Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

progressoid

(53,342 posts)
25. Good list but...
Sun May 1, 2016, 11:56 PM
May 2016

I've seen that before but I'm not sure they should have included 'Superstition'. How and who wrote it is a little vague.

I like both versions. A LOT.

Beck was present in the studio when Wonder wrote the track. In fact, it all started with a drumbeat Beck came up with while noodling around between takes in the studio where he’d been asked to join Wonder during the sessions for what became 1972’s Talking Book album...The original agreement was that he’d write me a song, and in return, I’d play on his album, and that’s where ‘Superstition’ came in.”

Beck went into the story in a bit further detail in Annette Carson’s book Jeff Beck: Crazy Fingers, saying, “One day I was sitting at the drum kit, which I love to play when nobody’s around, doing this beat. Stevie came kinda boogieing into the studio: ‘Don’t stop.’ ‘Ah, c’mon, Stevie,’ I can’t play the drums.’ Then the lick came out: ‘Superstition.’ That was my song, in return for Talking Book. I thought, ‘He’s given me the riff of the century.'”

...

As Beck remembered it in The Guitar Greats, Wonder “basically wrote it for me, but the story goes that he loved it a bit too much. No, he played it to Motown, and they said, ‘No way is Beck getting this song, it’s too good’ and, as they had the right to say what Stevie released at that time, I lost the song as an original.”

Wonder offered his version of events during an interview with Ben Fong-Torres, recalling, “Motown decided they wanted to release ‘Superstition.’ I said Jeff wanted it, and they told me I needed a strong single in order for the album to be successful. My understanding was that Jeff would be releasing ‘Superstition’ long before I was going to finish my album. I was late giving them Talking Book. Jeff recorded ‘Superstition’ in July, so I thought it would be out.”


Read More: The History of 'Superstition,' the No. 1 Song Stevie Wonder Stole From Jeff Beck | http://ultimateclassicrock.com/stevie-wonder-jeff-beck-superstition/?trackback=tsmclip


Kind of like 'Because the Night" is attributed to Patti Smith but was a song fragment of Springsteens that was given to her and she made it her own.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Leningrad Cowboys Red Army Choir SWEET HOME ALABAMA Ptah May 2016 #1
OMG! dixiegrrrrl May 2016 #5
Well, mine is pretty obvious, but here goes: Coventina May 2016 #2
Can't top that, even with Chimes of Freedom. Hoyt May 2016 #3
Yeah, even though I'm a child of the 80's, that's pretty much the Holy Grail of covers, IMHO. Coventina May 2016 #4
"My Back Pages" gets my vote. mac56 May 2016 #10
+1 sl8 May 2016 #17
Cannot find it online anywhere, but..... lastlib May 2016 #6
Hendrix's version was a cover too--of Dylan's original. panader0 May 2016 #45
you are correct--but AFAIAC, lastlib May 2016 #62
Patti Smith's cover of Dylan's Changing of the Guards discntnt_irny_srcsm May 2016 #7
I could probably list ten excellent covers. Here's one more: Ptah May 2016 #8
Little Wing- Sting Texasgal May 2016 #9
Stevie Ray Vaughan did a good cover of that too Cheese Sandwich May 2016 #34
Firework Major Nikon May 2016 #11
uhhh......errrr...... dixiegrrrrl May 2016 #14
I lasted 4 seconds. progressoid May 2016 #18
You're a better man than I am, Gunga Din Major Nikon May 2016 #19
My standard reply to this one....Hurt - Johnny Cash Wounded Bear May 2016 #12
That was going to be my reply as well. 47of74 May 2016 #40
Well, to really nail this song... Wounded Bear May 2016 #42
Dave Edmunds--New York's a Lonely Town Kingofalldems May 2016 #13
Mad World sl8 May 2016 #15
I liked Linda Ronstadt's version of "Heat Wave" better than... ailsagirl May 2016 #16
ooooh...I agree. dixiegrrrrl May 2016 #22
On a related note: sl8 May 2016 #20
Good list but... progressoid May 2016 #25
Thanks for the background on "Superstition." sl8 May 2016 #50
Just one? Hendrix - All Along the Watchtower. progressoid May 2016 #21
Changed my mind. Aretha - Respect. progressoid May 2016 #26
No. Wait. George Benson - On Broadway progressoid May 2016 #27
OK, I got it now. They Might Be Giants - Istanbul (not Constantinople) progressoid May 2016 #28
Nah, I prefer the Four Lads. n/t malthaussen May 2016 #36
I love both! n/t drmeow May 2016 #67
I thought of saying that My Good Babushka May 2016 #76
Chris Cornell's version of "Nothing Compares 2 U" Parker CA May 2016 #23
Whip My Hair sl8 May 2016 #24
Another one....Ring of Fire, by Home Free dixiegrrrrl May 2016 #29
If we're doing Ring of Fire... jmowreader May 2016 #61
Spooky Tooth - I Am The Walrus GReedDiamond May 2016 #30
That's a version I've never heard before. progressoid May 2016 #35
I rather liked that. Throd May 2016 #49
Luna's cover of Santo & Johnny's 'Sleepwalk' SeattleVet May 2016 #31
I'll give you three The Second Stone May 2016 #32
Eva Cassidy's "Over the Rainbow" and "autumn Leaves". too. dixiegrrrrl May 2016 #52
Caravan of Thieves pressbox69 May 2016 #33
Well, there's always John... malthaussen May 2016 #37
Be My Baby by Hey Ocean sharp_stick May 2016 #38
The Roots, Taylor Hicks and Stephen Colbert - Friday sharp_stick May 2016 #39
Oh I remember that one. progressoid May 2016 #70
And of course there's the Gipsy Kings version of Hotel California... 47of74 May 2016 #41
Ry Cooder's reggae version of the Stones' "It's All Over Now." Paladin May 2016 #43
Jane's Addiction - Ripple cemaphonic May 2016 #44
Creep -- Postmodern Jukebox ft. Hayley Reinhart Iggo May 2016 #46
two MowCowWhoHow III May 2016 #47
Stones -- Time Is On My Side. KamaAina May 2016 #48
Patti Smith - Smells Like Teen Spirit ret5hd May 2016 #51
She Came In Through The Bathroom Window rbrnmw May 2016 #53
Cocker does some great covers. My fave of his "Feelin' Alright" progressoid May 2016 #71
Since Hurt was taken. Lochloosa May 2016 #54
Most disagree but I love this cover... lame54 May 2016 #55
While My Guitar Gently Weeps ft. The Purple One KamaAina May 2016 #56
I have heard this one, tis very good. dixiegrrrrl May 2016 #59
"What's Up" by He-Man and the Masters of the Universe TacoD May 2016 #57
Tuba Skinny's cover of Crow Jane Lars39 May 2016 #58
A few more... ailsagirl May 2016 #60
Not necessarily best TexasBushwhacker May 2016 #68
There are a number of covers of this famous Dolly Parton song, blue neen May 2016 #63
Gov't Mule, "She Said She Said" Bryan May 2016 #64
Heart doing Stairway to Heaven Mnpaul May 2016 #65
Hell yes! N/t TexasBushwhacker May 2016 #66
How about most surprising TexasBushwhacker May 2016 #69
You win the most surprising, indeed! n/t dixiegrrrrl May 2016 #72
OMG! Is she your Mom?? Ino May 2016 #78
Oh no. It's just something I had see before TexasBushwhacker May 2016 #80
ELO's 'Roll Over Beethoven' and The Proclaimer's 'King of the Road'. LanternWaste May 2016 #73
Not so much a cover but a tribute and with a great video. Tikki May 2016 #74
One of the greatest rock albums of all time... malthaussen May 2016 #84
This one is grand... Tikki May 2016 #75
Somewhere Over the Rainbow by Israel Kamakawiwo'Ole Ino May 2016 #77
That is very nice...... dixiegrrrrl May 2016 #79
Can't help but be happy when i hear this one... Rhythm May 2016 #81
Let's start with ~this~ version of "Enjoy the Silence" Rhythm May 2016 #82
Someone else mentioned Johnny Cash's version of "Hurt"... but he had so many Rhythm May 2016 #83
Disney's "Let It Go" by Leo Moracchioli GreenPartyVoter May 2016 #85
Lemonheads' Mrs. Robinson! Skittles May 2016 #86
Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Share what you think is ...»Reply #25