Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Nonhlanhla

(2,074 posts)
6. It is entirely possible
Fri Feb 12, 2016, 12:12 PM
Feb 2016

for feminists to not like Hillary or to disagree on policy issues. But that is not the question.

All of Hillary's progressive detractors should ask themselves: have I really investigated this woman? Do I truly just differ on policy? Or have I basically bought into the public caricature of her that has been built up over 25 years of right wing hatred?

That caricature is deeply rooted in the right wing's rejection of Hillary as a feminist. When she first appeared on the national scene, they were upset because she did not play the traditional wife role, did not bake cookies, was clearly seeing herself as her husband's equal, and even tried to keep her own name. From that day on she was declared Public Enemy #1 by them.

Has she made mistakes over the years? Of course. She is human.

But a lot of what we see about Hillary, including here on DU, echoes the twisting of her record that is rooted in right wing smears. And even progressives, and yes, even feminists, sometimes unwittingly buy into that. That is why you will read on DU that some don't simply say they reject her reasons for the Iraq War, but that she is bloodthirsty and enjoys killing people. (I read that on DU just the other day.) There are many examples of the same thing. And it comes not just from the right wing these days. Indeed, a heck of a lot of it now comes from the Bernie camp. But if we dare to challenge it, then we're accused of playing the gender card. It's a Catch 22.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Well, my wife does not like her much, and she is a feminist hueymahl Feb 2016 #1
Well, he's asking members of this group. It's still Hillary's Group. that doesn't mean Cha Feb 2016 #4
It is entirely possible Nonhlanhla Feb 2016 #6
Thank you for that Nonhlanhla.. you're the perfect one to answer that. Cha Feb 2016 #8
Thanks Nonhlanhla Feb 2016 #11
You got it! yallerdawg Feb 2016 #10
I agree completely hueymahl Feb 2016 #19
I agree with this post's diagnosis of how people have come to feel about Hillary over the years... northoftheborder Feb 2016 #25
Spot on! BlueMTexpat Feb 2016 #28
the guys I know are often intimidated by strong women beachbum bob Feb 2016 #2
It is because she is a strong woman. DURHAM D Feb 2016 #3
25 years of Republicans trying to demonize her. Most millennials don't know the history. Many livetohike Feb 2016 #5
I can't state strongly enough aaaaaa5a Feb 2016 #7
I agree Nonhlanhla Feb 2016 #9
I - respectfully - completely disagree! yallerdawg Feb 2016 #12
+1 YoungDemCA Feb 2016 #13
I am NOT agreeing with the history of this country. aaaaaa5a Feb 2016 #15
What if it would have been a man saying it? fleabiscuit Feb 2016 #16
Being technically correct and having good campaign strategy are not the same thing. aaaaaa5a Feb 2016 #20
OK - not "respectfully" anymore. yallerdawg Feb 2016 #17
Nobody has said "pretend to be gender neutral." aaaaaa5a Feb 2016 #22
This harmless, humorous aside is the problem? yallerdawg Feb 2016 #26
Apparently the Clinton campaign AGREES with what I have been saying throughout this thread. aaaaaa5a Feb 2016 #30
But you do understand... yallerdawg Feb 2016 #32
Older women spitting out uncomfortable truths Ellen Forradalom Feb 2016 #23
I don't think any of us think she was serious Nonhlanhla Feb 2016 #29
She disrupted the 'wife' image. Basic LA Feb 2016 #14
I'm going with, "They're skeered of girls," and the clubhouse has a sign saying "No Gurlz Aloud." Hekate Feb 2016 #18
Successful women get it the worst in the media Starry Messenger Feb 2016 #21
She's violating a fundamental unspoken rule: Ellen Forradalom Feb 2016 #24
She's a strong woman bluestateguy Feb 2016 #27
It's not that at all jmowreader Feb 2016 #31
Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»Hillary Clinton»*HILLARY CLINTON GROUP* W...»Reply #6