The DU Lounge

Mike Daniels

(5,842 posts)

9. Speaking of the season at the farm....did have a question regarding something I saw upon rewatching

Wed Oct 15, 2014, 12:23 PM

Oct 2014

Shortly after arriving on the farm Rick mentions that they were looking for Sophia (describing her general appearance). At that point I noticed that Maggie gives Herschel a certain look and Herschel discretely shakes his head "no" in response.

After the cleansing of the barn, Maggie and Herschel claimed innocence of ever knowing that Sophia was already "dead" (stating that Otis rounded up the walkers). However, upon rewatching that scene (I didn't catch the silent looks when the episode first aired) I have wondered if they were well aware that Sophia was in their custody but Herschel simply didn't want to reveal that he was keeping walkers alive in the barn.

Just seeing if anyone remembers the moment and their thoughts on that possibility.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

15 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Is Walking Dead good again or is it just more ponderous bullshit? [View all] ReverendDeuce Oct 2014 OP

The first episode this season was all action and violence. The second episode airs Sunday. LonePirate Oct 2014 #1

Okay... ReverendDeuce Oct 2014 #2

It returned to its roots for one episode. Who knows about the remaining 15 in this season. LonePirate Oct 2014 #3

I don't think it was ever "not good" but this season is only one episode old dr.strangelove Oct 2014 #4

Okay, let me stop you at the first sentence... ReverendDeuce Oct 2014 #7

I am not sure association your comments with Michael Bay is self-righteous dr.strangelove Oct 2014 #10

Your OP was a bit pejorative regarding shows that this other poster really likes. Threedifferentones Oct 2014 #14

Observations about a TV show in the "lounge" is not a personal insult... ReverendDeuce Oct 2014 #15

Speaking of the season at the farm....did have a question regarding something I saw upon rewatching Mike Daniels Oct 2014 #9

I think that was about killing walkers, not about Sophia dr.strangelove Oct 2014 #11

Don't watch it. You won't like it. Iggo Oct 2014 #5

in the last two episodes d_r Oct 2014 #6

well, it wasn't that predictable, I thought NewJeffCT Oct 2014 #8

Yeah you are right d_r Oct 2014 #12

First episode this season was wall to wall staby-staby and shoot em in the back. GOLGO 13 Oct 2014 #13