Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

Mika

(17,751 posts)
5. Here ...
Wed Apr 3, 2013, 06:42 PM
Apr 2013

The Curious Case of Yoani Sanchez
http://www.counterpunch.org/2013/03/20/the-curious-case-of-yoani-sanchez/

13. How can your blog accept Paypal, a payment system not available to any island resident because of economic sanctions that affect, among other things, e-commerce?

16. How are you able to register your domain through the U.S. company GoDaddy when this is formally forbidden under current economic sanctions?

17. Your blog is available in 18 languages including; English, French, Spanish, Italian, German, Portuguese, Russian, Slovenian, Polish, Chinese, Japanese, Lithuanian, Czech, Bulgarian, Dutch, Finnish, Korean and Greek. No other Web site in the world, not even the sites of important international agencies, such as the UN, the World Bank, the IMF, OECD or the European Union offers this degree of linguistic support. Not even the U.S. State Department or the CIA offers this degree of access to non-English speakers. Who finances the translations?

18. How is it possible that the site that hosts your blog offers bandwidth 60 times greater than the Internet access service Cuba offers to its users?

24. In 2011, you published 400 messages per month. The price of sending one SMS message from Cuba is $1.25. So, you spent $7,000 in one year of Twitter use. Who pays for this?

When asked about this list during her visit to Columbia University’s School of Journalism she joked that when she was in Brazil the list had grown to fifty questions and that she had already answered all of them. These questions though are not just for Yoani to brush off but are rhetorical questions that thinking people ought to ask when looking at her website and the production methods of “Team Yoani”.
Indeed, the first stop on her 80-day Phineas Fogg-like trip produced plenty of questions and Yoani’s answers belied the fact that maybe she wasn’t exactly “ready for primetime.”

Upon her arrival in Brazil, Yoani was greeted by the stark reality that many global citizens do not agree with her narrative. She was challenged by Brazilian journalists, students, and other citizens about her description of Cuban reality and her answers to three questions in particular caused her to backtrack almost immediately.

When asked about the U.S. embargo against Cuba, Yoani stated unequivocally that it was an interventionist policy and was a justification for the failings of the Cuban government. Most importantly she emphasized that this policy of economic strangulation was a “relic of the Cold War” and needed to be abandoned as soon as possible (“Ya!”). She also called upon the closing of Guantanamo Bay Naval Base. Not the detention center that has brought so much infamy to the United States government and has challenged our notion of due process, but the actual base which is a violation of Cuban sovereignty. Lastly, she called for the release of the Cuban operatives known as the Cuban Five arguing that the Cuban government has spent an unnecessary portion of its budget to campaign for their release.

When confronted by Miami Cubans who were incensed by such commentary Yoani began to backpedal by saying that her comments about the Cuban Five were “ironic” and that she believes that they are not innocent. This rationalization poses a problem for the legitimacy of her position.

For example, now that she has arrived in the United States her position towards the embargo and Guantanamo has been mitigated to a milquetoast generalization that there should be a “dialogue” about these issues. Why is she advocating for dialogue now instead of demanding for the termination of unilateral sanctions as she did in Brazil? Why does she not also decry the interventionist nature of USAID programs that are specifically aimed at “regime change” in Cuba? Why are these questions not being asked in New York, or more pointedly, why aren’t the institutions and academics not letting them be asked? The “guardians” at NYU and Columbia have shown a tendency to “cherry-pick” the questions directed towards Yoani. Why, in what is supposedly the freest nation on earth, is this happening? There have been protests and outbursts in her meetings but no direct challenge has been allowed that would put her in a position of explaining her vacillating views on such important topics.


{permission granted by author to cite some or all of article}




Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Life's too short dipsydoodle Apr 2013 #1
Its interesting. After hearing her in several interviews ... Mika Apr 2013 #2
Nothing would surprise me naaman fletcher Apr 2013 #6
Raul is a smooth customer. Mika Apr 2013 #9
Ah naaman fletcher Apr 2013 #11
They arrested her .... why, then? MADem Apr 2013 #12
"Arrested" (like Gorki, as in: not arrested) and had to pay a fine for using hotel WiFi illegally. Mika Apr 2013 #15
No, I am not talking about that. She was also arrested and beaten enroute to a protest, MADem Apr 2013 #18
Not true, her latest detention was in a cell. joshcryer Apr 2013 #38
She's been saying this stuff for years. joshcryer Apr 2013 #37
Who pays her? You're saying the Columbia School of Journalism has been 'duped?' MADem Apr 2013 #3
USAID dipsydoodle Apr 2013 #4
So PBS got scammed? nt MADem Apr 2013 #8
Here ... Mika Apr 2013 #5
Many questions--not many answers...and it sounds like she tailors her responses to suit her MADem Apr 2013 #7
Unless that mentor is ... Mika Apr 2013 #10
Why would the government give her shit and arrest her x2, then? MADem Apr 2013 #13
Not when one thinks like an American. Mika Apr 2013 #16
No--I am talking about the kidnapping/beating in 09 and the arrest/detention last year. MADem Apr 2013 #19
1st, we have no idea who "kidnapped" and released her. Mika Apr 2013 #20
Someone beat her up but good. If she was going to fake bruises, she would have made them more MADem Apr 2013 #21
Consider that their interests are mutual. Mika Apr 2013 #22
So, you're saying USAID conspired with Raul Castro to install this dissident blogger in MADem Apr 2013 #23
Only the logic of campaign money and maintaining power is at play. Mika Apr 2013 #24
USAID has an interest in maintaining the status quo? MADem Apr 2013 #25
The entities that you mention who would be harmed by normalization ... Mika Apr 2013 #29
Bottom line, though, no matter how nicely Cuba trades with others, they are broke. MADem Apr 2013 #30
Sorta like the Walmart model. Mika Apr 2013 #31
Well, Cuba isn't Costco, though I sort of take your point. MADem Apr 2013 #32
My point was that Walmart doesn't have an inordinate focus on the bottom line. Mika Apr 2013 #33
Well, there's "immediate" bottom line (profits above all else) and there's MADem Apr 2013 #34
That doesn't seem to apply to sociopathic owners like Walmarts. Mika Apr 2013 #35
I agree with the analysis about the sanctions. joshcryer Apr 2013 #40
The best thing to happen for Ileana Ros & the Blowhard bros is Castro. Mika Apr 2013 #41
Unfortunately for them anti-embargo is on the rise. joshcryer Apr 2013 #42
Remember the New Jersey "exile"-derived politicians have their anti-Cuba mob to draw from, also. Judi Lynn Apr 2013 #43
Hmm dipsydoodle Apr 2013 #14
Can hardly wait for Raul to unfurl that flag that Bill Nelson gave Yoani. Mika Apr 2013 #17
One suspects she may just forget that flag in her hotel room! flamingdem Apr 2013 #26
She has answered these questions. Intermediaries. joshcryer Apr 2013 #39
More conspiracy fuel for the fire Yoani lives in an apartment flamingdem Apr 2013 #27
She has a "condescending" criticism for the Cuban government. ocpagu Apr 2013 #28
I love that Beyonce and Jay Z are visiting Havana and it's the new Cuba story flamingdem Apr 2013 #36
Latest Discussions»Region Forums»Latin America»Cuba's Yoani Sánchez Spea...»Reply #5