Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

So Far From Heaven

(354 posts)
49. I wouldn't worry too much about ecological problems or global warming using pulp wood trees.
Thu Mar 17, 2016, 01:24 AM
Mar 2016

Southern pulp wood trees have been hybridized (not GMO but natural) to be extremely fast growing. Since the original trees were cut down ages ago, there isn't any real net ecological damage, and since the carbon is already in the system it is generally considered to be carbon neutral. That is why virtually all biofuels are also considered carbon neutral.

What is environmentally detrimental are the processes used in converting the cellulite material to fibres necessary to make paper. I'm not sure which is worse, wood or plant.

As far as global warming goes, the concern is the industrial energy source for the manufacture and transportation. Products made in China contribute substantially more carbon pollution than products made in every other industrialized country. Transportation is one of the 'hidden' global warming problems being totally ignored by both consumers and the IPCC. An example is the US. Our transportation contribution to our total carbon output is only slightly smaller than our energy production contribution. This is one reason why a large number of us consider the Paris agreement to be a total failure.

I agree wholeheartedly that a US manufactured paper that uses the basic ingredients you prefer would be much more desirable. Unfortunately, this probably falls into the category of why capitalism isn't going to mitigate global warming.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

My favorite used to be a brand carried by Costco intrepidity Mar 2016 #1
It depends on the purpose that I'm using it for. TexasTowelie Mar 2016 #2
I always use Scott, 'cause, Governor Scott. eom Laffy Kat Mar 2016 #3
! rurallib Mar 2016 #4
I switched to Scott because Charmin and Cottonelle left too much lint when the paperwork was done. In_The_Wind Mar 2016 #5
Charmin from Costco. Kingofalldems Mar 2016 #6
fairly sure Scott is owned by Kimberly-Clark which is James Sensenbrenner rurallib Mar 2016 #16
No, Scott is not owned by KB. I checked. eom Laffy Kat Mar 2016 #26
Scott PasadenaTrudy Mar 2016 #7
The exact reason I use Scott. avebury Mar 2016 #52
Scott blogslut Mar 2016 #8
I use whatever is the best deal at the time I need to buy it. GoCubsGo Mar 2016 #9
Costco........without a doubt....eom mrmpa Mar 2016 #10
Angel NV Whino Mar 2016 #11
BJ's house brand -Berkley Jenson dr.strangelove Mar 2016 #12
If I have to tell you why, you've got bigger problems than picking a brand! Orsino Mar 2016 #13
Scott, for sure. cyberswede Mar 2016 #14
1)Whatever is on sale 2) Because it beats using sandpaper Major Nikon Mar 2016 #15
i would substitute junk mail for #2 restorefreedom Mar 2016 #21
The Farmer's Almanac. malthaussen Mar 2016 #17
Cheap generic single ply no name crap Hayduke Bomgarte Mar 2016 #18
Charmin Ultra Soft PennyK Mar 2016 #19
I'm a former Scott user, but now I buy these as well. phylny Mar 2016 #56
Scott. Cottenelle was getting to the point where the roll goes so fast it seemed to be evaporating. Gidney N Cloyd Mar 2016 #20
basic Scott is easiest on balky plumbing annabanana Mar 2016 #22
Charmin or Cottonelle Populist_Prole Mar 2016 #23
Charmin - no matter how tight our wallets get nadine_mn Mar 2016 #24
yep CTyankee Mar 2016 #53
I prefer a nice quality double ply. Quilting is nice, a little extra niceness for the tushy and underahedgerow Mar 2016 #25
your last line is basically what prompted me to do a survey rurallib Mar 2016 #27
Kora Brand. It's made from bamboo. Fast-growing, no trees cut, septic-safe bamboo. No BPA, as in valerief Mar 2016 #28
looks quite interesting rurallib Mar 2016 #29
Nope. TP comes from China, however, but so doesn't everything else. valerief Mar 2016 #31
I looked at their amazon reviews. Pretty stellar rurallib Mar 2016 #33
I'm desynthesizing as much of my grooming and cleaning products as possible to valerief Mar 2016 #34
I wouldn't worry too much about ecological problems or global warming using pulp wood trees. So Far From Heaven Mar 2016 #49
I just checked the packaging. valerief Mar 2016 #32
Scott. Charmin clogs old, narrow pipes. DamnYankeeInHouston Mar 2016 #30
I use the Sears-Roebuck catalog, you bunch o' wimps. Orrex Mar 2016 #35
I disagree. JC Penney is much better than Sears. Unless its a really old black and white Sears. So Far From Heaven Mar 2016 #48
Cottonelle Capt. Obvious Mar 2016 #36
Consumer Reports toilet paper ratings: IcyPeas Mar 2016 #37
Why do I use toilet paper? Thor_MN Mar 2016 #38
I refuse to use any TP that is 'Quilted' LynneSin Mar 2016 #39
Kirkland from Costco...nice on the bum mackerel Mar 2016 #40
we replaced our toilets a couple of years ago rurallib Mar 2016 #41
Kirkland is a good quality at a good price. nt ohnoyoudidnt Mar 2016 #57
Quilted Northern JVS Mar 2016 #42
Trader Joe's... I can walk there to reload when I run out. KeepItReal Mar 2016 #43
I do not use toilet papermade by the Koch brother's companies CajunBlazer Mar 2016 #44
Charmin 2-ply on mega rolls aikoaiko Mar 2016 #45
Free. ghostsinthemachine Mar 2016 #46
Up and Up - Target brand Iris Mar 2016 #47
Whatever is made from 100% recycled paper. roody Mar 2016 #50
Scott's does not shred if it ends up in the wash - hubby uses it like Kleenex, then patricia92243 Mar 2016 #51
Just found my new favorite pokerfan Mar 2016 #54
never heard of it - where is it available? rurallib Mar 2016 #55
Washington State, at least pokerfan Mar 2016 #58
3M... Hotler Mar 2016 #59
Usually Charmin liberalfromaustin21 Mar 2016 #60
Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Question: What type of to...»Reply #49