Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

DanTex

(20,709 posts)
32. It's not the principles, it's the way that they are applied that I object to.
Sat Feb 4, 2012, 07:47 PM
Feb 2012

The "harm principle" is great in theory, but can easily be taken to far. For example, strictly speaking it wouldn't allow the government to regulate who is able to perform surgery via medical licensing. It also wouldn't allow things like social security or medicare, which force people to pay into a collective insurance system even if they might prefer not to. And it wouldn't allow the government to pass laws protecting workers from, say, toxic chemicals in the workplace. And so on.

That kind of stuff might sound great in the abstract, but in reality, it's, yes, childish. You need government in these and other areas of society otherwise things simply wouldn't function.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

"Libertarianism" is a synonym for childish stupidity. baldguy Feb 2012 #1
My mistake. discntnt_irny_srcsm Feb 2012 #7
Interesting mvccd1000 Feb 2012 #8
Right. "Every man for himself", "Screw the other guy" & "Mine, all mine!. Me! Me! Me!" baldguy Feb 2012 #10
As long as we're completely misrepresenting each others' positions... mvccd1000 Feb 2012 #12
You're being facetious. Or should I say "childish"? baldguy Feb 2012 #18
+100 BiggJawn Feb 2012 #39
Day in the Life of Joe Middle-Class Republican krispos42 Feb 2012 #44
Libertarians are just Republicans who want to smoke pot. baldguy Feb 2012 #47
Rampant mischaracterization. Callisto32 Feb 2012 #14
If we're going for any semblance of accuracy here, Dagny Taggard DOES cook and clean AtheistCrusader Feb 2012 #56
The classic quote about Atlas Shrugged: DanTex Feb 2012 #13
One can be a libertarian without worshipping or even being able to stand Rand. Callisto32 Feb 2012 #15
Libertarians are assholes - Ron Paul being the prime example jpak Feb 2012 #20
Are you always this abusive to people you don't know. Callisto32 Feb 2012 #24
Yes he is, juvenile name calling is all he's got rl6214 Feb 2012 #27
many people on DU call republicans assholes, too. provis99 Feb 2012 #54
Ron Paul's a libertarian. Remmah2 Feb 2012 #30
oh, snap! Tuesday Afternoon Feb 2012 #45
I've read and been told that there's a difference, but never bothered to figure out what it was. DanTex Feb 2012 #28
What do you believe to be the foundational philosophy of libertarianism? Callisto32 Feb 2012 #29
It's not the principles, it's the way that they are applied that I object to. DanTex Feb 2012 #32
I agree with you to a point gejohnston Feb 2012 #41
Wow! We agree on something! DanTex Feb 2012 #42
the gun industry is not protected against civil law suits gejohnston Feb 2012 #43
Hmm. Callisto32 Feb 2012 #17
Crying because your prejudices aren't supported by the majority of DU? baldguy Feb 2012 #19
No. Callisto32 Feb 2012 #25
OH! Those poor, helpless Libertarians! (Not to mention anonymous & hypothetical, too!) baldguy Feb 2012 #33
Oh, it absolutely did. Callisto32 Feb 2012 #48
To paraphrase Harry Truman: baldguy Feb 2012 #49
Harry S. Truman gejohnston Feb 2012 #50
He was also a member of the KKK. baldguy Feb 2012 #51
This is interesting: baldguy Feb 2012 #52
I was never offended by it gejohnston Feb 2012 #53
Oh Yeah: since you probably lack the gene to understand it - baldguy Feb 2012 #34
Callisto32, Tuesday Afternoon Feb 2012 #46
At least BaldGuy attempted to start a conversation. ManiacJoe Feb 2012 #2
herewith is jpak's attempt at starting a conversation -- Tuesday Afternoon Feb 2012 #4
Like when he called me an asshole? Callisto32 Feb 2012 #26
yeah, like that -- Tuesday Afternoon Feb 2012 #31
How many shot and dead so far? DonP Feb 2012 #3
Obama "I will not take your shotgun away. I will not take your rifle away. I won't take your handgun jody Feb 2012 #5
Mark Pahrump off my list of places to retire... BiggJawn Feb 2012 #6
But isn't Pahrump where they have all the bordellos? rl6214 Feb 2012 #9
Well, they said he knows what all his neighbours are doing... BiggJawn Feb 2012 #11
What, exactly, do you believe libertarianism to be? Callisto32 Feb 2012 #16
What do I believe Libertarianism to be? BiggJawn Feb 2012 #37
Libertarian societies possible? gejohnston Feb 2012 #40
It's sad to see all the hatred for Librarians in this thread slackmaster Feb 2012 #21
But, but ... they're evil Librarians with guns DonP Feb 2012 #22
Indeed. Angus86 Feb 2012 #35
He loves posting stories where nothing happened. Part of his ritual google dump. DonP Feb 2012 #36
Betcha those books get returned on time...n/t BiggJawn Feb 2012 #38
LOL! jpak Feb 2012 #23
New York times whines about Nevada firearm laws. ileus Feb 2012 #55
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Gun Control & RKBA»Wearing Guns, and Support...»Reply #32