Religion

libodem

(19,288 posts)

1. I like the idea of a common community

Fri Nov 22, 2013, 08:58 PM

Nov 2013

Gathering to celebrate the milestones in our lives. I appreciate the concept of a baby dedication, christening, or baptism ceremony. I like the idea of a childhood right of passing like confirmation. I think an adolescent passage like a bar and bat mitzvahs is cool. A place for weddings so everyone is celebrating the union of a new couple. And a forum for a funeral. I think human beans need ceremony and some rituals to make their lives complete.

I don't really think it takes religion to make us be moral and ethical, by way of the fear of fire and brimstone. But why not have lessons in morality for kids?

I think Bible study for the learning of Hebrew history and the life and times if Jesus is a must for a decent grip on western civilization.

Church politics, practices, and doctrines, I'm kind of a meh attitude since I'm mostly a nonbeliever in the old testament version of the deity.

If we must personify the deity, I say GO GODDESS!

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

35 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

What's an objective assessment of the benefits and harms of religion overall, in your view? [View all] pinto Nov 2013 OP

I like the idea of a common community libodem Nov 2013 #1

Yeah. I think community, in one form or another, can be a benefit. pinto Nov 2013 #2

That's a big question, and lots of research have gone toward answering it. To be objective, dimbear Nov 2013 #3

See some of your your points, yet does religion go hand in hand with poverty? Economic policy, pinto Nov 2013 #4

It's not a simple question. That's why there's so much research in the area. One could look to dimbear Nov 2013 #5

While I agree with you in general Promethean Nov 2013 #7

Another explanation is that those who are impoverished are often without hope cbayer Nov 2013 #8

I disagree that religion necessarily represents a "dumbing down" of adherents. pinto Nov 2013 #18

Lots of "harm done" by belief in miracles, spirits: magical thinking cripples people Brettongarcia Nov 2013 #9

Religion produces poverty? cbayer Nov 2013 #10

Monks often explicitly spoke against material "riches"; took vows of "Poverty, Chastity, Obedience" Brettongarcia Nov 2013 #11

Well monks and priests make that as a choice. cbayer Nov 2013 #12

Goodman's hypothesis Brettongarcia Nov 2013 #13

Who is he and what kind of research does he propose? cbayer Nov 2013 #14

Good observations, caveats. Aside from Prosperity Gospel though? Consider Asceticism, Spirituality Brettongarcia Nov 2013 #15

Delusions are generally a sign of mental illness. cbayer Nov 2013 #17

Assertions that "whosoever asks" can literally walk on water, are delusional/fantasy; easily shown Brettongarcia Nov 2013 #22

If one is a literalist, that might be true. cbayer Nov 2013 #23

If the Bible is not literally true, but only metaphorically, it loses much claim to truth Brettongarcia Nov 2013 #25

I don't think it is necessarily an all or none thing, and cbayer Nov 2013 #26

Would you and Psych. say a person who thinks he can literally walk on water, is not delusional? Brettongarcia Nov 2013 #27

I have said multiple times that that person would most likely be deemed delusional, cbayer Nov 2013 #29

Many believe this delusion of miraculous powers. As for the rest? "Spiritual" persons...? Brettongarcia Nov 2013 #30

Some do believe that, but they don't encompass all religious believers. cbayer Nov 2013 #31

In some ways, earth has often been a fairly grim place for most of humanity, struggle4progress Nov 2013 #6

There is no question that religion has both benefits and harms, imo. cbayer Nov 2013 #16

Broad brush statements about anything are generally pointless, imho. pinto Nov 2013 #19

What good has religion done skepticscott Nov 2013 #20

I'll offer my post below as one example. MLK often spoke from a faith based perspective. pinto Nov 2013 #24

Oh, YOU doubt it? skepticscott Nov 2013 #34

No, as I said, MLK's position played a part in his advocacy for civil rights and it echoed with many pinto Nov 2013 #35

Religion's role in secular politics shows both sides of benefit and harm. In different ways. pinto Nov 2013 #21

I see few benefits of religion. longship Nov 2013 #28

Christians should stay in the closet to do their praying just as Jesus advised. lumpy Nov 2013 #32

Staying "in the closet" has such a negative connotation. cbayer Nov 2013 #33