Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

3catwoman3

(28,701 posts)
84. So many possibilities.
Sun Jan 18, 2026, 09:03 PM
Sunday

My mom was the oldest of 4 - 3 girls, then a boy. The book was given to her when she was about 10, in 1932+/-, and was purchased at a Dayton's department store somewhere in Minnesota, based on a teeny tiny sticker on one of the front pages. She and both her sisters read the book many, many times, and some of the pages have seriously tattered edges, and others are tear-stained from where they all cried over some of the sad parts of the story - or so I was told.

My grandmother had the book re-bound for me in 1963, at the Hutchinson (MN) Maplewood Book Bindery - that is noted in ink, in her handwriting about 3 pages in, under mother's name and street address written in pencil, probably in my mother's somewhat childish hand.

The book has 12 illustrations, including the one on the cover. The artist was a C M Burd - Clara Miller Burd, born in 1873. The cover and 3 of the others illustrations are in color. One B&W illustration page is missing -according to the list of illustrations, there is supposed to be one on page 230, but there isn't. Page 230 is present, but is all print, no picture. She did the illustrations for Little Women in 1925. She also did work in stained glass, and for a time worked for Louis Tiffany of the famous Tiffany lamps.

This book will soon be 100 years old. I consider it a family treasure. An antiques seller on Etsy is offering this same edition for $140.00.

I also loved Madeleine L'Engle's A Wrinkle In Time. I always thought it would make a great movie, and I know 2 versions have been made. I've not seen either of them, as my mind has created such vivid images of all the characters that I'm quite sure I would be disappointed in the movies. I know the 2018 version shows the 3 old ladies as looking rather glamorous, which they definitely do not in the book, and the Murray family was cast as biracial, which makes it impossible for Mrs. Murray to have the flaming red hair and violet eyes that L'Engle so often refers to in the book.

Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Where the Wild Things are Sun-Moon Sunday #1
Thank you , Sun-Moon. I read that book to my class. debm55 Sunday #3
The Black Stallion, I just loved that book. Diamond_Dog Sunday #2
Thank you very much for sharing with us. Diamond_Dog. Also,read to my class. I did a Teacher Read classics for my class. debm55 Sunday #4
Reading aloud is a lost art, good for you Deb! Diamond_Dog Sunday #6
Thank you very much, Diamond _Dog. debm55 Sunday #8
Me, too! pandr32 Sunday #11
The Sound and the Fury by William Faulkner True Dough Sunday #5
Thank you very much for sharing with us. TrueDough. debm55 Sunday #7
Yoknapatawpha County True Dough Sunday #9
I don't remember that one. Thank you for sharing. True Dough. debm55 Sunday #12
That's where The Sound and the Fury was set, deb. True Dough Sunday #15
Thank you Thank you. A recommendation for you would be Hatchet or Julie of the Wolves. Chrispin, or The Island of the debm55 Sunday #19
Oh, I just love it when you are loquacious 🤭 Polly Hennessey Sunday #26
How unusual True Dough Sunday #38
Dang. That was a tough go for me in high school Easterncedar Sunday #53
You read it as a kid? The Blue Flower Sunday #61
Psst... True Dough Sunday #66
Yes don't flatter yourself. And use the sarcasm emoji. debm55 Sunday #78
Oh, look at that! There's a sarcasm emoji! Will I use it? True Dough Sunday #80
You should .if what you are posting is sarcasm. That is why it is there. debm55 Sunday #82
What about these other ones? True Dough Sunday #83
Sorry, I tend to take things literally The Blue Flower 21 hrs ago #154
I grew up with lots of favorites. pandr32 Sunday #10
Wonderful selections, Thank you for sharing with us. pandr32. debm55 Sunday #16
Go Dog Go! I loved the big dog party in the canopy of the tree. applegrove Sunday #13
Thank you very much applegrove. Thank you for sharing your book selection debm55 Sunday #17
I also loved Go Dog Go and could read it before I went to school Diamond_Dog Sunday #20
I was 4 at Montesori. I don't think I ever read it until I read it to my nieces and nephews. applegrove Sunday #21
My mother was a reading teacher Diamond_Dog Sunday #22
My grandmother taught me to read 3 letter words applegrove Sunday #27
Charlotte's Web. mucifer Sunday #14
Thank you very much. I cried at the end of book. But it is a classic. Thank you mucifer. debm55 Sunday #18
"Wind in the Willows." n/t malthaussen Sunday #23
Thank you very much, malthaussen. I loved that classic. debm55 Sunday #25
The Secret Garden MoonlightHillFarm Sunday #24
Thank you very much, MoonlightHillFarm ----another classic. debm55 Sunday #28
Still a favorite Easterncedar Sunday #55
For me always and forever, The Secret Garden. Polly Hennessey Sunday #29
Thank you Polly Hennessey for sharing with us. I loved it too debm55 Sunday #34
Two books, both biographies no_hypocrisy Sunday #30
Wonderful , outstanding books, Thank you, no_hypocrisy, I read the second book in my classroom. Classic books debm55 Sunday #36
I *STILL* have both in my library. no_hypocrisy Sunday #75
I had other books twenty copies of each that we would read together or in reading groups. I took them when I left debm55 Sunday #96
Constantly reading so I will guess MuseRider Sunday #31
Sorry...BOOK MuseRider Sunday #33
Thank you very much, MuseRider. for sharing with us. debm55 Sunday #37
Anne of Green Gables dflprincess Sunday #32
Yes. outstanding book that is a Classic because it held up over generations and time.Thank you dflprincess. debm55 Sunday #40
My favorite childhood book too - Anne the red headed orphan womanofthehills Yesterday #100
Mike Mulligan and the Steam shovel and all of Virginia Lee Burton's other stories Chasstev365 Sunday #35
I read that book to my son. Brings back memories. Thank you Chasstev365 debm55 Sunday #44
As I got older, I loved Nancy Drew, but as a kid I loved The Cricket in Times Square. terip64 Sunday #39
Thank you very much, terip64. I two loved the Nancy Drew series and the Cricket in Times Square. debm55 Sunday #48
I can't believe someone said what was going to be my answer. Xavier Breath Sunday #88
Any of the Nancy Drew or Hardy Boys mysteries Ritabert Sunday #41
Thank you so much. My local library had the complete set of both. They were free at the time. So I read and read. to my debm55 Sunday #49
Charlottes Web samplegirl Sunday #42
Thank you very much, samplegirl for sharing with us. Two greats. debm55 Yesterday #108
All of the above plus... 2naSalit Sunday #43
Thank you very much, 2naSalit. I remember reading through the shelves at our mill town Carnegie Library. Little Women, debm55 Sunday #47
We were... 2naSalit Sunday #50
Thank you very much, 2naSalit. My family wasn't Books took me to places I could only imagine. debm55 Yesterday #121
The Hobbit/LOTR! buzzycrumbhunger Sunday #45
Thank you very much,buzzycrumbhunger. Two outstanding classic. debm55 Yesterday #109
"The Wind in the Willows". Still have it on my bokshelf. sinkingfeeling Sunday #46
Thank you very much for sharing with us, sinkingfeeling. Terrific book. debm55 Yesterday #110
The Enormous Egg Mz Pip Sunday #51
Thank you very much Mz Pip. I went through a period where I was a Nancy Drew addict. debm55 Yesterday #111
A Wrinkle in Time, The Secret Garden Easterncedar Sunday #52
Thank you very much, Eastercedar. Love your selection of books. Fantastic. debm55 Yesterday #112
The Black Stallion biophile Sunday #54
Thank you very much, biophile. I agree with you about the sad places in the book. Reading a book you bond with the debm55 Sunday #60
The Saggy, Baggy Elephant SheltieLover Sunday #56
Thank you very much for sharing with us, SheltieLover. debm55 Yesterday #113
Misty of Chincoteague. I loved that book. n/t livetohike Sunday #57
Loved it to. It is such a beloved classic. Thank you very much for sharing, livetohike. . Have you thougth of reading debm55 Yesterday #115
Bread and Jam for Frances choie Sunday #58
Love your selection, choie. I don't know why, but when I was a kid, Babar scared me. debm55 Yesterday #114
Aw. choie Yesterday #146
I know. but there was something that frigthened me about him. debm55 Yesterday #148
The Boxcar Children PJMcK Sunday #59
Thank you PJMcK, I remember ordering them from Scholastic books . They come came in a decorative box that looked like debm55 Yesterday #116
The World Book Encyclopedia. greatauntoftriplets Sunday #62
I loved reading the World Book yellowdogintexas Yesterday #102
Thank you very much for sharing with us. Love it. debm55 Yesterday #120
Thank you very much, greatauntoftriplets. Very unique. debm55 Yesterday #117
As a younger child I liked reading the Golden Books series. Endlessmike56 Sunday #63
Thank you very much for sharing with us, Endlessmike56. Call of the Wild---classic. debm55 Yesterday #119
Franz: a Dog of Police Rhiagel Sunday #64
Thank you Rhiagel for sharing. Great post. debm55 Yesterday #122
Great topic. Harriet the Spy Alpeduez21 Sunday #65
Great and varied selections of books. Thank you very much, Alseduez21. debm55 Yesterday #123
Two series of books, The Sci-fi/fantasy books by Andre Norton and the Tom Swift books by Victor Appleton. wcmagumba Sunday #67
Terrific series of books. Thank you for sharing with us, wcmagumba. debm55 Yesterday #124
Little Shepherd of Kingdom Come UpInArms Sunday #68
Thank you very much, UpInArms. I went to your link and it sounds wonderful . I can see why you fear it more then 20 debm55 Yesterday #129
The Phantom Tollbooth surrealAmerican Sunday #69
likewise jgo Sunday #98
Great book. Thank you for sharing surrealAmerican. You should read it again. debm55 Yesterday #130
The Time Machine and War of the Worlds. H. G. Wells was ahead of his time. Borogove Sunday #70
Classic books. Thank you for sharing, Borogove. You should read them again. debm55 Yesterday #132
Treasure Island, Robert Louis Stevenson Onthefly Sunday #71
Thank you very much, Onthefly. Loved that book debm55 Sunday #97
Cherry Ames series zeusdogmom Sunday #72
Excellent selections, especially the second.Thank you for sharing with us. Three Came Home lit a spark in you. Sometimes debm55 Sunday #95
Kim by Rudyard Kipling chowmama Sunday #73
Thank you very much for sharing with us.chowmama. Love your selection. debm55 Sunday #94
Salem's Lot. Read it many times by age 12. (n/t) OldBaldy1701E Sunday #74
Thank you OldBaldy1701E for sharing with us. debm55 Sunday #93
Half Magic by Edward Eager nikatnyte Sunday #76
Thank you very much, nikatnyte. Half Magic. sounds very interesting. debm55 Sunday #91
The Jungle Book FullySupportDems Sunday #77
Thank you very much, FullySupportDems. debm55 Sunday #79
Anderson's Fairy Tales, 1930 edition some_of_us_are_sane Sunday #81
Thank you very much for sharing that Fairy Tale . Wonderful. Thank you some_of_us_are_sane debm55 Sunday #92
So many possibilities. 3catwoman3 Sunday #84
A Wrinkle inTime is a great book. I have never seen the movies, but have read it to my class and they loved it as did I debm55 Sunday #89
I'm thinking National Velvet, Black Beauty. But very soon after... electric_blue68 Sunday #85
Thank you very much electric_blue68. I couldn't remember the name of another book I read and it was "A Wrinkle in Time" debm55 Sunday #86
Little house on the prairie ExtraGriz Sunday #87
Thank you very much, ExtraGritz for your two selections. Excellent choices debm55 Sunday #90
"The Hobbit". I got a copy after seeing the animated TV version in 1978. Aristus Yesterday #99
Thank you very much, Aristus. for sharing with us. You sound like a huge fan of the classic. debm55 Yesterday #133
Very much. Aristus Yesterday #135
The Betsy-Tacy books, set in Minnesota. LisaM Yesterday #101
Thank you very much, LisaM, for sharing with us. It sounds familiar. debm55 Yesterday #134
There were several favorites yellowdogintexas Yesterday #103
Thank you very much for sharing with us, yellowdogintexas. Love your selections,except for Babar--frightened me for some debm55 Yesterday #136
Two actually - Charlotte's Web and Anna and the King of Siam. nt woodsprite Yesterday #104
Two classics. Thank you very much for sharing with us. woodsprite. debm55 Yesterday #138
Tom Sawyer.. Permanut Yesterday #105
Thank you very much, Permanut for sharing the first book you ever read. Iconic book. not always politically correct but debm55 Yesterday #139
ZOTS multigraincracker Yesterday #106
Thank you, multigraincracker. debm55 Yesterday #107
Oh my goodness, where to start? mwmisses4289 Yesterday #118
Thank you very much for sharing with us mwmisses 4289 debm55 Yesterday #147
"The Old Man and the Sea" by Ernest Hemingway Emile Yesterday #125
HAHAHHAHHA. thank you very much, Emile. debm55 Yesterday #143
Dr Seuss.... Anything. C_U_L8R Yesterday #126
I loved Dr. Seuss. Classic reads for both children and adults with a funnybone. Thank you very much for sharing, C_U_L8R debm55 Yesterday #144
A. C. Clark: The Promise of Space Layzeebeaver Yesterday #127
Thank you very much, Layzeebeaver. Great. debm55 Yesterday #145
The Jerry Todd books... MiHale Yesterday #128
Thank you very much for sharing with us. MiHale. All of your selections are tremendous. debm55 Yesterday #142
Pippy Longstocking KT2000 Yesterday #131
Thank you very much for sharing with us, KT2000, I loved that book. did it come in a series? debm55 Yesterday #141
Just the one I knew about KT2000 23 hrs ago #149
Thank you, KT2000 debm55 21 hrs ago #150
All of a kind family kimbutgar Yesterday #137
Thank you very much for sharing with us, kimbutgar. It sounds like a sonderful book. and you got a signed book-wonderful debm55 Yesterday #140
Nancy Drew when a bit older & anything with horses SheltieLover 21 hrs ago #151
Thank you very much, SheltieLover, for your selections. debm55 21 hrs ago #153
Henry Huggins universe. (Ramona, Beasus, Ribsy) Thunderbeast 21 hrs ago #152
Thank you very much, Thunderbeast. Beverly Cleary was a terrific writer for children debm55 21 hrs ago #155
The Wahoo Bobcat Lochloosa 21 hrs ago #156
Thank you very much, Lochloosa. That sounds interesting. debm55 21 hrs ago #157
The Whipping Boy debm55 21 hrs ago #158
My Side of the Mountain by Jean George Botany 20 hrs ago #159
Wonderful book , Thank you very much for selecting it, Botany debm55 20 hrs ago #160
The Nancy Drew series. Easy way to win the most books read contest in sixth grade. marble falls 19 hrs ago #161
HAHAHAHAHHAHA. Thank you very marble falls. That's funny. debm55 19 hrs ago #162
Number the Stars. I read it along with my class. And the Diary of Anne Frank Excellent book's debm55 4 hrs ago #163
Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»As a child, what was you ...»Reply #84