Israel/Palestine

grossproffit

(5,591 posts)

44. Not really interesting. More like transparent on your part.

Reply to Jefferson23 (Reply #43)

Wed Oct 29, 2014, 07:59 PM

Oct 2014

Nice try!

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

45 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

New book by Norman Finkelstein explores Israel�s assault on Gaza [View all] Jefferson23 Oct 2014 OP

Fuck finkelstein. His views on the holocaust are bullshit and so is he. still_one Oct 2014 #1

"It Takes an Enormous Amount of Courage to Speak the Truth When No One Else is Out There" Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #2

You're disingenuously pretending Hilberg endorses Fink as a scholar.... shira Oct 2014 #34

I'm not pretending anything, that would be you..hoping against hope that people are not Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #37

+1 He's garbage. grossproffit Oct 2014 #3

+1 nobody takes this dude seriously besides some discussion forums. King_David Oct 2014 #6

Yea, only world renowned Holocaust scholars. n/t Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #7

He's a hero on Internet forums King_David Oct 2014 #8

Tell that to the scholars that praise his work. n/t Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #9

The praise he gets from the Jewish community in particular King_David Oct 2014 #10

No that is not it, he is recognized by world remowned scholars for his work regarding the Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #12

Yep he called out the BDS movement. King_David Oct 2014 #16

Your link? Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #19

yes, storm front and David Duke are his big fans still_one Oct 2014 #13

Post#2, don't let that get in your way. n/t Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #18

Which world renowned Holocaust scholars? oberliner Oct 2014 #20

Read post number 2, and you're here just in the nick of time to minimize Hilberg. Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #21

Minimize Hilberg? oberliner Oct 2014 #22

Read the link, that's why it's there. Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #23

There are no Holocaust scholars mentioned anywhere in the interview other than Mr. Hilberg. oberliner Oct 2014 #24

Avi Shlaim, an Oxford scholar on the Israeli/Palestinian conflict is a nobody too? Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #30

He is not a Holocaust scholar and does not claim to be one oberliner Oct 2014 #38

Oh well then, that makes the totality of Hilbergs endorsement rather exculsive in a Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #39

"Finkelstein has long been an outspoken opponent of all violence in the Middle East." shira Oct 2014 #4

Look at that, you and grossproffit agree on so much posted here. n/t Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #5

The video speaks for itself. Finkelstein is a low-life supporter..... shira Oct 2014 #11

Yep, according to you..I heard you the first time. Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #14

Won't stop some from spreading his garbage propaganda. n/t shira Oct 2014 #15

Many are afraid of him, I find it revealing..posts like yours vs praise he receives from Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #17

Scholars, King_David Oct 2014 #25

One scholar like Hilberg apparently makes Fink 1000% kosher. n/t shira Oct 2014 #26

I am certain you wish he had none..sorry. n/t Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #28

Hilberg was very specific in what he endorsed from the Fink... shira Oct 2014 #29

What is essential is that he did and of course he was specific..how does that change anything? Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #31

Well duh, it means Hilberg endorses only a small fraction.... shira Oct 2014 #32

Nope, but you knew that..just as you know your other unreliable tools for Bibi are Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #33

Yep. To quote Hilberg again... shira Oct 2014 #35

Right and what you're suggesting is unsupported..it's what you do here on a regular basis. n/t Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #36

That makes sense to you, and he doesn't need anyone past Hilberg...sorry for you. n/t Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #27

There are many, many of us in the Democratic party that strongly support Israel. grossproffit Oct 2014 #40

Yep, you and shira share a lot in common. n/t Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #41

Aw, I get it. You think we're the same person. grossproffit Oct 2014 #42

Those are your words, interesting though. n/t Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #43

Not really interesting. More like transparent on your part. grossproffit Oct 2014 #44

Those were not your words and conclusions? The pumpkin is a nice added addition to your Jefferson23 Oct 2014 #45