Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Gun Control & RKBA
Showing Original Post only (View all)Man Kills Attacker at Northeast Dallas Convenience Store in Stand-Your-Ground-Style Shooting [View all]
http://blogs.dallasobserver.com/unfairpark/2012/07/man_kills_attacker_at_northeas.phpAbout 4 p.m. yesterday, a man who a witness said appeared drunk, walked into the EZ Trip Food Store above and, according to police, began harassing customers.
Specifically, he slapped one person repeatedly in the face before chasing them from the store. Upon his return, he began punching a second customer in the face which, it soon became clear, was a terrible idea.
The fight moved outside where the customer, who police have not yet identified, pulled out a handgun and shot his assailant. He then waited for police to arrive and was taken into custody without incident. Yesterday afternoon, he was being interviewed by homicide detectives.
<snip>
Witness told the DMN that the shooting was uncalled for, though it's a safe guess the shooter, who has a concealed handgun license, will walk. this seems the prototypical example of the situation covered by Texas' 2007 Stand Your Ground law which "abolishes the duty to retreat if the defendant can show he: (1) had a right to be present at the location where deadly force was used; (2) did not provoke the person against whom deadly force was used; and (3) was not engaged in criminal activity at the time deadly force was used," as summed up by the Baylor Law Review. All of which seems to apply in this case.
<more>
More legalized murder in the Wild West.
yup
84 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Man Kills Attacker at Northeast Dallas Convenience Store in Stand-Your-Ground-Style Shooting [View all]
jpak
Jul 2012
OP
Fine. Take the gun out of the situation. Drunk guy starts beating on innocent person
Common Sense Party
Jul 2012
#66
Shooter DID retreat, drunk chased him, still punching him. Not murder - Self defense.
GreenStormCloud
Jul 2012
#72
Going on a drunken rampage and punching out strangers carries a risk of getting shot
slackmaster
Jul 2012
#3
If he was a diabetic suffering from low blood sugar - would this be justified as well?
jpak
Jul 2012
#5
Sorry about your wife. I hope she has it well-managed. I know several diabetics, both 1s and 2s.
slackmaster
Jul 2012
#10
Yes. A mentally impaired person trying to kill you is still trying to kill you.
NewMoonTherian
Jul 2012
#7
It's just an extremely weak attempt at distraction, something jpak often treats us to
slackmaster
Jul 2012
#11
So you downgrade the criminal's Assault & Battery to "looks at me cross-eyed"?
GreenStormCloud
Jul 2012
#46
Our late Canadian zampolit was *far* better at excusing criminal behavior then you'll ever be:
friendly_iconoclast
Jul 2012
#62
Laugh away while you become the anti-gun poo flinger with a losing track record.
aikoaiko
Jul 2012
#82
From the standpoint of his victim, it doesn't matter what his problem is.
AtheistCrusader
Jul 2012
#57
I'm a type one diabetic as is my son and neither of us has ever punched anyone out when
rl6214
Jul 2012
#69
You might see it differently had the drunk person been one of your children or a person who
ladjf
Jul 2012
#21
You might see it differently if the drunk person had been attacking one of your children or a person
slackmaster
Jul 2012
#24
Both of our statements could well be true. My point was that had the drunkard been well
ladjf
Jul 2012
#25
We had something along those lines happen to us when we first moved into Wash DC
ProgressiveProfessor
Jul 2012
#79
I would probably be remorseful that my child, who I equipped to deal with the world
AtheistCrusader
Jul 2012
#58
So you would have shot the man because you thought that perhaps he might beat or kill
ladjf
Jul 2012
#23
Perhaps I misread the post. I wasn't aware that the shooter was being assaulted. nt
ladjf
Jul 2012
#60
Self defense isn't an exercise of extra-judicial power. It is just self defense. Try again.
AtheistCrusader
Jul 2012
#59
not this Individual's fault that society failed the Drunk. Society needs to put in place
Tuesday Afternoon
Jul 2012
#76
Seems like the usual type of highly suspect sources that the anti-gun religionists use.
Clames
Jul 2012
#56
Why didn't the guy getting beaten by the drunk just respond to him in a strong, authoritative voice?
Common Sense Party
Jul 2012
#68