Education

FBaggins

(28,706 posts)

47. Dodging what? You think others can't tell?

Wed Jul 25, 2012, 06:15 PM

Jul 2012

You presented your own personal experience as evidence for your argument. You've been asked three times what that experience was... and you've dodged (even after a friendly jab).

You've been asked three times whether or not you consider teachers to be professionals. Your statements certainly imply that you think they aren't... but you dodge the straight question.

Feel free to actually answer at any time.

originally the independent clergy, lawyers, and doctors.

Bull. You deceptively added "independent" because the actual list is self-contradictory with the standard that you've invented to describe it. There were no "independent clergy" in the 15th century. The clergy were not self-regulating and they were not independent.

The actual reason clergy,lawyers, and doctors were the only three was because those were the only ones that required extensive additional formal education. (from "professors" no less). Other "professions" came under the umbrella to the extent they share that characteristic...

...regardless of whether or not they work for someone else. A lawyer does not cease to be a professional when she goes to work at the EPA and a physician does not cease to be a professional when he joins a hospital staff.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

56 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

do you think teachers need a dress code? [View all] demtenjeep Jul 2012 OP

Are they going to give you a clothing allowance? murielm99 Jul 2012 #1

Each school should have its own, implicit, 'dress code,' elleng Jul 2012 #2

Teaching the teachers how to lie, eh? Trillo Jul 2012 #3

you would hope not, but mopinko Jul 2012 #4

I wish she worked sulphurdunn Jul 2012 #50

The company I worked for had a dress code & after years & years they did away with it. Booster Jul 2012 #5

Where did you work? Goblinmonger Jul 2012 #11

For a major television network. In no way did I intend to put teachers down in my post. But in Booster Jul 2012 #12

It seems to me dress codes are the refuge of cowardly managers. dballance Jul 2012 #6

Unfortunately, there are people in every profession who do need to be told how to dress. Arkansas Granny Jul 2012 #7

What's wrong with dealing with those people individually? proud2BlibKansan Jul 2012 #15

Establishing a dress code isn't exactly penalizing an entire group of people. It sets standards Arkansas Granny Jul 2012 #16

Teachers are professionals and should be treated as such proud2BlibKansan Jul 2012 #18

And most teachers dress like the professionals that they are and a dress code would not affect Arkansas Granny Jul 2012 #19

Yes, doctors often have dress codes. FBaggins Jul 2012 #21

This message was self-deleted by its author Arkansas Granny Jul 2012 #17

totally agree demtenjeep Jul 2012 #54

No, but.. LeftTurnOnly Jul 2012 #8

Not "need" perhaps (for most)... but not a big deal. FBaggins Jul 2012 #9

As recently as 10 years ago I worked in law firms TBF Jul 2012 #10

I don't have a problem with a dress code. noamnety Jul 2012 #13

As with most things, a dress code, if it exists at all, LWolf Jul 2012 #14

I teach Ceramics. Starry Messenger Jul 2012 #20

I doubt that any dress code for teachers will require office attire. FBaggins Jul 2012 #22

I've actually seen that phrase in dress codes for teachers proud2BlibKansan Jul 2012 #23

I had the "open-toed shoes" thing, too. LWolf Jul 2012 #25

My response up-thread suggests differently. LWolf Jul 2012 #24

I would think they should be required to dress business casual jpbollma Jul 2012 #26

With the obvious exception of roles where to do so makes no sense. FBaggins Jul 2012 #27

I think we should be required to dress appropriately LWolf Jul 2012 #28

Two of the last three points seem like a perfect dress code to me. FBaggins Jul 2012 #30

Seems good to me, too. LWolf Jul 2012 #38

Even without that... FBaggins Jul 2012 #40

Well, the school I teach at has never had to issue one. Starry Messenger Jul 2012 #48

it's just to show you you're not a professional, you're just a walmart peon like everyone else. HiPointDem Jul 2012 #29

Are you under the impression that professionals don't have dress codes? FBaggins Jul 2012 #31

no, cube rats have a dress code. HiPointDem Jul 2012 #32

Cube rats ALSO have a dress code. FBaggins Jul 2012 #33

i'm saying professionals are expected to know how to dress and not to require formalized HiPointDem Jul 2012 #34

Then perhaps you're the one who isn't a professional? FBaggins Jul 2012 #35

what are "professional industries"? the professions aren't "industries" -- that used to be one HiPointDem Jul 2012 #36

That explains the gap FBaggins Jul 2012 #37

uh, yes, it did. HiPointDem Jul 2012 #39

Can you describe the professional settings in which you've worked? FBaggins Jul 2012 #41

you first. HiPointDem Jul 2012 #42

Already done. FBaggins Jul 2012 #43

oh, the training dept of a medium sized corp. not a professional, just an educated employee. HiPointDem Jul 2012 #44

Dodging? FBaggins Jul 2012 #45

dodging what? it's not my own definition, it's the traditional meaning. "the professions" were HiPointDem Jul 2012 #46

Dodging what? You think others can't tell? FBaggins Jul 2012 #47

i wasn't talking about the 15th century. your claim that most professionals are paid by HiPointDem Jul 2012 #49

Maybe just the illegal aliens do, other than that.... 2on2u Jul 2012 #51

Yes I do and I am a teacher! roody Jul 2012 #52

No, it's insulting...nt lutefisk Jul 2012 #53

I agree demtenjeep Jul 2012 #55

No, we don't need more insults. RobertAustin Jul 2012 #56