Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

Demeter

(85,373 posts)
7. What Militarism Means
Thu Jul 30, 2015, 10:57 PM
Jul 2015
http://www.theamericanconservative.com/articles/what-militarism-means/

When we think of militarism, Prussians in spiffy uniforms goose-stepping down Unter den Linden probably comes to mind. Prussia’s fixation on her army was less an “ism” than a product of her geography, which stranded the country between two great land powers, France and Russia, with no natural defenses on her borders. Nonetheless, a cartoon from the Kaiser’s time depicts such militarism well. It shows a Berlin street full of people in various uniforms, all staring pop-eyed at a man in a suit. The caption reads, “A civilian! A civilian!”

A book a friend recommended offers a supplementary definition of militarism, one that touches closer to home for Americans. The work, A History of Militarism by Alfred Vagts, was first published in 1937. Vagts makes an important distinction at the outset:

Every war is fought, every army is maintained in a military way and in a militaristic way. The distinction is fundamental and fateful. The military way is marked by a primary concentration of men and materials on winning. … Militarism, on the other hand, presents a vast array of customs, interests, prestige, actions and thought associated with armies and wars and yet transcending true military purposes. Indeed, militarism is so constituted that it may hamper and defeat the purposes of the military way.

Modern militarism has … specific traits … modern armies … are more liable to forget their true purpose, war, and the maintenance of the state to which they belong. Becoming narcissistic, they dream that they exist for themselves alone … perpetuating themselves for the purpose of drawing money.


This definition of militarism is alive, well, and running the show on Capitol Hill and in the Pentagon. As Vagts warns, the result is not merely the waste of some hundreds of billions of dollars. Much of that money is spent in ways that work against military effectiveness, against the ability of our armed forces to win. Vagts reminds us: “The acid test of an army is war—not the good opinion it entertains of itself. …War is the criterion, and war only. The rest is advertisement.”

YOU KNOW WHERE THIS IS GOING--F35 FIASCO---ONE IN A SERIES OF STUPID THINGS DONE IN THE NAME OF DEFENSE....

Republicans in Congress continually call for reducing the federal deficit. Sloughing off this albatross would save a neat trillion. At the very least, congressional budget hawks should demand a fly-off, where the F-35 would have to prove it is a better fighter than our existing F-15s, F-16s, and F-18s. Will they? No. Some of those nice men in expensive suits standing at their office doors, checkbooks in hand, might go away.

The shape of American militarism is the enormous shadow cast by the F-35.

William S. Lind is author of the Maneuver Warfare Handbook and director of the American Conservative Center for Public Transportation.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Bill allows government to revoke Americans’ passports without charges or trial Demeter Jul 2015 #1
THE ROAD TO FAILURE IS "GREECED" Demeter Jul 2015 #2
Lies, Damned Lies, and Greek Statistics (COMPARED TO ICELAND) Demeter Jul 2015 #5
The Greece debt bailout negotiations are really about France, not Greece Demeter Jul 2015 #6
Before Raiding The Bank Of Greece, Look At Their Balance Sheet! Demeter Jul 2015 #8
How Big Corporations Are Starving Public Schools of Billions of Dollars Demeter Jul 2015 #3
What’s Left of the American Dream Withers at Record Pace by Wolf Richter Demeter Jul 2015 #4
What Militarism Means Demeter Jul 2015 #7
UN sets principles for new debt framework (HOPE THIS SPIKES TPP AND CO) Demeter Jul 2015 #9
China's Headaches Are the Fed's, Too Demeter Jul 2015 #10
U.S. Calls Insider-Trading Ruling ‘Harmful’ in Review Bid Demeter Jul 2015 #11
U.S. GDP Rises 2.3% in Second Quarter; First Quarter Revised Upward Demeter Jul 2015 #12
Fed Sheds No Light, Plays Charades with Media; Tiptoe Balancing Act Demeter Jul 2015 #14
Pacific trade negotiators chase elusive final deal in tough talks TPP Demeter Jul 2015 #13
One Email That Proves Campaign Finance Laws Are A Joke Demeter Jul 2015 #15
Judge Won't Let Medical Company Sell Itself Short Demeter Jul 2015 #16
U.S. must wait for EU hedge fund "passports" Demeter Jul 2015 #17
In US, 8 million baby boomers go hungry amid health and economic challenges Demeter Jul 2015 #18
The ways in which the economy never recovered from 2008 Demeter Jul 2015 #19
Americans’ Economic Confidence Gets Mauled by Wolf Richter Demeter Jul 2015 #20
After Two Years, White House Finally Responds to Snowden Pardon Petition — With a “No” Demeter Jul 2015 #21
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Economy»STOCK MARKET WATCH -- Fri...»Reply #7