Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Personal Finance and Investing

Showing Original Post only (View all)

question everything

(47,479 posts)
Fri Dec 20, 2019, 02:34 PM Dec 2019

About those RMDs (for the 70+ here) [View all]

Some years ago, after reading a story, we opened Roth IRAs and moved some funds from traditional IRA to lower the amounts that would be used for RMD (Required minimum withdrawal). Did it for two years but then realized that, hey, I don't need to reduce the amount of the IRAa; the withdrawal would be the amount to maintain our expenses.

But, the stock market has been going up and up. The Dow Jones is up 20%, NASDQ is 30%, I think. We are 50-50 so the value increased by 10% and after withdrawal of around 4% the funds are still 6% higher. Yes, I know, problems of the "haves," (until the market crashes..)

They yearly RNDs are calculated based on the value on Dec. 31st, and as we grow older, the denominator decreases.

We have had some unexpected expenses recently ($2,000 dental bridge repair) so decided to take more this month, above the minimum required. This should also reduce somewhat the amount required for 2020 and... I made sure that we are still at the 12% tax rate. One reason why I keep a spreadsheet year around, starting January.


19 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
About those RMDs (for the 70+ here) [View all] question everything Dec 2019 OP
Ah heck- James48 Dec 2019 #1
The Secure Act which was passed by both houses of Congress raises the RMD age requirement still_one Dec 2019 #2
Would have hurt us. At 70 and 1/2 we retired and needed the RMD question everything Dec 2019 #4
You don't have any regular taxable accounts to withdraw from? progree Dec 2019 #5
Yes, do. Most of it are securities that selling would generate capital gain question everything Dec 2019 #10
How would you pay capital gains taxes if you are in the 12% ordinary tax bracket? progree Dec 2019 #11
Oh. But one first has to take all the RMD and then can take extra to convert to Roth question everything Dec 2019 #12
Good luck 😂. I have to make my Roth conversion decision (yes/no/how much) in a few days progree Dec 2019 #13
To add and to thank you question everything Dec 2019 #14
I'm glad I helped in some way 😁 progree Dec 2019 #15
Qualified Dividends and Capital Gain Tax Worksheet question everything Dec 2019 #16
But don't you use TurboTax and don't they get it right (as far as qualified dividends)? progree Dec 2019 #17
Don't like surprises. Certainly not where money is invovled question everything Dec 2019 #18
Don't like surprises either, but whether I get a $2,000 refund in April or have to pay a $5,000 progree Dec 2019 #19
The ideal situation is one invests in such a way that the investments generate interest and dividend still_one Dec 2019 #6
Still, if you need to withdraw money for expenses, you want to withdraw it from taxable accounts progree Dec 2019 #3
Also for inherited IRAs there are several ways to take those RMDs, including annuitizing them still_one Dec 2019 #7
Yes, another option that looks real good to me is just donating the RMDs directly to charity -- progree Dec 2019 #8
Exactly, especially since for a lot of folks they can't itemize deductions, and this is a perfect still_one Dec 2019 #9
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Personal Finance and Investing»About those RMDs (for the...»Reply #0