Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

ellisonz

(27,711 posts)
91. " A healthy fear of the people by the government yields freedom." - or Tyranny.
Tue Jan 10, 2012, 04:57 PM
Jan 2012

“It is better to be feared than loved, if you cannot be both.” - Machiavelli

Given that, how do you justify gun control at all..."to give federal authority of the regulation of private citizens regarding arms" - so there should be no background checks?

Government will intrude as it must, and that does not constitute infringement. BTW - The Declaration of Independence is not law, if it was I could simply complain as a public citizen that the incompetent distribution of arms is allowing criminals to prey upon the people and that my right to good government has been infringed.

"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.--That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed"

I'm really not seeing how the libertarian argument for the weakest government possible is anywhere enshrined in our social contract; it seems to be that the Founders wanted good government, not no government at all, and that your quotation immediately following mine only indicates that such conditions existed under King George III, and not simply as a binary choice instead of a continuum of injustices. Your argument is circular and negates the very clear statements in the Constitution for the general right of the people to safety and general welfare.

Antifederalist claptrap that should be paid no more mind than Harry Potter.

Get over yourself and join your fellow citizens in the advancement of a Republic of the Good.

A common question to both sides... [View all] discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 OP
is there a question in there? Tuesday Afternoon Jan 2012 #1
not in my mind discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #2
you are asking for one's personal definition of the word militia? Tuesday Afternoon Jan 2012 #3
While the militia... discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #4
but, in my mind Tuesday Afternoon Jan 2012 #5
This is precisely my point. discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #6
Definition of "militia" is clear. And, it is not not a bunch of right wingers living in a compound. Hoyt Jan 2012 #7
Discounting.... discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #8
The definition of militia... discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #11
Sorry, but you left out the "well regulated" part. Hoyt Jan 2012 #12
Thank you... discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #13
The founders were a bunch of smart white guys who owned slaves Starboard Tack Jan 2012 #58
regarding the Founders discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #60
What does my use of the subjunctive have to do with prescience. Starboard Tack Jan 2012 #73
Yup discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #84
Well... discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #114
Let me guess, you slept through history class? Spoonman Jan 2012 #87
Let me guess, you slept through english comprehension. Starboard Tack Jan 2012 #89
Feel free to continue Spoonman Jan 2012 #90
If only your "heroes" were around today Starboard Tack Jan 2012 #106
the term has been around for gejohnston Jan 2012 #108
About 100 years. OK Starboard Tack Jan 2012 #112
It has been well documented here what "well regulated" means and it is not what you think rl6214 Jan 2012 #14
Documented by right wing gun groups? There are plenty of scholars who disagree Hoyt Jan 2012 #15
Decided correctly in your mind is the way you want it, not the way the law really is rl6214 Jan 2012 #16
And, the recent decisions haven't accomplished a think in Chicago or DC. Hoyt Jan 2012 #20
That certain local governments fail to comply with the letter and spirit of court decisions ObamaFTW2012 Jan 2012 #22
Apparently the majority in Chicago and DC don't think so. Hoyt Jan 2012 #24
Good thing ObamaFTW2012 Jan 2012 #28
Chicago and DC don't control the nation rl6214 Jan 2012 #29
"Apparently the majority in Chicago and DC don't think so." beevul Jan 2012 #40
Lol, check this.. X_Digger Jan 2012 #26
they think Citizens United v FEC was decided correctly too gejohnston Jan 2012 #18
Well, at least you acknowledge that the SC screws up as they've done recently Hoyt Jan 2012 #19
have fun with that gejohnston Jan 2012 #23
Yes, the ACLU... discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #27
When the situation warrants it, ObamaFTW2012 Jan 2012 #17
We'll buy your interpretation for a moment -- then, leave your guns at home until called. Hoyt Jan 2012 #21
The defense of freedom, ObamaFTW2012 Jan 2012 #25
Well, 96% of population does not feel need to strap a gun on to venture out. Hoyt Jan 2012 #31
As long as they don't try to stop the other 4% (assuming your "96%" is accurate) ObamaFTW2012 Jan 2012 #32
We have the right to do a lot of things, but shouldn't -- like carrying guns in public. Hoyt Jan 2012 #33
Whether or not you consider it something we should not do We_Have_A_Problem Jan 2012 #37
Says you ObamaFTW2012 Jan 2012 #38
What i find to be humorous We_Have_A_Problem Jan 2012 #39
Once again, a pro-gunner trying to compare his poor, pitiful gun plight to THE Civil Rights Movement Hoyt Jan 2012 #48
I am not comparing the defense of my right to be armed in public, ObamaFTW2012 Jan 2012 #51
Actually, I would not have defended a cross burning. Hoyt Jan 2012 #63
Yeah, maybe ObamaFTW2012 Jan 2012 #64
I hear you. But would rather folks don't shoot it out in streets. o Hoyt Jan 2012 #65
I don't want shoot outs in the streets ObamaFTW2012 Jan 2012 #82
Really? ellisonz Jan 2012 #66
Correct ObamaFTW2012 Jan 2012 #81
"Well Regulated" - Without the "Hoyt" spin Spoonman Jan 2012 #41
Define working-order in this context of firearms regulation. n/t ellisonz Jan 2012 #67
I’m certain you feel as though your question Spoonman Jan 2012 #86
I'm certain your patronization doesn't reveal your true character. ellisonz Jan 2012 #92
since women are now allowed to serve in the military Tuesday Afternoon Jan 2012 #76
In UK and USSR gejohnston Jan 2012 #80
We are a country of laws E6-B Jan 2012 #117
Care to share it with us then? jeepnstein Jan 2012 #118
What part of my family isn't my country. ileus Jan 2012 #9
? discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #10
What does "well regulated" mean in your opinion? ellisonz Jan 2012 #30
"well regulated" discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #34
So then we should have effective regulation? n/t ellisonz Jan 2012 #42
Did that point even ruffle your hair as it flew over your head? n/t We_Have_A_Problem Jan 2012 #43
To rephrase the 2A: discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #44
Means exactly what it says - "well regulated" ellisonz Jan 2012 #46
Your link discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #47
Read the whole thing and tell me what your impression is... ellisonz Jan 2012 #52
In the Swiss model gejohnston Jan 2012 #55
I think this is honestly closer to what the Founders meant... ellisonz Jan 2012 #68
That was the idea to have such an army gejohnston Jan 2012 #70
... ellisonz Jan 2012 #71
bold does not improve gejohnston Jan 2012 #78
Depends how you define people... ellisonz Jan 2012 #79
Most of them were West Germany gejohnston Jan 2012 #85
I'll get back to you on that as well as my reading of Stevens, et al... discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #56
Done. ellisonz Jan 2012 #69
I guess you missed this bit, eh? X_Digger Jan 2012 #72
Your argument is incongruous. ellisonz Jan 2012 #74
No, your whining about 'well-regulated' has been dealt with. X_Digger Jan 2012 #83
the people discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #88
" A healthy fear of the people by the government yields freedom." - or Tyranny. ellisonz Jan 2012 #91
How Machiavellian of you to provide that quote ;) discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #93
At the same time the Constitution clearly makes treason a punishable offense... ellisonz Jan 2012 #94
"Can we not add to that list?" discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #96
Known member of a known hate group or criminal organization... ellisonz Jan 2012 #97
Sure... discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #98
So you oppose gang injunctions? ellisonz Jan 2012 #99
I'm with the supreme court in Chicago v. Morales X_Digger Jan 2012 #102
I disagree - their activity in and of itself is intimidating conduct. ellisonz Jan 2012 #103
*gasp* you agree with Scalia?!? X_Digger Jan 2012 #104
Twisting. n/t ellisonz Jan 2012 #105
In a word... discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #113
so you want to base a regulation gejohnston Jan 2012 #100
You're saying opposition to arming... ellisonz Jan 2012 #101
and who defines it gejohnston Jan 2012 #107
Not even going to try to unpack the meaning/facts of any of that...n/t ellisonz Jan 2012 #109
simply pointing out gejohnston Jan 2012 #110
Well... ellisonz Jan 2012 #111
To further elaborate... discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #45
regulate Tuesday Afternoon Jan 2012 #53
Agreed. n/t discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #59
Post removed Post removed Jan 2012 #35
Milita means an irregular group of civilians voluntarily DWC Jan 2012 #36
heh. irregular, nice choice of adjective there Tuesday Afternoon Jan 2012 #75
So, why doesn't the Constitution start with, "We the militia . . . . ." instead of "we the people." Hoyt Jan 2012 #49
Because the PEOPLE compose the militia. So, why don't... discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #50
People are a set, (or group) Tuesday Afternoon Jan 2012 #54
All squirrels are mammals.. X_Digger Jan 2012 #57
Are squirrels in the militia? Sounds to me it's "people" the way you HAVE TO DEFINE IT Hoyt Jan 2012 #61
I bet that point didn't even ruffle your hair as it went right by. n/t X_Digger Jan 2012 #62
Hopefully, we'll get a Supreme Court in the next few years that is not so right wing. -- Tuesday Afternoon Jan 2012 #77
It's all one big right-wing conspiracy... ellisonz Jan 2012 #95
" I ask sir, what is a militia? DWC Jan 2012 #115
For a modern spin: discntnt_irny_srcsm Jan 2012 #116
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Gun Control & RKBA»A common question to both...»Reply #91