Environment & Energy
In reply to the discussion: Electricity's looking rather ugly in Europe today. [View all]NNadir
(38,133 posts)...spent fuel rods would have mattered quite as much to your family as the normal operations of a coal plant would have.
The supposed risks of used nuclear fuel are always exaggerated and always reported, almost 100% of the time using conditional words, "could have," "might have," etc. Deaths from dangerous fossil fuels are not, even though conditional words are not required to show they kill people.
If FPL had built a coal plant where Turkey Point is, there would have been no effort to improve "safety," at all. A coal plant kills people whenever it operates normally, not just in a theoretical "safety issue" raised about used nuclear fuel. There is NO safety in coal operations. These operations always result in fatalities.
Used nuclear fuel is different than used fossil fuel in that it has a spectacular record in not killing anyone, anywhere, at any time in this country, whereas used fossil fuel, aka air pollution, has killed tens of millions of people in this country and continues to do so.
If I lived in Florida, I'd be far more worried about seawater than I would be about Turkey Point. Disasters associated with the former are now extremely likely, whereas a disaster at Turkey Point involving fatalities, while certainly not impossible, are extremely unlikely.
I remarked on the cooling rates of used nuclear fuel elsewhere: Some comments on the war situation with Chernobyl as well as the operable nuclear plants in Ukraine.
I personally think the storage of used nuclear fuels in pools is a wasteful, bad idea, even though the practice is widely used, in fact, used almost exclusively. I would prefer that they be stored in thermoelectric devices designed to be air cooled, or, even better, reprocessed on site while still hot in a pyro-processing scheme.
I would be very happy to have a nuclear plant in my town, especially one with in line reprocessing. I'd feel proud that my community is involved in saving human lives and ecosystems. I'm a little sad because I used to take my kids to the beach here in New Jersey in sight of the Oyster Creek Nuclear Plant, which has regrettably been shut and displace by dangerous natural gas, the waste of which, as I'm sure you know, creates significant risk for anyone living at low elevations, including but not limited to Florida. I used to tell my boys how important that Oyster Creek plant was, and one of them grew up to be entered into a nuclear engineering Ph.D. program. I hope that the time will come that he'll participate in putting the used nuclear fuel still stored there to use.