Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Creative Speculation

In reply to the discussion: Balsamo Busted, again [View all]

johndoeX

(268 posts)
3. Seger fails comprehension again.
Fri Jun 27, 2014, 04:25 PM
Jun 2014

Seger, do you see the lines with the arrows at the "Factor of 1.5"? Up and down?

They are describing the 1.5 Factor of Safety vertically, the upper and lower limits (positive and negative G loads). The horizontal Overspeed margin is not 1.5. In fact, it is only 10% between Vne and Vd as manadated by the FAA.


You would know this if you read anything you have posted.

I posted the Vne diagram to keep it simple for people like you.. and the fact it is in Flying Magazine read by thousands of subscribers... from passengers, to students, to professional pilots.

Jets do not have a Vne and havent since the 60's.

I guess we now know why Seger is no longer a "draftsman".... he can't even understand a simple Vg and the 1.5 factor of safety designated by the upper and lower arrows in the diagram he posted...



Balsamo Busted, again [View all] William Seger Jun 2014 OP
Dang Seger.... wildbilln864 Jun 2014 #1
Oh yeah, I'm ready William Seger Jun 2014 #2
Seger fails comprehension again. johndoeX Jun 2014 #3
ouch! wildbilln864 Jun 2014 #4
Yeah... Seger is pretty much done at this point... johndoeX Jun 2014 #5
"Do you think Seger will admit he is wrong? " wildbilln864 Jun 2014 #6
I agree... johndoeX Jun 2014 #7
You're still using the fudged diagram in your new video? William Seger Jul 2014 #16
LOL, bad guess William Seger Jun 2014 #8
It may say IAS - johndoeX Jun 2014 #9
LOL. Yeah, why admit you were wrong William Seger Jun 2014 #12
Wrong again Seger. johndoeX Jun 2014 #13
I already asked the FAA and two engineering forums William Seger Jun 2014 #15
..., someone made up some stuff, or found another internet journalist to quote mine superbeachnut Jun 2014 #10
Beachy, do you agree with Seger? johndoeX Jun 2014 #11
Yes, I agree, you have no idea what the point is superbeachnut Jun 2014 #14
the ultimate load envelope inam56 Aug 2014 #17
pilots for truth have no aero experts superbeachnut Aug 2014 #18
and 1.15Vd (or better 1.2Vd standards!) need to prove that damping ratio are stable inam56 Aug 2014 #19
767-200 FAA certificat inam56 Aug 2014 #20
1.2 was the old 25.629 superbeachnut Aug 2014 #21
use of FSX by balsamo inam56 Aug 2014 #22
Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»Creative Speculation»Balsamo Busted, again»Reply #3