Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

NNadir

(38,534 posts)
14. Um, thanks for the soothsaying about the blades. I've heard it for many years.
Sun Jun 4, 2023, 01:39 PM
Jun 2023

I generally provide something called "references" for what I say.

As I noted in the OP, the oil and gas hellhole Denmark had, as of 2022, 3,444 decommissioned wind turbines, 24 that haven't produced power since 2015 but are still "commissioned," along with, including those 24, 346 turbines that were dysfunctional for at least one full year, some them much longer, and 479 turbines that are clearly operating well below their design, with capacity utilization of less than 10%, and 248 that are operating at less than 5% capacity utilization.

With all these decommissioned and rotting in place turbines surely someone who claims that they are being recycled can point to an industrial facility where this activity is taking place on a scale commensurate with the high rate at which they fail.

It would aslo be useful to understand the processes used. Are the trucks used to haul these huge chucks of rusting steel away powered by wind charged batteries. Are the blast furnaces like the ones shown in the OP powered by solar - and no, cheap marketing bull about "offsets" will not be credited - or are they powered by a grid involving fossil fuel generated electricity?

Many of us, I'm sure, would love to hear about this facility so we can all evaluate it.

Talking about alternators does not imply that wind turbines are recycled, by the way. One can put an alternatior in one's trunk and drive to a metals recycling shop. No cranes are required.

May I suggest that once the antinuke community here contact this guy, who can't seem to get the wind company to come and haul away the wind turbines they put on his land. It seems no one will own up to having responsibility for them:

The wind turbines on his Colorado farm are 20 years old. Who’s going to take them down?

Subtitle:

As wind farms flood the Eastern Plains, the renewable energy alternative is now running into the same concerns that originally plagued the fossil fuel industry


I've been asked to accept that wind turbines are all recycled because automotive alternators are. I'm used to antinukes claiming I'm stupid and uninformed, but if they're bright and super informed they can certainly do what I do and provide references, no?

I've looked briefly through the scientific and engineering literature, and while I see lots of theory on how wind turbines might be recycled some day, I see no information suggesting they are being recycled.

The pictures all over the internet show lots of rotting abandoned wind industrial parks. Are they all historical because of this marvelous recycling practice?

Do get back to me on this...

I can't wait to find out how wind turbines, while having failed to address climate change, are nonetheless immune from ending up in landfills.

Do tell...

Have a nice Sunday afternoon.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Nuclear power still sucks jpak Jun 2023 #1
Corroborating the OP 4dog Jun 2023 #8
At this moment in time... Think. Again. Jun 2023 #2
There is one and only one form of energy that is sustainable and potentially fossil fuel free. NNadir Jun 2023 #5
Correlation doesn't equal causation... Think. Again. Jun 2023 #10
Bullshit. NNadir Jun 2023 #11
I agree... Think. Again. Jun 2023 #12
I disagree. NNadir Jun 2023 #20
Nah... Think. Again. Jun 2023 #22
If one opens a science book, one might recognize... NNadir Jun 2023 #23
Yes... Think. Again. Jun 2023 #24
Oh. The conclusion then is that reactionary return to 19th century... NNadir Jun 2023 #25
Summary of the Table: Jewelry gets recycled. eppur_se_muova Jun 2023 #3
The choice of what to recycle is very much connected with the cost of the metal itself and... NNadir Jun 2023 #4
Nuclear is the way we need to go, flying rabbit Jun 2023 #6
Luckily... Think. Again. Jun 2023 #9
Kick. ❤️ littlemissmartypants Jun 2023 #7
As the TVA guy said - SMR's in groups of 4 make sense Finishline42 Jun 2023 #13
Um, thanks for the soothsaying about the blades. I've heard it for many years. NNadir Jun 2023 #14
I wonder if they recycle the soothing pretty flashing red lights and radar systems progree Jun 2023 #15
Imagine the level of snowflake you have to be to be freaked out by blinking lights not in sync Blues Heron Jun 2023 #16
Some people seeking country living (and plenty of others) don't like living in an industrial park. progree Jun 2023 #17
Maybe they should try a real industrial park, or since they are talking about destruction Blues Heron Jun 2023 #18
Here's the bigger issue progree Jun 2023 #19
And a LOT more Solar and Wind (or nuclear) has to be built here and world-wide progree Jun 2023 #21
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Environment & Energy»Steel recycling firm cons...»Reply #14