Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Economy

Showing Original Post only (View all)
 

Demeter

(85,373 posts)
Fri Feb 10, 2012, 07:03 PM Feb 2012

Weekend Economists Enumerate the Wealth of Nations, February 10-12, 2012 [View all]

Well, hello!! What Makes a Nation Wealthy? And How Do You Count It?

An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, generally referred to by its shortened title The Wealth of Nations, is the magnum opus of the Scottish economist and moral philosopher Adam Smith. First published in 1776, it is a reflection on economics at the beginning of the Industrial Revolution and argues that free market economies are more productive and beneficial to their societies. The book is a fundamental work in classical economics.

History

The Wealth of Nations was first published on 9 March 1776, during the British Agricultural Revolution. It influenced a number of authors and economists, as well as governments and organizations. For example, Alexander Hamilton was influenced in part by The Wealth of Nations to write his Report on Manufactures, in which he argued against many of Smith's policies. Interestingly, Hamilton based much of this report on the ideas of Jean-Baptiste Colbert, and it was, in part, to Colbert's ideas that Smith responded to with The Wealth of Nations.

Many other authors were influenced by the book and used it as a starting point in their own work, including Jean-Baptiste Say, David Ricardo, Thomas Malthus and, later, Ludwig von Mises. The Russian national poet Aleksandr Pushkin refers to The Wealth of Nations in his 1833 verse-novel Eugene Onegin.

Irrespective of historical influence, however, The Wealth of Nations represented a clear shift in the field of economics, similar to Sir Isaac Newton's Principia Mathematica for physics, Antoine Lavoisier's Traité Élémentaire de Chimie for chemistry, or Charles Darwin's On the Origin of Species for biology.

Publishing history

Five editions of The Wealth of Nations were published during Smith's lifetime: in 1776, 1778, 1784, 1786, and 1789. Numerous editions appeared after Smith's death in 1790. To better understand the evolution of the work under Smith's hand, a team led by Edwin Cannan collated the first five editions. The differences were published along with an edited sixth edition in 1904. They found minor but numerous differences (including the addition of many footnotes) between the first and the second editions, both of which were published in two volumes. The differences between the second and third editions, however, are major: In 1784, Smith annexed these first two editions with the publication of Additions and Corrections to the First and Second Editions of Dr. Adam Smith’s Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, and he also had published the three-volume third edition of the Wealth of Nations, which incorporated Additions and Corrections and, for the first time, an index. Among other things, the Additions and Corrections included entirely new sections. The fourth edition, published in 1786, had only slight differences from the third edition, and Smith himself says in the Advertisement at the beginning of the book, "I have made no alterations of any kind." Finally, Cannan notes only trivial differences between the fourth and fifth editions — a set of misprints being removed from the fourth and a different set of misprints being introduced.

Anachronisms and terminology

Modern commentary on the work may suffer from anachronism— the imposition of modern context on a 250-year-old work.

The book is written in English of the late 18th century, so there are some points to consider:

  • The term economics was not yet in use.
  • The term capitalism was not yet in use. Smith talks about a "system of perfect liberty" or "system of natural liberty".
  • Feudalism was still dominant in parts of Europe.
  • The term corporation, as in feudal corporations, referred to a body that regulated and, in Smith's portrayal, limited participation in a skilled trade.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Nations

    Here's a picture of the man who started the argument:



    Why don't we give it a shot? What IS the Wealth of Nations?


  • 86 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
    Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
    It IS Euchre Night, Folks Demeter Feb 2012 #1
    Damn, I haven't played Euchre since I left Ohio State back in 1981... WCGreen Feb 2012 #9
    I had some good cards last night Demeter Feb 2012 #22
    the blizzard that hit Columbus in 1978 really helped to hone my game... WCGreen Feb 2012 #38
    The Snow Didn't Amount to Much Out Here Demeter Feb 2012 #43
    6 PM EST and NO BANKS DOWN--yet Demeter Feb 2012 #2
    2 BANKS DOWN THIS WEEKEND--TOTAL LOSS: $51.3m Demeter Feb 2012 #10
    The Grexit is coming sooner or later girl gone mad Feb 2012 #3
    Greek police union wants to arrest EU/IMF officials girl gone mad Feb 2012 #4
    shouldn't be any shortage of willing hotel staff Po_d Mainiac Feb 2012 #7
    Greece Will Again Be the Cradle of Democracy Demeter Feb 2012 #11
    Yes! Yes!! YES!! (n/t) bread_and_roses Feb 2012 #40
    I would bet on sooner rather than later Owlet Feb 2012 #6
    Marshall Auerback: Greece and the Rape by the Rentiers Demeter Feb 2012 #17
    Greek People Start 48-Hour National Strike Demeter Feb 2012 #23
    Political resignations and general strikes hit Greece xchrom Feb 2012 #35
    Greek Endgame in Sight posted by Philomila Tsoukala Demeter Feb 2012 #58
    Athens is burning. girl gone mad Feb 2012 #84
    Been there, done that Demeter Feb 2012 #86
    Video of Yves Smith on today's Democracy Now!, with Amy Goodman. Fuddnik Feb 2012 #5
    Central Bankers are never wrong Po_d Mainiac Feb 2012 #8
    Today's Central Banksters Are Either Idiots or Crooks Demeter Feb 2012 #12
    I assure you, they are not idiots. Tansy_Gold Feb 2012 #68
    Synopsis: The Wealth of Nations Demeter Feb 2012 #13
    BOOK 1 Continues Demeter Feb 2012 #14
    Ballmer (MICROSOFT) Expects "A Fundamental Economic Reset” CONGRESSIONAL TESTIMONY Demeter Feb 2012 #15
    Thanks for this, Demeter hamerfan Feb 2012 #69
    Of course you love this company Steve. It has made you very rich. n/t Hotler Feb 2012 #82
    "The American workforce is the best on the planet" Hotler Feb 2012 #83
    Mortgage Settlement Term Sheet: Bailout as Reward for Institutionalized Fraud Demeter Feb 2012 #16
    What the Mortgage Deal Reveals About The Obama Administration Demeter Feb 2012 #18
    What the Mortgage Deal In The Works Reveals About The Obama Administration Demeter Feb 2012 #19
    TALK ABOUT DELUSIONAL! Demeter Feb 2012 #20
    This Is No Bailout for Main Street America Demeter Feb 2012 #24
    Why Millions Won’t Get Help From Big Mortgage Settlement Demeter Feb 2012 #25
    Gov. Scott Walker To Use Foreclosure Settlement Money To Balance His Budget, Not Help Homeowners Demeter Feb 2012 #26
    How to Occupy the Economy, According to Richard Wolff Demeter Feb 2012 #29
    TANSY GOLD: THIS ONE IS FOR YOU! Demeter Feb 2012 #30
    I will take a look/listen later Saturday afternoon Tansy_Gold Feb 2012 #47
    what Could Be Better Than Dilbert? Demeter Feb 2012 #21
    #1 = me, x 20,000,000,000,000 or so n/t Tansy_Gold Feb 2012 #48
    Nuclear Regulatory Commission Ignores Fukushima, Green-Lights First New Reactors in 34 Years Demeter Feb 2012 #27
    On the News With Thom Hartmann: Spencer Bachus Investigated for Insider Trading, and More Demeter Feb 2012 #28
    good morning... xchrom Feb 2012 #31
    since the weather got mentioned --Weekend Storm Looms for U.S. Northeast xchrom Feb 2012 #32
    i stole this from n2doc: Ultrafast Trades Trigger Black Swan Events Every Day, Say Econophysicists xchrom Feb 2012 #33
    Justice Department calls Swiss Bank a "fugitive" xchrom Feb 2012 #34
    This is a look over here ruse because Switzerland is one of many and not the biggest. n/t kickysnana Feb 2012 #49
    They haven't forked over the bribe (translation) Demeter Feb 2012 #59
    MF Global: Trail Growing Cold - 'No One to Blame"' DemReadingDU Feb 2012 #36
    Mack the Knife DemReadingDU Feb 2012 #37
    Unaccountable ECB creates a genuine democratic deficit in EU xchrom Feb 2012 #39
    DON'T READ THIS IF YOU'RE FEELING SUICIDAL: Obama’s Worst Year Demeter Feb 2012 #41
    That was a good read and a sad read all at the same time. I could just imagine... Hotler Feb 2012 #78
    King of UAW wants to have his cake and eat it too bread_and_roses Feb 2012 #42
    WOW Demeter Feb 2012 #44
    "Labor and management can accomplish more by working together: Fuddnik Feb 2012 #63
    "That's the language of a serf." bread_and_roses Feb 2012 #64
    Mortgage Settlement as AG Sellout: Deal NOT Done, Final Guaranteed Worse Than Advertised Demeter Feb 2012 #45
    It's Nothing We Haven't Seen Before Demeter Feb 2012 #46
    +1000000000 kickysnana Feb 2012 #50
    Some recession-hit horse owners freeing animals into wild herds Demeter Feb 2012 #51
    Petrol 3-Month Rolling Ave. Sharply Lower; Neg. Shipping Rates; Collapse in Global Trade Demeter Feb 2012 #52
    A Combination of Speculation-Driven Oil Prices and Wage Depression will do that Demeter Feb 2012 #54
    “Good life does not come easily in Lithuania” xchrom Feb 2012 #53
    Negative Shipping Rents Demeter Feb 2012 #55
    Richard Nixon gets it / Edward Harrison Demeter Feb 2012 #56
    S&P downgrades 34 Italian banks xchrom Feb 2012 #57
    MF Global Trustee Sees $1.6 Billion Customer Shortfall (DEFICIT CLIMBING STILL) Demeter Feb 2012 #60
    Mind-Blowing Charts From the Senate's Income Inequality Hearing Demeter Feb 2012 #61
    Lanny Breuer’s Theory of Chatting Accountability for CEOs Demeter Feb 2012 #62
    The wealth of the U.S.A.: It's all about oil... rfranklin Feb 2012 #65
    Are 'sweatshops' an economic necessity? Demeter Feb 2012 #66
    SO, WHAT MAKES A NATION WEALTHY? Demeter Feb 2012 #67
    bon jour! xchrom Feb 2012 #70
    I never pay attention to Fashion Week, lol DemReadingDU Feb 2012 #72
    there's probably 3 serious fashionistas on du. xchrom Feb 2012 #73
    Nope. snot Feb 2012 #79
    oh cool! i like ny times, london telegraph, xchrom Feb 2012 #80
    Thanks! I'll check 'em out. snot Feb 2012 #85
    Soros: Greek Bailout Won’t Rid Europe of ‘Danger’ xchrom Feb 2012 #71
    Bankers arrested in tax probe {uk} xchrom Feb 2012 #74
    You See, Tax Evasion is Theft from the Politicians' Power and Influence Demeter Feb 2012 #75
    well said. nt xchrom Feb 2012 #76
    In 'Money Shot,' Poet Reacts to Financial Crisis in Verse xchrom Feb 2012 #77
    Well, the Party was a great success Demeter Feb 2012 #81
    Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Economy»Weekend Economists Enumer...»Reply #0