Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

aint_no_life_nowhere

(21,925 posts)
78. I have
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 04:45 PM
Feb 2014

Unfortunately, it's not my cup of tea. I just don't see Mr. Cumberbatch as incarnating Sherlock Holmes, not the way the three great actors who previously played him have: Basil Rathbone, Jeremy Brett, and Peter Cushing. And I don't think the 21st century is a proper setting for the Holmes stories. Much of the charm of Holmes resides in the fact he used cutting edge forensics and psychological profiling during the Victorian era. Nowadays, with advances in police science, there is much less for him to do in the modern era that sets himself apart as a great superhero that he was in the 1890s. And in the original Conan Doyle stories there's the interesting contrast between Holmes and the many aristocrats who he deals with who have to come begging for his help; Holmes, somewhat misanthropic and arrogant, was at ease among the masses as well as in any social strata and was beyond social class, a distinctive superhero quality really missing when the story is based in the 21st century. Holmes could get away with insulting even Kings, the way he did at the end of A Scandal In Bohemia where he refused to shake his client the King's hand and insulted him without the King's realizing it when he suggested that the woman the King refused to marry, a commoner, and whose photo Holmes was hired to retrieve, Irene Adler, was clearly not at the King's social level (expressed in a sarcastic way by Holmes which is understood to imply that she was at a higher level than the King).

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Its unbelievable how many movies I'll watch over and over... nirvana555 Feb 2014 #1
i never get sick of office space fizzgig Feb 2014 #3
Good choices AnneD Feb 2014 #98
One thing about "The Fugitive": Brigid Feb 2014 #4
You know that Nichols was the main villain, right? As in, arranged everything? WinkyDink Feb 2014 #12
Of course Nichols was the mastermind. Brigid Feb 2014 #21
i need to watch that again fizzgig Feb 2014 #2
I've probably watched Yellow Submarine 50 times or more Art_from_Ark Feb 2014 #5
Oh gosh, it's embarrassing how many! Ino Feb 2014 #6
Fargo. Smarmie Doofus Feb 2014 #57
I'm goin' crazy out there at the lake! Ino Feb 2014 #71
Don't sound like too good a deal for HIM. n/t Smarmie Doofus Feb 2014 #82
12 O'Clock High, Casablanca Sherman A1 Feb 2014 #7
Agree with North by Northwest & The American President. I also can watch.... mrmpa Feb 2014 #48
The Best Years of Our Lives is another great one Sherman A1 Feb 2014 #55
I'm a real Sherlock Holmes nut aint_no_life_nowhere Feb 2014 #8
You should check out free old time radio recordings of Sherlock Holmes: mucifer Feb 2014 #9
Bookmarked - thanks aint_no_life_nowhere Feb 2014 #19
Not a movie but.... clarice Feb 2014 #74
I have aint_no_life_nowhere Feb 2014 #78
I agree. My favorite SH movie is "Murder by Decree" nt clarice Feb 2014 #79
I, too, can watch many over and over again MissMillie Feb 2014 #10
Ty's "Zorro"; "GF I&II"; "Jaws"; "Hoosiers"; "French Connection"; Basil's "S.H."; Bournes; "Dirty WinkyDink Feb 2014 #11
Nothing, I don't like watching movies over and over. Xyzse Feb 2014 #13
I saw 'Labyrinth" over a hundred times as a teenager. Aristus Feb 2014 #14
I love Local Hero, need to see that again... bettyellen Feb 2014 #80
I lived in Houston at that time... AnneD Feb 2014 #99
So many movies. geardaddy Feb 2014 #15
Fargo. Smarmie Doofus Feb 2014 #56
White Men Can't Jump , Casablanca HERVEPA Feb 2014 #16
"Pitch Black" with Vin Diesel. I love that man. RebelOne Feb 2014 #17
I always tell my son "Pitch Black" was better than "Star Wars." It has kairos12 Feb 2014 #76
Riddick wins hands down. n/t RebelOne Feb 2014 #81
We just picked up the Riddick trilogy set and... rppper Feb 2014 #94
Groundhog Day. Princess Bride. Spinal Tap. O Brother Where Art Thou. Fletch. Three Amigos. Common Sense Party Feb 2014 #18
The Inlaws. Demoiselle Feb 2014 #20
Tons! Initech Feb 2014 #22
I'll have to check out Kevin Smith movies... MrMickeysMom Feb 2014 #35
Clerk's, Mallrats, and Dogma are his best. Initech Feb 2014 #38
Who did he play in Dogma (one of my favorites) ??? MrMickeysMom Feb 2014 #39
Silent Bob Initech Feb 2014 #40
Oh! MrMickeysMom Feb 2014 #47
Clerks--"a bunch of savages in this town." "I wasn't even supposed to be here today." kairos12 Feb 2014 #87
"I don't watch movies!" Initech Feb 2014 #88
Great list! nt ZombieHorde Feb 2014 #52
Ghost World, This is Spinal Tap, Wings of Desire n/t PasadenaTrudy Feb 2014 #23
CHARIOTS OF FIRE! CTyankee Feb 2014 #24
The Court Jester Graybeard Feb 2014 #25
I am with you there.. solara Feb 2014 #67
I often watch favorite films solara Feb 2014 #68
Polyester libodem Feb 2014 #26
Blazing Saddles. n/t A Simple Game Feb 2014 #27
I forgot Mel Brooks on my list leftynyc Feb 2014 #70
Almost any Mel Brooks film for me. n/t A Simple Game Feb 2014 #84
Dark Star, RepoMan, Big Lebowski Kali Feb 2014 #28
Big Lebowski, Kali…. MrMickeysMom Feb 2014 #34
I often prefer to rewatch a film I really like tavernier Feb 2014 #29
Men in Black for me :D Mrdrboi Feb 2014 #30
Bullitt, Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, 2001, 8 track mind Feb 2014 #31
Brigid, re: The Fugitive- I think the whole reason that the "one armed man" killed nirvana555 Feb 2014 #36
Agatha Christie wrote of a perfect plot to kill and have the target convicted. WinkyDink Feb 2014 #62
I love "Velvet Goldmine". Great music, great plot - I think I'll watch it again tomorow LynneSin Feb 2014 #32
Ooh, that is a good one. WorseBeforeBetter Feb 2014 #91
That's a good one for me, too... MrMickeysMom Feb 2014 #33
Get Shorty Brother Buzz Feb 2014 #37
That is a good one. kairos12 Feb 2014 #86
Excellent.... AnneD Feb 2014 #100
Drive Raffi Ella Feb 2014 #41
A few DFW Feb 2014 #42
Cabaret, Doctor Zhivago rurallib Feb 2014 #43
Very visual films - David Lean's films, any of the Qatsi films (Koyaanisqatsi, Powaqqatsi), closeupready Feb 2014 #44
Star Wars, Indiana Jones, Galaxy Quest mainer Feb 2014 #45
I'm on a big "Perks of Being a Wallflower" kick. WorseBeforeBetter Feb 2014 #46
That's a *great* movie Rob H. Feb 2014 #65
Awww. :-) WorseBeforeBetter Feb 2014 #89
Me, too! Rob H. Feb 2014 #102
Alexander Nevsky, Battleship Potemkin Sognefjord Feb 2014 #49
Vertigo, Rope, Shadow of a Doubt, Suspicion, North by Northwest ailsagirl Feb 2014 #50
My favorite NBN scene is the matchbook throw. WinkyDink Feb 2014 #61
I have a bunch. Here are some in reverse alphabetical order starting with the second letter... ZombieHorde Feb 2014 #51
Any Hitchcock or Kubrick movie I'll always watch. edbermac Feb 2014 #53
I like Kubrick too Sherman A1 Feb 2014 #54
All About Eve. Smarmie Doofus Feb 2014 #58
Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid BarbaRosa Feb 2014 #59
Amélie, Amadeus, and The Doors (Stone) KurtNYC Feb 2014 #60
Bad Santa.. sendero Feb 2014 #63
John Carpenter's "The Thing" Rob H. Feb 2014 #64
Love that movie. hrmjustin Feb 2014 #73
Since it hasn't been mentioned yet: Blue_Tires Feb 2014 #66
Casablanca, All About Eve, leftynyc Feb 2014 #69
2010. hrmjustin Feb 2014 #72
The Shootist. nt clarice Feb 2014 #75
L.A. Confidential kairos12 Feb 2014 #77
Yes that is an instant classic. applegrove Feb 2014 #85
as a former resident of LA, I love this film. kwassa Feb 2014 #95
Canadian Bacon and Mystery Science Theater 3000 Submariner Feb 2014 #83
Goodfellas, casino, full metal jacket.... rppper Feb 2014 #90
I liked Waterworld too. I don't know why it got panned. applegrove Feb 2014 #92
It was a good sci-Fi flick... rppper Feb 2014 #93
Monty Python and the Holy Grail TorchTheWitch Feb 2014 #96
Anything Coen bros Boom Sound 416 Feb 2014 #97
I'd forgotten how many there are . . . R. P. McMurphy Feb 2014 #101
Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»What movie can you watch ...»Reply #78