2023 #96

Moolenium Crunch by Blue Bell. txwhitedove May 2023 #14

xwhitedove...... Upthevibe May 2023 #57

Blue Bell! The Official Ice Cream of Texas. yellowdogintexas May 2023 #97

I was all into Blue Bell until the listeria outbreak in 2015 TexasBushwhacker May 2023 #99

anything in the HEB house brands will be top quality yellowdogintexas May 2023 #100

The Butt family has been very careful about opening new locations TexasBushwhacker May 2023 #102

The Butt family has been very generous in donations yellowdogintexas May 2023 #109

Dreyer's butter pecan. PoindexterOglethorpe May 2023 #16

PoindexterOglethorpe ............. Upthevibe May 2023 #58

Trader Joe's non-dairy Strawberry frozen dessert and their mango sorbet. MLAA May 2023 #17

MLAA .......... Upthevibe May 2023 #60

So glad you are well on the road to recovery! MLAA May 2023 #74

Glad you feel human again! Re Trader's... electric_blue68 May 2023 #85

I always buy Trader Joe's ice cream - SharonClark May 2023 #20

SharonClark ............. Upthevibe May 2023 #61

Ben and Jerry's Brownie Batter happybird May 2023 #22

happybird ........... Upthevibe May 2023 #62

Phish Food Ice cream Rizen May 2023 #24

Rizen .......... Upthevibe May 2023 #63

Ben and Jerry's Phish Food..yum Deuxcents May 2023 #71

I was enjoying FemDemERA May 2023 #25

FemDemERA .... Upthevibe May 2023 #64

Me too! FemDemERA May 2023 #91

Were those in the transparent rectangular gallon containers? If so... electric_blue68 May 2023 #86

Yes, a rounded rectangle FemDemERA May 2023 #92

Yup ty. That was it.... electric_blue68 May 2023 #94

I like to make my own I_UndergroundPanther May 2023 #27

I_UndergroundPanther............. Upthevibe May 2023 #65

Mr YD is a fabulous Ice Cream maker. yellowdogintexas May 2023 #101

I have three favorites...Tillamook, Guernsey Farms, and Jeni's bif May 2023 #31

bif........ Upthevibe May 2023 #66

Tillamook should be available bif May 2023 #73

I sometimes have a "NYC has everything (somewheres storewise)" attitude. bc? Well, NYC: a World City electric_blue68 May 2023 #88

When I traveled I'd often try the local ice creams. 👍 electric_blue68 May 2023 #38

electric_blue68 ........... Upthevibe May 2023 #67

TY It's been a while. And one place I've been to like 9 times for fun and electric_blue68 May 2023 #77

Turkey Hill Chocolate zanana1 May 2023 #41

zanana1 ........ Upthevibe May 2023 #68

Cold Stone Creamery cake batter flavor... 3catwoman3 May 2023 #59

3catwoman3... Upthevibe May 2023 #72

I was quite excited when a CSC store opened up in Times Sq. But a few tries decided it was too sweet electric_blue68 May 2023 #89

we have Cold Stone Creamery and Marble Slab Creamery yellowdogintexas May 2023 #98

Straus ... Northern San Francisco Bay Auggie May 2023 #69

Auggie... Upthevibe May 2023 #79

Breyer's Vanilla for me. Different Drummer May 2023 #76

Different Drummer Upthevibe May 2023 #80

Haagen Daz Rum Raisin llmart May 2023 #78

llmart........ Upthevibe May 2023 #81

Probably just rum flavoring, similar to the vanilla flavoring most common in baking. llmart May 2023 #82

Signature Select Black Walnut AnnaLee May 2023 #83

AnnaLee........ Upthevibe May 2023 #104

It is Safeway brand AnnaLee May 2023 #108

Turkey Hill Cookies and Cream malthaussen May 2023 #90

malthaussen ...... Upthevibe May 2023 #105

It's only been sold on the WC since 2019. malthaussen May 2023 #110

It's all good! Emile May 2023 #93

Butter Pecan Is My Fave ProfessorGAC May 2023 #103

ProfessorGAC ......... Upthevibe May 2023 #106

Feeling better, Upthevibe? True Dough May 2023 #111