Israel/Palestine

shira

(30,109 posts)

57. 1. Israel's non-Jews are guaranteed equal rights by law

Reply to guillaumeb (Reply #56)

Mon Apr 27, 2015, 03:19 PM

Apr 2015

2. Abbas is a dictator. When he speaks for himself, he speaks for Palestine. It's his show & no one else's.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

58 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

The 67 Israeli soldiers who fell during Gaza war died in vain [View all] Israeli Apr 2015 OP

more......... Israeli Apr 2015 #1

By posting the whole article nobody needs pay Haaretz to read the article King_David Apr 2015 #13

They can read the article or free by signing up to Haaretz too azurnoir Apr 2015 #14

Yes 10 articles a month free and when your done if you want to bypass the paywall King_David Apr 2015 #15

Your complaints are noted. R. Daneel Olivaw Apr 2015 #17

Are you an Admin here King_David Apr 2015 #18

Don't worry, dave, it'll be aright. R. Daneel Olivaw Apr 2015 #19

thanks for the legal advice dave shaayecanaan Apr 2015 #50

That's a pretty controversial piece, but I agree. Little Tich Apr 2015 #2

Are you boycotting this author? oberliner Apr 2015 #3

Nope .... Israeli Apr 2015 #16

Your description of Israel reminds me of post-WWI-Germany. DetlefK Apr 2015 #4

Boycotting Jewish Stores and businesses is WW2 King_David Apr 2015 #21

You are right: Institutionalized discrimimination in Israel really reminds me of the 1930s. DetlefK Apr 2015 #22

"stuffing people into ghettos because they are of a different ethnicity..." oberliner Apr 2015 #24

This was not a war of necessity, it was a war of choice azurnoir Apr 2015 #5

How many rocket attacks have their been since then? oberliner Apr 2015 #6

do you support Israel's action during Protective Edge? Hamas had kept the 2012 ceasefire azurnoir Apr 2015 #7

Nope oberliner Apr 2015 #8

Then you agree that Hamas kept the 2012 cease fire until Israel began it's attacks? azurnoir Apr 2015 #9

No oberliner Apr 2015 #10

Did Hamas take responsibility for attacks prior to late June 2014 or was it splinter groupss such as azurnoir Apr 2015 #12

so you disapprove of Israel's actions but approve of what they "accomplised"? azurnoir Apr 2015 #23

Yes, they did die in vain. Another war initiated by Hamas will break out.... shira Apr 2015 #11

Israel DOES need a better plan guillaumeb Apr 2015 #25

Without a peace treaty, such a pullout will make things worse shira Apr 2015 #26

The "goal" in your words, guillaumeb Apr 2015 #28

Israel has already offered 2 peaceful solutions based on International Law.... shira Apr 2015 #30

If the Israelis had actually ever offered to comply with International Law, guillaumeb Apr 2015 #31

They did, based on UNSCR 242. As for land swaps, both Abbas & the Saudi Plan.... shira Apr 2015 #32

Actually, YOU first mentioned RoR in your previous post. guillaumeb Apr 2015 #33

I asked u about Palestinian RoR. It's fantasy, correct? shira Apr 2015 #34

My interpretation of UNSCR 242 is the clear language guillaumeb Apr 2015 #35

It's clearly not. Otherwise, everyone would be calling for that... shira Apr 2015 #36

Or you have no grasp of what I said. guillaumeb Apr 2015 #37

Israel, like every other country on the planet, gets to determine.... shira Apr 2015 #38

Israel allows all Jews, no matter the country of origin, guillaumeb Apr 2015 #39

So what does that have to do with the alleged RoR? shira Apr 2015 #40

Would you describe the US as guillaumeb Apr 2015 #41

USA = White Christianistan? No. And there's part of your problem... shira Apr 2015 #46

In your "free nation" sentence, you left out one group. guillaumeb Apr 2015 #47

Free, as in open society, liberal, western. shira Apr 2015 #55

Two minor points guillaumeb Apr 2015 #56

1. Israel's non-Jews are guaranteed equal rights by law shira Apr 2015 #57

I might agree with point number 1, guillaumeb Apr 2015 #58

"abandoning all territory seized from Palestine and Syria" oberliner Apr 2015 #27

Is your question serious? guillaumeb Apr 2015 #29

East Jerusalem was seized from Jordan, wasn't it? oberliner Apr 2015 #42

define seized. guillaumeb Apr 2015 #43

However you wish to define it oberliner Apr 2015 #44

I would define inhabitants as the people originally inhabiting the area prior guillaumeb Apr 2015 #45

Recommend...great read, thank you. n/t Jefferson23 Apr 2015 #20

April 21st: Joint Israeli-Palestinian Memorial Day event Jefferson23 Apr 2015 #48

Further Jefferson..... Israeli Apr 2015 #49

It is so tragic there is only a minority support, but it is there and should be acknowledged and Jefferson23 Apr 2015 #51

acknowledge it now Jefferson..... Israeli Apr 2015 #52

How anyone expects a bantustan to be the future state for the Palestinians and that peace Jefferson23 Apr 2015 #53

Bibi and Bennett have already won .... Israeli Apr 2015 #54