Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

The DU Lounge

Showing Original Post only (View all)

edbermac

(16,382 posts)
Mon Jul 14, 2025, 04:13 PM Jul 2025

Man walks into neighbor's yard, cuts down 50-year-old trees to improve his views [View all]

A woman on the vacation island of Nantucket is suing her neighbor after he allegedly walked onto her property and cut down several of her trees for a better view of the ocean — and the increased property value that comes with it.

The lawsuit accuses Jonathan Jacoby of using a chainsaw to fell 16 of Patricia Belford’s nearly 50-year-old cedar, cherry, and Leyland cypress trees.

Three weeks after he allegedly cut down the trees, Jacoby listed his home for sale for nearly $10 million, according to the Boston Globe.

Listed among the home's features: its "sweeping view of the Atlantic Ocean," according to the complaint.

When asked why he destroyed Belford's trees, Jacoby provided a terse response.

"I wasn't trespassing, I was clearing out her crappy trees," he told the Boston Globe in a single-line email.

https://www.yahoo.com/news/nantucket-man-walked-neighbor-yard-171813348.html

What an entitled asshole!

93 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Should put a lien on the house to prevent the sale question everything Jul 2025 #1
Absoloutely! SheltieLover Jul 2025 #52
Plus, he should go to jail. n/t returnee Jul 2025 #66
He really ahould jfz9580m Aug 2025 #90
Hope she wins everything... 2naSalit Jul 2025 #2
In my state, if you do that you're liable for treble the value of the trees removed. rsdsharp Jul 2025 #3
Same here -- Oregon. KPN Jul 2025 #20
Same in Arkansas. TomSlick Jul 2025 #59
Also North Carolina R Merm Jul 2025 #80
That's what the property owner claimed in the lawsuit.Triple damages... Grins Jul 2025 #84
##$@/@+ BASTARD! electric_blue68 Jul 2025 #4
Triple the value of the trees plus lost value with her property IbogaProject Jul 2025 #71
Jerk MustLoveBeagles Jul 2025 #5
She has a good lawsuit /nt bucolic_frolic Jul 2025 #6
Sue him for 10 million. sheshe2 Jul 2025 #7
Wouldn't it be a shame if his $10M house somehow caught fire and burned to the ground. sop Jul 2025 #8
no, 'cause then she'd be out her trees... ret5hd Jul 2025 #10
This message was self-deleted by its author live love laugh Jul 2025 #11
Guess who he voted for? live love laugh Jul 2025 #9
I assume he's the prick who works for Blackstone. Fucker. CurtEastPoint Jul 2025 #12
Crazy eyes and all ... live love laugh Jul 2025 #13
republicon ethics and values suck sewage-pipe oysters BoRaGard Jul 2025 #16
If that's him I'm very surprised he even knew which side of the chainsaw was the handle. Probably a hired tree hit job Cheezoholic Jul 2025 #21
His underwear ZDU Jul 2025 #35
Are you sure that's him? skypilot Jul 2025 #40
Pretty sure. I found a Nantucket based FB group that had a lot of comments about that particular guy CurtEastPoint Jul 2025 #50
Ahh, and auditor for Arthur Anderson onethatcares Jul 2025 #68
there once was a douche from Nantucket... Blues Heron Jul 2025 #14
Perhaps this will fulfill some things limerick.... xocetaceans Jul 2025 #86
Awesome! Bonus for utilizing the word twixt! Blues Heron Jul 2025 #88
Thank you. n/t xocetaceans Jul 2025 #89
He confessed, and then he proved he could pay for damages ... Auggie Jul 2025 #15
Even after he pays for damages, he still makes a profit. Irish_Dem Jul 2025 #33
Yes, but replacing the trees will cost him. Aside from the those, there are also potential fines ... Auggie Jul 2025 #41
He probably has it figured out down to the penny. Irish_Dem Jul 2025 #43
Not necessarily. Trees ain't cheap. localroger Jul 2025 #47
But he is making $10 million on his house. Irish_Dem Jul 2025 #48
A million won't begin to cover it. localroger Jul 2025 #58
How does a financial guru make such a big blunder? Irish_Dem Jul 2025 #63
Hubris. n/t PatrickforB Jul 2025 #76
Damages could be as much as $5 million VMA131Marine Jul 2025 #54
He still pockets $5 million. Irish_Dem Jul 2025 #62
He might have a mortgage... druidity33 Jul 2025 #64
Yes the numbers might not add up the way he hopes. Irish_Dem Jul 2025 #65
If someone cared to look... druidity33 Jul 2025 #67
Maybe he overpaid for the property and is desperate to turn a profit. Irish_Dem Jul 2025 #70
"" AllaN01Bear Jul 2025 #17
It sounds like he already has a buyer defacto7 Jul 2025 #18
More money than brains. Dr. T Jul 2025 #39
He might be ordered to pay or to have new trees planted Grim Chieftain Jul 2025 #19
Shun him? He's already put his house up for sale. tinrobot Jul 2025 #22
$1M per tree Grim Chieftain Jul 2025 #25
I hope Mother Nature pays that weasel a visit. sheshe2 Jul 2025 #34
Hopefully while he's bent over gardening Grim Chieftain Jul 2025 #42
It's not nice to fool mother nature. sheshe2 Jul 2025 #44
Please let us know TNNurse Jul 2025 #23
some people around here do that NJCher Jul 2025 #24
Yes, I have heard other instances of this. LisaM Jul 2025 #27
I would so much rather see trees jfz9580m Aug 2025 #93
Belford points out in her lawsuit that the ocean vistas were "conspicuously missing from the property's prior listings." riversedge Jul 2025 #26
I bet I could bring his property value back down JoseBalow Jul 2025 #28
Lawsuit? My wasn't he arrested for malicious destruction of property and trespassing? sinkingfeeling Jul 2025 #29
This message was self-deleted by its author chowder66 Jul 2025 #31
My question is why this isn't a crime. sinkingfeeling Jul 2025 #32
About 30 years ago, somebody did EXACTLY THAT in my neighbourhood. TrollBuster9090 Jul 2025 #30
I hope the asshole is forced to forfeit his own property in its entirety DFW Jul 2025 #36
This is the 2nd article I've read today where people walked onto slightlv Jul 2025 #37
Omg! SheltieLover Jul 2025 #53
This could be the one. Abolishinist Jul 2025 #56
This is gonna cost him in dollars and prison time. Joinfortmill Jul 2025 #38
$100k per tree X 16 trees X treble damages VMA131Marine Jul 2025 #55
What a jackass! I hope she wins all the Luciferous Jul 2025 #45
His leader dug up the White House malaise Jul 2025 #46
Yup lonely bird Jul 2025 #83
There is NO punishment harsh enough for this rotted soul. What's his name? efhmc Jul 2025 #49
Why is this person not in jail? efhmc Jul 2025 #51
A buyer that knows the story and purchases is just as evil. IA8IT Jul 2025 #57
Could she put up a screen as tall as the trees? fargone Jul 2025 #60
'the view' people SUCK. when my grandparents built a cottage on the 'family lake', she said trees, not lawn. pansypoo53219 Jul 2025 #61
bah humbug AllaN01Bear Jul 2025 #69
The guy cuts down 16 trees, and it would have been better to just build another storey on his house FakeNoose Jul 2025 #72
The confusing headline... eggplant Jul 2025 #73
I lived in coastan New England and I've seen cases like this before Warpy Jul 2025 #74
I planted my honey locust 40 years ago Nittersing Jul 2025 #75
Honey Locust are the best! markie Jul 2025 #78
I hope the wronged neighbor adds goats, chickens, Ilsa Jul 2025 #77
Apparently Mike Love of the BBs did the same thing in his Tahoe Incline Villge neighborhood. nt Exp Jul 2025 #79
File the lawsuit, record a Lis Pendens. flvegan Jul 2025 #81
The house has been on the market for over a year and the price has dropped by 13%. He cut the paulrevere2018 Jul 2025 #82
No doubt a trmp voter. louis-t Jul 2025 #85
I met a guy some years ago, who, together with his partner, took down a large Douglas FIr that they were sure.... BobTheSubgenius Jul 2025 #87
What is happening now? efhmc Aug 2025 #91
I checked the date on this story, because I swear I heard the same thing a couple of years ago. Sogo Aug 2025 #92
Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Man walks into neighbor's...