Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

Demeter

(85,373 posts)
14. The Only Certainty Is That He Won’t Show Up: The Right Way to Say ‘Godot’
Fri Mar 7, 2014, 08:51 PM
Mar 2014
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/12/theater/the-right-way-to-say-godot.html

Maybe Godot never appears because everyone is mispronouncing his name.

More than 60 years after the debut of “Waiting for Godot,” Beckett’s absurdist drama about two vagabonds anticipating a mysterious savior, there is much disagreement among directors, actors, critics and scholars on how the name of that elusive title figure should be spoken. “GOD-oh,” with the accent on the first syllable, is how “it should be pronounced,” said Sean Mathias, the British director of the latest a Broadway revival of “Waiting for Godot,” opening later this month at the Cort Theater. “It has to be, really,” he said. “There’s no other way to do it.” But the theater critic John Lahr said that rendering “is too obvious” for the playwright Samuel Beckett, with its suggestion of the Almighty. “Beckett is more elusive and poetic, and he wouldn’t hit it on the head like that,” said Mr. Lahr, a longtime contributor to The New Yorker, who instead advocates for “god-OH,” with the accent on the second syllable.

Georges Borchardt, a literary agent who represented Beckett and continues to represent his literary estate, suggested even a third pronunciation was possible. “I myself have always pronounced it the French way, with equal emphasis on both syllables,” Mr. Borchardt said in an email. Mr. Borchardt said he had consulted with Edward Beckett, a nephew of the author, who told him that his uncle pronounced it the same way, and that Edward Beckett could not see “why there should be a correct or incorrect way of pronouncing Godot...As the agents for the estate,” Mr. Borchardt continued, “we do not insist on any particular pronunciation.”

There seems to be nothing to be done to reconcile these competing camps, and productions of “Godot” do what they will. In a video recording, Peter Hall, who directed the first British production, in 1955, pronounces it GOD-oh. An American television production from 1961 starring Burgess Meredith and Zero Mostel uses “god-OH.” Discussing his role in the 2009 Broadway production, Nathan Lane says “GOD-oh.”

“I don’t think there is a mathematical solution to this problem,” said Mark Nixon, the director of the Beckett International Foundation at the University of Reading in England. Dr. Nixon said he believed the name was correctly pronounced with a stressed first syllable. But, he said, “I don’t feel strongly in the sense that I would correct somebody who said it differently.” Still, he did not dismiss the Godot question as a trivial issue. “Nothing’s trivial when it comes to Beckett,” he said...


AN ENTIRE COLUMN ABOUT....NOTHING! MORE AT LINK

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

The Plot (there's always a plot, you know) Demeter Mar 2014 #1
The Characters (there are always characters, too) Demeter Mar 2014 #2
More Characters Demeter Mar 2014 #3
Godot Demeter Mar 2014 #4
CURRENTLY OFF BROADWAY Demeter Mar 2014 #7
The Only Certainty Is That He Won’t Show Up: The Right Way to Say ‘Godot’ Demeter Mar 2014 #14
No banks have failed, yet Demeter Mar 2014 #5
Inside The Army’s Spectacular Hidden Treasure Room Demeter Mar 2014 #6
NOT KIDDING - GO TO THE LINK FOR THE PICS. IT'S AMAZING. n/t jtuck004 Mar 2014 #30
Why Russians Are ‘Paranoid’ By Peter Hitchens Demeter Mar 2014 #8
Who’s the Villain Here? Nicholas Kristof Demeter Mar 2014 #11
Why Russia Can’t Afford Another Cold War Demeter Mar 2014 #16
The Face Behind Bitcoin Demeter Mar 2014 #9
The Satoshi Paradox: Newsweek out on a wire with a Bitcoin blockbuster By Felix Salmon Demeter Mar 2014 #46
Fed officials see high hurdle for changing course on QE taper Demeter Mar 2014 #10
Billion Dollar Babies GAIL COLLINS Demeter Mar 2014 #12
A Little Night Music on the Theme Demeter Mar 2014 #13
Kansas violating state constitution in school funding, court says Demeter Mar 2014 #15
The Hammock Fallacy PAUL KRUGMAN Demeter Mar 2014 #17
Natural Gas as a Diplomatic Tool Demeter Mar 2014 #18
Owner of 32-Room, $43 Million Mansion Stole His Workers Tips And Cheated Them of Overtime Demeter Mar 2014 #19
Sounds like somebody who deserved to be shot in the balls. Fuddnik Mar 2014 #31
carly is waiting, too Demeter Mar 2014 #20
women do a lot of waiting Demeter Mar 2014 #21
The essence of existentialism concentrates on the concept of the individual's freedom of choice, jtuck004 Mar 2014 #22
All I know is, when I wait for something indefinitely Demeter Mar 2014 #25
Yeah, I actively try to avoid it. Once in a while I get sucked in, but that's why I carry a book jtuck004 Mar 2014 #28
April 2014 "Discover" article on the science of Neuropsychoanaysis kickysnana Mar 2014 #33
I think it is much harder day-to-day there than it is here, and that we don't take that jtuck004 Mar 2014 #35
In America, they are called a 'Bash Mob' DemReadingDU Mar 2014 #56
J***s! Why do all the bad ideas come out of California? Demeter Mar 2014 #57
this says it all Demeter Mar 2014 #23
Ever Thought About A Career In Loan Sharking, A Booming Industry? jtuck004 Mar 2014 #24
Are you kidding? They learned it here. Demeter Mar 2014 #26
<G> n/t jtuck004 Mar 2014 #27
I knew several Mafia loan sharks back in the '70s. Fuddnik Mar 2014 #32
Interpretations of "Godot" Demeter Mar 2014 #29
Musical Interlude hamerfan Mar 2014 #34
Aw, hamerfan....a pun? Demeter Mar 2014 #42
CHINA'S FEBRUARY EXPORTS DOWN 18 PERCENT xchrom Mar 2014 #36
BANK OF AMERICA CEO PAY JUMPED 77 PERCENT xchrom Mar 2014 #37
JAPAN SEES FUTURE BUSINESS IN FUKUSHIMA CLEANUP xchrom Mar 2014 #38
Straining at gnats Demeter Mar 2014 #43
That's such a curious meme "straining at gnats" that I went looking for its origin Demeter Mar 2014 #54
Greece, lenders will miss March 10 deadline for rescue loan deal - sources xchrom Mar 2014 #39
Funny Papers Demeter Mar 2014 #40
CALVIN IN THE STYLE OF SAMUEL BECKET Demeter Mar 2014 #41
Russia warns could 'reduce to zero' economic dependency on US Demeter Mar 2014 #44
ARTICLE SCOOPED FROM another liberal, WHO NOTES Demeter Mar 2014 #45
Ukraine crisis: Russia warns US against 'hasty' sanctions Demeter Mar 2014 #50
Obama and Putin: Liar’s Poker Demeter Mar 2014 #52
U2’s Bono asks for Europe-wide campaign for Spain xchrom Mar 2014 #47
Rajoy offers last-minute support for Merkel’s choice in EU vote xchrom Mar 2014 #48
OAS meeting ends with no action taken on Venezuela xchrom Mar 2014 #49
Spain should impose fiscal devaluation to restore competitiveness, experts say xchrom Mar 2014 #51
Why Americans Should Take August Off xchrom Mar 2014 #53
Hear! Hear! Demeter Mar 2014 #55
And maybe the months ending in RRRR, too. Demeter Mar 2014 #58
Musical Interlude II hamerfan Mar 2014 #59
Bank of England's Carney faces grilling over foreign exchange scandal xchrom Mar 2014 #60
IBM factory strike shows shifting China labour landscape xchrom Mar 2014 #61
CHINA'S INFLATION RATE EASES TO 2 PCT IN FEBRUARY xchrom Mar 2014 #62
We Can't Escape Our 'Groundhog Day' Recovery xchrom Mar 2014 #63
So the Ukranian Prime Minister is going to visit, jtuck004 Mar 2014 #64
Ukraine has left Irony way behind it Demeter Mar 2014 #66
Richard D. Wolff | Obama's Economic Significance xchrom Mar 2014 #65
Well, since the Reactionary Capitalists couldn't abide by the Accommodation Demeter Mar 2014 #67
I'm calling it a wrap for the Weekend Demeter Mar 2014 #68
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Economy»Weekend Economists Waitin...»Reply #14