In the discussion thread: Spirituality vs the "God" idea. [View all]
Response to Stuart G (Original post)
Tue Jan 24, 2012, 09:48 PM
progree (7,727 posts)
4. Kind of hard to endure the religious proselytization about a prayer-answering favor dispensing deity
Though they might not require belief in God; the whole program, Steps, and literature is proselytization about a prayer-answering favor-dispensing deity, one who will restore us to sanity, remove our shortcomings, manage our lives, care for us, love us, listen to our prayers, give us power, and guide our groups (this list from the 12 Steps and Tradition 2),
and who in Step 11 you pray to for knowledge of His will for us and the power to carry that out - the same God that you turned your will and life over to in Step 3. They pressure you to work the 12 steps -- AA's literature tells you that "Unless each A.A. member follows to the best of his ability our suggested Twelve Steps to recovery, he almost certainly signs his own death warrant" [12X12 p.174]. And whose Big Book spends a whole chapter (Chapter 4 "We Agnostics" ![]() For these and many other reasons, four Federal Courts of Appeals (Second, Third, Seventh, and Ninth circuits) and Two State Supreme Courts (New York and Tennessee) have ruled that Alcoholics Anonymous and Narcotics Anonymous are religious and that nobody can be coerced by government authority into attending these organizations (as that would violate the First Amendment's prohibition against the state establishment of religion). No Federal Court of Appeals and no State Supreme Court has ruled otherwise. To date, the United States Supreme Court has declined to consider any of these rulings, thus letting these ruling stand. Here is a Duke Law Journal article that discusses the religious aspects of A.A. and the definition of religion for constitutional purposes (first amendment establishment clause). http://www.law.duke.edu/shell/cite.pl?47+Duke+L.+J.+785 |
Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
![]() |
Author | Time | Post |
Stuart G | Jan 2012 | OP | |
NMDemDist2 | Jan 2012 | #1 | |
Tripod | Jan 2012 | #2 | |
Old Codger | Jan 2012 | #3 | |
tavalon | Feb 2012 | #15 | |
Old Codger | Feb 2012 | #20 | |
Stuart G | Feb 2012 | #21 | |
progree | Feb 2012 | #23 | |
NMDemDist2 | Feb 2012 | #27 | |
tavalon | Feb 2012 | #38 | |
Old Codger | Feb 2012 | #31 | |
tavalon | Feb 2012 | #33 | |
tavalon | Feb 2012 | #36 | |
demosincebirth | Feb 2012 | #35 | |
tavalon | Feb 2012 | #37 | |
demosincebirth | Feb 2012 | #39 | |
![]() ![]() |
progree | Jan 2012 | #4 |
Rhiannon12866 | Jan 2012 | #5 | |
progree | Jan 2012 | #6 | |
Stuart G | Jan 2012 | #7 | |
tavalon | Feb 2012 | #16 | |
progree | Feb 2012 | #24 | |
tavalon | Feb 2012 | #26 | |
NMDemDist2 | Jan 2012 | #8 | |
progree | Jan 2012 | #9 | |
NMDemDist2 | Jan 2012 | #10 | |
progree | Jan 2012 | #11 | |
NMDemDist2 | Jan 2012 | #12 | |
progree | Jan 2012 | #14 | |
Stuart G | Jan 2012 | #13 | |
tavalon | Feb 2012 | #18 | |
Tripod | Feb 2012 | #22 | |
progree | Feb 2012 | #32 | |
tavalon | Feb 2012 | #17 | |
Rhiannon12866 | Feb 2012 | #19 | |
progree | Feb 2012 | #25 | |
NMDemDist2 | Feb 2012 | #28 | |
Stuart G | Feb 2012 | #29 | |
dixiegrrrrl | Feb 2012 | #30 | |
progree | Feb 2012 | #34 | |
mrjackshuman | Apr 2013 | #40 | |
NMDemDist2 | Apr 2013 | #41 | |
cordelia | Apr 2013 | #42 | |
Lil Missy | Apr 2013 | #43 | |
Rhiannon12866 | Apr 2013 | #44 | |
progree | Apr 2013 | #45 | |
cordelia | Apr 2013 | #46 | |
Stuart G | Apr 2013 | #47 | |
Rhiannon12866 | Apr 2013 | #48 | |
progree | Apr 2013 | #49 |
Edit History
Please login to view edit histories.