Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

CrispyQ

(36,457 posts)
37. "The Great Alone" by Kristin Hannah
Mon Nov 28, 2022, 12:15 PM
Nov 2022


Most people gave this book a great review. Not me.

The story takes place in the 70s & is about a dysfunctional family that moves to Alaska & the challenges of living in the wild & the dark. The POV character is their 14 year old daughter.

There are so many scenes of domestic abuse in this book they should have put a trigger warning on the cover. The antagonist is a Vietnam POW survivor who beats his wife & eventually his daughter, too. The author gives no history of the man, except an occasional comment by his wife that he wasn't always like this. Because he has ZERO redeeming qualities, he comes across as a one-dimensional monster.

The story could have been saved, possibly, except the wife was stupid. Unlike a lot of abused women, she had family & friends who wanted to help her escape her situation, but she refused & continued to live with the creep, risking her daughter's well-being.

Then there was a daughter, who was a victim of circumstance, but by the end of the book she never elevated above that. She too, behaved stupidly when she was older & had to depend on others to get her out of a bad situation.

I have 12 books on hold at the library & hope at least one of them comes in today!



Just finished "The Lineup," by Otto Penzler. Excellent! SheltieLover Nov 2022 #1
The Lineup sounds fantastic! hermetic Nov 2022 #2
Omg, it is! SheltieLover Nov 2022 #13
"He's Gone" by Deb Coletti bif Nov 2022 #3
Sounds interesting hermetic Nov 2022 #6
Back to an old "stand by". Grisham Paper Roses Nov 2022 #4
I love Grisham's work! SheltieLover Nov 2022 #8
Reading on tablet Timewas Nov 2022 #24
That is a good one. hermetic Nov 2022 #9
Fort Worth offers e-books and no longer charges late fees yellowdogintexas Nov 2022 #26
Question for you avid readers: cilla4progress Nov 2022 #5
I don't worry about forgetting or missing things. SheltieLover Nov 2022 #10
Cool. cilla4progress Nov 2022 #17
I do that, too. SheltieLover Nov 2022 #18
YMMV hermetic Nov 2022 #14
Keeping a list is a great idea! SheltieLover Nov 2022 #19
one of the handy things about ebooks from Amazon: you can mark them 'read' yellowdogintexas Nov 2022 #27
I have thought about writing up a brief cilla4progress Nov 2022 #22
That could be fun hermetic Nov 2022 #32
Oh, snap! cilla4progress Nov 2022 #33
Mike Lawson's Joe DeMarco series. cbabe Nov 2022 #7
Sounds great! SheltieLover Nov 2022 #11
Those sound really good. hermetic Nov 2022 #15
"We Begin at the End" by Chris Whitaker The King of Prussia Nov 2022 #12
Sounds quite good. hermetic Nov 2022 #16
These 2 characters are explained in "The Lineup" as well SheltieLover Nov 2022 #20
"The Engines of God" by Jack McDevitt Jeebo Nov 2022 #21
Mmm, intriguing.. hermetic Nov 2022 #23
Stephen King Timewas Nov 2022 #25
A new one hermetic Nov 2022 #31
I finished the Stone Thieves and the Honorable Order of Inventors yellowdogintexas Nov 2022 #28
I am currently reading The Book Woman of Troublesome Creek yellowdogintexas Nov 2022 #29
That is a good read. hermetic Nov 2022 #30
I had read several articles about them yellowdogintexas Nov 2022 #36
I read both of them & enjoyed them quite a bit. CrispyQ Nov 2022 #38
Just finished reading Barbara Kingsolver's latest, japple Nov 2022 #34
Oh lovely! hermetic Nov 2022 #35
"The Great Alone" by Kristin Hannah CrispyQ Nov 2022 #37
I just finished Louise Penny's new book, KatyaR Nov 2022 #39
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Fiction»What Fiction are you read...»Reply #37